,,*APT] #BB
  ,:O 9 ! RA9B[ C DRAW ! L9E ": !
VIOLET T9T 5DS &! ORANGE T9T 2G9S8
,4T9CTLY WE SEE ! DI6];E (! COLORS1 B
": EXACTLY DOES ! "O F/ BL5D+LY 5T]
96! O!R8 ,S ) SAN;Y & 9SAN;Y4 ,9
PRON\NC$ CASES "! IS NO "Q AB !M4 ,B
9 "S SUPPOS$ CASES1 9 V>I\S DEGREES
SUPPOS$LY LESS PRON\NC$1 6DRAW !
EXACT L9E ( DEM>K,N FEW W "UTAKE ?O0'
=A FEE "S PROFES.NAL EXP]TS W4 ,"! IS
NO?+ NAMA# B T "S M5 W "UTAKE 6D X =

PAY4
  ,:E!R ,CAPTA9 ,V]E1 Z ! ,SURGEON
PROFES.N,Y & PRIVATELY SURMIS$1 0
RE,Y ! SU45 VICTIM ( ANY DEGREE (
AB]R,N1 "O M/ DET]M9E = HMF 0S* LI<T
Z ? N>RATIVE MAY AF=D4
  ,T ! UNHAPPY EV5T : HAS BE5 N>RAT$
CD N H HAPP5$ AT A WORSE JUNCTURE 0 B
TOO TRUE4 ,= X 0 CLOSE ON ! HEEL (!
SUPPRESS$ 9SURREC;NS1 AN AF"T V
CRITICAL 6NAVAL AU?OR;Y1 DEM&+ F E
,5GLI% SEA-COMM&] TWO QUALITIES N
R1DILY 9T]FUSA#- PRUD;E & RIG\R4
,MOREOV] "! 0 "S?+ CRUCIAL 9 ! CASE4
  ,9 ! JU7L]Y ( CIRCUM/.ES PREC$+ &
ATT5D+ ! EV5T ON BO>D ! ,9DOMITA#1 &
9 ! LI<T ( T M>TIAL CODE ":BY X 0
=M,Y 6BE JUDG$1 9NOC;E & GUILT
P]SONIFI$ 9 ,CLA7>T & ,BUDD 9 E6ECT
*ANG$ PLACES4 ,9 A LEGAL VIEW !
APP>5T VICTIM (! TRAG$Y 0 HE :O _H
S"\ 6VICTIMIZE A MAN BLAME.S2 &!
9DISPUTA# DE$ (! LATT]1 NAV,Y REG>D$1
3/ITUT$ ! MO/ HE9\S ( MILIT>Y CRIMES4
,YET M4 ,! ESS5TIAL "R & WR;G 9VOLV$

9 ! MATT]1 ! CLE>] T MI<T BE1 S M* !
WORSE =! RESPONSIBIL;Y (A LOYAL SEA-
-M&] 9ASM* Z HE 0 N AU?ORIZ$ 6DET]M9E
! MATT] ON T PRIMITIVE BASIS4
  ,SMALL WOND] !N T ! ,9DOMITA#'S
,CAPTA91 ?\< 9 G5]AL A MAN ( RAPID
DECI.N1 FELT T CIRCUMSPECT;S N LESS
?AN PROMPTITUDE 0 NEC4 ,UNTIL HE CD
DECIDE ^U 8 C\RSE1 & 9 EA* DETAIL2 &
N ONLY S1 B UNTIL ! 3CLUD+ M1SURE 0
^U ! PO9T ( 2+ 5ACT$1 HE DEEM$ X
ADVISA#1 9 VIEW ( ALL ! CIRCUM/.ES1
6GU>D Z M* Z POSSI# AG/ PUBLIC;Y4 ,"H
HE MAY OR MAY N H ]R$4 ,C]TA9 X IS1
H["E1 T SUBSEQU5TLY 9 ! 3FID5TIAL
TALK ( M ?AN "O OR TWO GUN-ROOMS &
CAB9S HE 0 N A LL CRITICIZ$ 0"S
(FIC]S1 A FACT IMPUT$ 0HIS FRS &
VEHE;TLY 0HIS C\S91 ,JACK ,D5TON1
6PROFES.NAL J1L\SY ( ,/>RY ,V]E4 ,"S
IMAG9ATIVE GR.D = 9VIDI\S -;T "! WAS4
,! MA9T5.E ( SECRECY 9 ! MATT]1 !
3F9+ ALL K ( X =A "T 6! PLACE ": !
HOMICIDE O3URR$1 ! QU>T]-DECK CAB92 9
^! "PICUL>S LURK$ "S RESEMBL.E 6!

POLICY ADOPT$ 9 ^? TRAG$IES (! PALACE
: H O3URR$ M ?AN ONCE 9 ! CAPITAL
F.D$ 0,PET] ! ,B>B>IAN4
  ,! CASE 9DE$ 0 S* T FA9 WD !
,9DOMITA#'S ,CAPTA9 H DEF]R$ TAK+ ANY
AC;N :AT"E RESPECT+ X FUR!R ?AN 6KEEP
! ,=ETOPMAN A CLOSE PRISON] TILL !
%IP REJO9$ ! SQUADRON1 & !N SUBMITT+
! MATT] 6! JUDGE;T ( 8 ,ADMIRAL4
  ,B A TRUE MILIT>Y (FIC] IS 9 "O
"PICUL> L A TRUE MONK4 ,N ) M ( SELF-
ABNEG,N W ! LATT] KEEP 8 V[S (
MONA/IC OB$I;E ?AN ! =M] 8 V[S (
ALLEGI.E 6M>TIAL DUTY4
  ,FEEL+ T UN.S QK AC;N 0 TAK5 ON X1
! DE$ (! ,=ETOPMAN1 S SOON Z X %D 2
"KN ON ! GUN DECKS1 WD T5D 6AWAK5 ANY
SLUMB]+ EMB]S (! ,NORE AM;G ! CREW1 A
S5SE (! URG5CY (! CASE OV]RUL$ 9
,CAPTA9 ,V]E E O!R 3SID],N4 ,B ?O0' A
3SCI5TI\S 4CIPL9>IAN1 HE 0 NO LOV] (
AU?OR;Y = M]E AU?OR;Y'S SAKE4 ,V F> 0
HE F EMBRAC+ OPPORTUNITIES =
MONOPOLIZ+ 6HMF ! P]ILS ( MORAL
RESPONSIBIL;Y1 N"O AT L1/ T CD

PROP]LY 2 REF]R$ 6AN (FICIAL SUP]IOR1
OR %>$ ) HM 0HIS (FICIAL EQUALS OR
EV5 SUBORD9ATES4 ,S ?9K+1 HE 0 GLAD X
WD N 2 AT V>I.E ) USAGE 6TURN ! MATT]
OV] 6A SUMM>Y C\RT ( 8 [N (FIC]S1
RES]V+ 6HMF Z ! "O ON :OM ! ULTIMATE
A3.TABIL;Y WD RE/1 ! "R ( MA9TA9+ A
SUP]VI.N ( X1 OR =M,Y OR 9=M,Y
9T]POS+ AT NE$4 ,ACLY A DRUM-H1D C\RT
0 SUMM>ILY 3V5$1 HE ELECT+ !
9DIVIDUALS -POS+ X1 ! ,F/ ,LIEUT5ANT1
! ,CAPTA9 ( ,M>9ES1 &! ,SAIL+ ,MA/]4
  ,9 ASSOCIAT+ AN (FIC] ( M>9ES )!
SEA-LIEUT5ANTS 9 A CASE HAV+ 6D )A
SAILOR1 ! ,-M&] P]H DEVIAT$ F G5]AL
CU/OM4 ,HE 0 PROMPT$ "!TO 0!
CIRCUM/.E T HE TOOK T SOLDI] 6BE A
JUDICI\S P]SON1 ?"\;L1 & N ALT 9CAPA#
( GRAPPL+ )A DI6ICULT CASE UNPREC$5T$
9 8 PRIOR EXP]I;E4 ,YET EV5 Z 6HM HE
0 N )\T "S LAT5T MISGIV+1 = )AL HE 0
AN EXTREMELY GDNATUR$ MAN1 AN 5JOY] (
8 D9N]1 A S.D SLEEP]1 & 9CL9$
6OBES;Y1 A MAN :O ?O0' HE WD ALW
MA9TA9 8 MANHOOD 9 BATTLE MI<T N

PROVE ALT RELIA# 9 A MORAL DILEMMA
9VOLV+ AU<T (! TRAGIC4 ,Z 6! ,F/
,LIEUT5ANT &! ,SAIL+ ,MA/]1 ,CAPTA9
,V]E CD N B 2 AW>E T ?\< H"O/
NATURES1 ( APPROV$ GALLANTRY ^U
O3A.N1 _! 9TELLIG;E 0 MO/LY 3F9$ 6!
MATT] ( ACTIVE S1MAN%IP &! FI<T+
DEM&S ( _! PROFES.N4 ,! C\RT 0 HELD 9
! SAME CAB9 ": ! UN=TUNATE A6AIR _H
TAK5 PLACE4 ,? CAB91 ! ,-M&]'S1
EMBRAC$ ! 5TIRE >EA "U ! POOPDECK4
,AFT1 & ON EI SIDE1 0 A SMALL /ATE-
ROOM2 ! "O ROOM TEMPOR>ILY A JAIL &!
O!R A D1D-H\SE1 &A YET SMALL] -"P;T
L1V+ A SPACE 2T1 EXP&+ =W>D 96A GDLY
OBL;G ( L5G? CO9CID+ )! %IP'S B1M4 ,A
SKYLI<T ( MOD]ATE DIM5.N 0 OV]H1D &
AT EA* 5D (! OBL;G SPACE 7 TWO SA%$
PORT-HOLE W9D[S EASILY 3V]TI# BACK
96EMBRASURES = %ORT C>RONADES4
  ,ALL 2+ QKLY 9 R1DI;S1 ,BILLY ,BUDD
0 >RAIGN$1 ,CAPTA9 ,V]E NECESS>ILY
APPE>+ Z ! SOLE WIT;S 9 ! CASE1 & Z
S*1 TEMPOR>ILY S9K+ 8 RANK1 ?\<
S+UL>LY MA9TA9+ X 9 A MATT] APP>5TLY

TRIVIAL1 "NLY1 T HE TE/IFI$ F ! %IP'S
W1!R-SIDE1 ) T OBJECT HAV+ CAUS$ !
C\RT 6SIT ON ! LEE-SIDE4 ,3CISELY HE
N>RAT$ ALL T _H L$ UP 6! CATA/ROPHE1
OMITT+ NO?+ 9 ,CLA7>T'S A3US,N &
DEPOS+ Z 6! MANN] 9 : ! PRISON] _H
RCVD X4 ,AT ? TE/IMONY ! ?REE (FIC]S
GL.ED ) NO LL SURPRISE AT ,BILLY
,BUDD1 ! LA/ MAN !Y WD H SUSPECT$ EI
(! MUT9\S DESIGN ALLEG$ 0,CLA7>T OR !
UND5IA# DE$ HE HMF _H D"O4
  ,! ,F/ ,LIEUT5ANT1 TAK+ JUDICIAL
PRIMACY & TURN+ T[>D ! PRISON]1 SD1
8,CAPTA9 ,V]E HAS SPOK54 ,IS X OR IS
X N Z ,CAPTA9 ,V]E SAYS80 ,9 RESPONSE
CAME SYLLA#S N S M* IMP$$ 9 ! UTT].E
Z MI<T H BE5 ANTICIPAT$4 ,!Y 7 ^!3
8,CAPTA9 ,V]E TELLS ! TRU?4 ,X IS J Z
,CAPTA9 ,V]E SAYS1 B X IS N Z !
,MA/]-AT->MS SD4 ,I H EAT5 ! ,K+'S
BR1D & ,I AM TRUE 6! ,K+40
  8,I 2LIEVE Y1 MY MAN10 SD ! WIT;S1
8 VOICE 9DICAT+ A SUPPRESS$ EMO;N N
O!RWISE 2TRAY$4
  8,GOD W B.S Y = T1 ,YR ,HONOR60 N

)\T /AMM]+ SD ,BILLY1 & ALL B BROKE
D[N4 ,B IMMLY 0 RECALL$ 6SELF-3TROL
0ANO!R "Q1 6: )! SAME EMO;NAL
DI6ICULTY ( UTT].E HE SD1 8,NO1 "! 0
NO MALICE 2T U4 ,I N"E BORE MALICE
AG/ ! ,MA/]-AT->MS4 ,I AM SORRY T HE
IS D1D4 ,I DID N M1N 6KILL HM4 ,CD ,I
H US$ MY T;GUE ,I WD N H /RUCK HM4 ,B
HE F\LLY LI$ 6MY FACE & 9 PRES;E ( MY
,CAPTA91 & ,I _H 6SAY "S?+1 & ,I CD
ONLY SAY X )A BL[1 ,GOD HELP ME60
  ,9 ! IMPULSIVE ABV-BO>D MANN] (!
FRANK "O1 ! C\RT SAW 3FIRM$ ALL T 0
IMPLI$ 9 ^WS T J PREVI\SLY _H P]PLEX$
!M1 -+ Z !Y DID F ! TE/IFI] 6! TRAG$Y
& PROMPTLY FOLL[+ ,BILLY'S IMPAS.N$
4CLAIM] ( MUT9\S 9T5T- ,CAPTA9 ,V]E'S
^WS1 8,I 2LIEVE Y1 MY MAN40
  ,NEXT X 0 ASK$ ( HM :E!R HE KNEW (
OR SUSPECT$ AU<T SAVOR+ ( 9CIPI5T
TR\# 7M1N+ MUT9Y1 ?O0' ! EXPLICIT T]M
0 AVOID$7 GO+ ON 9 ANY SEC;N (! %IP'S
-PANY4
  ,! REPLY L+]$4 ,? 0 NATUR,Y IMPUT$
0! C\RT 6! SAME VOCAL EMB>RASS;T : _H

RET>D$ OR OB/RUCT$ PREVI\S ANSW]S4 ,B
9 MA9 X 0 O!RWISE "H2 ! "Q IMMLY
RECALL+ 6,BILLY'S M9D ! 9T]VIEW )!
AFGU>DSMAN 9 ! =E-*A9S4 ,B AN 9NATE
REPUGN.E 6PLAY+ A "P AT ALL APPROA*+
T ( AN 9=M] AG/ "O'S [N %IPMATES- !
SAME ]R+ S5SE ( UN9/RUCT$ HONOR : _H
/OOD 9 ! WAY ( 8 REPORT+ ! MATT] AT !
"T ?\< Z A LOYAL MAN-(-W>-MAN X 0
9CUMB5T ON HM1 & FAILURE S 6D IF *>G$
AG/ HM & PROV51 WD H SUBJECT$ HM 6!
H1VIE/ ( P5ALTIES2 ?1 )! BL FEEL+ N[
HIS1 T NO?+ RE,Y 0 2+ HAT*$1 PREVAIL$
) HM4 ,:5 ! ANSW] CAME X 0 A
NEGATIVE4
  8,"O "Q M10 SD ! (FIC] ( M>9ES N[
F/ SP1K+ &)A TR\#D E>NE/;S4 8,Y TELL
U T :AT ! ,MA/]-AT->MS SD AG/ Y 0 A
LIE4 ,N[ :Y %D HE H S LI$1 S
MALICI\SLY LI$1 S9CE Y DCL "! 0 NO
MALICE 2T Y80
  ,AT T "Q UN9T5;N,Y T\*+ ON A _SUAL
SPH]E :OLLY OBSCURE 6,BILLY'S ?"\S1
HE 0 NONPLUSS$1 EV9C+ A 3FU.N 9DE$ T
"S OBS]V]S1 S* Z C R1DILY 2 IMAG9$1

WD H 3/RU$ 969VOLUNT>Y EVID;E ( HI45
GUILT4 ,N"E!.S HE /ROVE "S WAY
6ANSW]1 B ALL AT ONCE REL9QUI%$ ! VA9
5D1VOR1 AT ! SAME "T TURN+ AN APP1L+
GL.E T[>DS ,CAPTA9 ,V]E Z DEEM+ HM 8
BE/ HELP] & FR4 ,CAPTA9 ,V]E :O _H
BE5 S1T$ =A "T ROSE 6HIS FEET1
A4RESS+ ! 9T]ROGATOR4 8,! "Q Y PUT
6HM -ES NATUR,Y 5\<4 ,B H[ C HE "RLY
ANSW] X8 OR ANYBODY ELSE8 UN.S 9DE$ X
2 HE :O LIES )9 "!10 DESIGNAT+ !
-"P;T ": LAY ! CORPSE4 8,B ! PR"O "O
"! W N RISE 6\R SUMMONS4 ,9 E6ECT1
?O0'1 Z X SEEMS 6ME1 ! PO9T Y MAKE IS
H>DLY MAT]IAL4 ,Q ASIDE F ANY 3CEIVA#
MOTIVE ACTUAT+ ! ,MA/]-AT->MS1 &
IRRESPECTIVE (! PROVOC,N 6! BL[1 A
M>TIAL C\RT M/ NE$S 9 ! PRES5T CASE
3F9E XS ATT5;N 6! BL['S 3SEQU;E1 :
3SEQU;E JU/LY IS 6BE DEEM$ N O!RWISE
?AN Z ! /RIK]'S DE$40
  ,? UTT].E1 ! FULL SIGNIFIC.E ( : X
0 N AT ALL LIKELY T ,BILLY TOOK IN1
N"E!.S CAUS$ HM 6TURN A WI/;L
9T]ROGATIVE LOOK T[>D ! SP1K]1 A LOOK

9 XS DUMB EXPRESSIVE;S N UNLIKE T : A
DOG ( G5]\S BRE$ MI<T TURN ^U 8 MA/]
SEEK+ 9 8 FACE "S ELUCID,N (A PREVI\S
GE/URE AMBIGU\S 6! CAN9E 9TELLIG;E4
,NOR 0 ! SAME UTT].E )\T M>K$ E6ECT
^U ! ?REE (FIC]S1 M ESPECI,Y !
SOLDI]4 ,C\*$ 9 X SEEM$ 6!M A M1N+
UNANTICIPAT$1 9VOLV+ A PREJUDGE;T ON
! SP1K]'S "P4 ,X S]V$ 6AUG;T A M5TAL
4TURB.E PREVI\SLY EVID5T 5\<4
  ,! SOLDI] ONCE M SPOKE2 9 A T"O (
SU7E/IVE DUBIETY A4RESS+ AT ONCE 8
ASSOCIATES & ,CAPTA9 ,V]E3 8,NOBODY
IS PRES5T- N"O (! %IP'S -PANY1 ,I
M1N- :O MI<T %$ LAT]AL LI<T1 IF ANY
IS 6BE _H1 ^U :AT REMA9S MY/]I\S 9 ?
MATT]40
  8,T IS ?"\;LLY PUT10 SD ,CAPTA9
,V]E2 8,I SEE YR DRIFT4 ,AY1 "! IS A
MY/]Y2 B1 6USE A ,SCRIPTURAL PHRASE1
X IS 'A MY/]Y ( 9IQU;Y10' A MATT] =
PSY*OLOGIC !OLOGIANS 64CUSS4 ,B :AT
HAS A MILIT>Y C\RT 6D ) X8 ,N 6ADD T
= U ANY POSSI# 9VE/IG,N ( X IS CUT (F
0! LA/+ T;GUE-TIE (- HM- 9 YOND]10 AG

DESIGNAT+ ! MORTU>Y /ATEROOM4 8,!
PRISON]'S DE$1- ) T AL"O WE H 6D40
  ,6?1 & "PICUL>LY ! CLOS+ REIT],N1 !
M>9E SOLDI] "K+ N H[ APTLY 6REPLY1
SADLY AB/A9$ F SAY+ AU<T4 ,! ,F/
,LIEUT5ANT :O AT ! \TSET _H N
UNNATUR,Y ASSUM$ PRIMACY 9 ! C\RT1 N[
OV]RUL+LY 9/RUCT$ 0A GL.E F ,CAPTA9
,V]E1 A GL.E M E6ECTIVE ?AN ^WS1
RESUM$ T PRIMACY4 ,TURN+ 6! PRISON]1
8,BUDD10 HE SD1 & SC>CE 9 EQUA# T"OS1
8,BUDD1 IF Y H AU<T FUR!R 6SAY = YRF1
SAY X N[40
  ,^U ? ! "Y SAILOR TURN$ ANO!R QK
GL.E T[>D ,CAPTA9 ,V]E2 !N1 Z TAK+ A
H9T F T ASPECT1 A H9T 3FIRM+ 8 [N
9/9CT T SIL;E 0 N[ BE/1 REPLI$ 6!
,LIEUT5ANT1 8,I H SD ALL1 ,SIR40
  ,! M>9E- ! SAME :O _H BE5 ! S5T9EL
)\T ! CAB9-DOOR AT ! "T T ! ,=ETOPMAN
FOLL[$ 0! ,MA/]-AT->MS1 5T]$ X- HE1
/&+ 0! SAILOR "?\T ^! JUDICIAL
PROCE$+S1 0 N[ DIRECT$ 6TAKE HM BACK
6! AF -"P;T ORIG9,Y ASSIGN$ 6!
PRISON] & 8 CU/ODIAN4 ,Z ! TWA9

4APPE>$ F VIEW1 ! ?REE (FIC]S Z "PI,Y
LIB]AT$ F "S 9W>D 3/RA9T ASSOCIAT$ )
,BILLY'S M]E PRES;E1 SIMULTANE\SLY
/IRR$ 9 _! S1TS4 ,!Y EX*ANG$ LOOKS (
TR\#D 9DECI.N1 YET FEEL+ T DECIDE !Y
M/ & )\T L;G DELAY4 ,Z = ,CAPTA9
,V]E1 HE =! "T /OOD UNCONSCI\SLY ) 8
BACK T[>D !M1 APP>5TLY 9 "O ( 8 ABS5T
FITS1 GAZ+ \ F A SA%$ PORT-HOLE
6W9DW>D ^U ! MONOTON\S BLANK (!
TWILI<T SEA4 ,B ! C\RT'S SIL;E 3T9U+1
BROK5 ONLY AT MO;TS 0BRIEF 3SULT,NS 9
L[ E>NE/ T"OS1 ? SEEM$ 6>M HM &
5]GIZE HM4 ,TURN+1 HE TO-&-FRO PAC$ !
CAB9 A?W>T2 9 ! RETURN+ ASC5T
6W9DW>D1 CLIMB+ ! SLANT DECK 9 !
%IP'S LEE ROLL2 )\T "K+ X SYMBOLIZ+
?US 9 8 AC;N A M9D RESOLUTE 6SURM.T
DI6ICULTIES EV5 IF AG/ PRIMITIVE
9/9CTS /R;G Z ! W9D &! SEA4 ,PRES5TLY
HE CAME 6A /& 2F ! ?REE4 ,AF SCANN+
_! FACES HE /OOD LESS Z MU/]+ 8 ?"\S
= EXPRES.N1 ?AN Z "O 9LY DELIB]AT+ H[
BE/ 6PUT !M 6WELL-M1N+ M5 N
9TELLECTU,Y MATURE1 M5 ) :OM X 0 NEC

6DEMON/RATE C]TA9 PR9CIPLES T 7
AXIOMS 6HMF4 ,SIMIL> IMPATI;E Z
6TALK+ IS P]H "O R1SON T DET]S "S
M9DS F A4RESS+ ANY POPUL> ASSEMBLIES4
  ,:5 SP1K HE DID1 "S?+ BO? 9 !
SUB/.E ( :AT HE SD & 8 MANN] ( SAY+
X1 %[$ ! 9FLU;E ( UN%>$ /UDIES
MODIFY+ & TEMP]+ ! PRACTICAL TRA9+ (
AN ACTIVE C>E]4 ,?1 AL;G ) 8
PHRASEOLOGY1 N[ & !N 0 SU7E/IVE (!
GR.DS ":ON RE/$ T IMPUT,N (A C]TA9
P$ANTRY SOCI,Y ALLEG$ AG/ HM 0C]TA9
NAVAL M5 ( :OLLY PRACTICAL CA/1
CAPTA9S :O N"E!.S WD FRANKLY 3C$E T
,8 ,MAJE/Y'S ,NAVY MU/]$ NO M E6ICI5T
(FIC] ( _! GRADE ?AN ,/>RY ,V]E4
  ,:AT HE SD 0 6? E6ECT3 8,HI!RTO ,I
H BE5 B ! WIT;S1 LL M2 & ,I %D H>DLY
?9K N[ 6TAKE ANO!R T"O1 T ( YR
COADJUTOR1 =! "T1 DID ,I N P]CV 9 Y1-
AT ! CRISIS TOO- A TR\#D HESITANCY1
PROCE$+1 ,I D\BT N1 F ! CLA% (
MILIT>Y DUTY ) MORAL SCRUPLE- SCRUPLE
VITALIZ$ 0-PAS.N4 ,=! -PAS.N1 H[ C ,I
O!RWISE ?AN %>E X8 ,B1 M9D;L ( P>AM.T

OBLIG,NS ,I /RIVE AG/ SCRUPLES T MAY
T5D 65]VATE DECI.N4 ,N1 G5TLEM51 T ,I
HIDE F MYF T ! CASE IS AN EXCEP;NAL
"O4 ,SPECULATIVELY REG>D$1 X WELL
MI<T 2 REF]R$ 6A JURY ( CASUI/S4 ,B =
U "H ACT+ N Z CASUI/S OR MORALI/S1 X
IS A CASE PRACTICAL1 & "U M>TIAL LAW
PRACTIC,Y 6BE D1LT )4
  8,B YR SCRUPLES3 D !Y MOVE Z 9 A
DUSK8 ,*ALL5GE !M4 ,MAKE !M ADV.E &
DCL !MVS4 ,-E N[3 D !Y IMPORT "S?+ L
?8 ,IF1 M9D.S ( PALLIAT+ CIRCUM/.ES1
WE >E B.D 6REG>D ! D1? (! ,MA/]-AT-
>MS Z ! PRISON]'S DE$1 !N DOES T DE$
3/ITUTE A CAPITAL CRIME ":( ! P5ALTY
IS A MORTAL "O8 ,B 9 NATURAL JU/ICE
IS NO?+ B ! PRISON]'S OV]T ACT 6BE
3SID]$8 ,H[ C WE ADJUDGE 6SUMM>Y &
%AME;L D1? A FELL[-CR1TURE 9NOC5T 2F
,GOD1 & :OM WE FEEL 6BE S8- ,DOES T
/ATE X A"R8 ,Y SIGN SAD ASS5T4 ,WELL1
,I TOO FEEL T1 ! FULL =CE ( T4 ,X IS
,NATURE4 ,B D ^! BUTTONS T WE WE>
ATTE/ T \R ALLEGI.E IS 6,NATURE8 ,NO1
6! ,K+4 ,?\< ! OC1N1 : IS 9VIOLATE

,NATURE PRIMEVAL1 ?O0' ? 2 ! ELE;T ":
WE MOVE & H \R 2+ Z SAILORS1 YET Z !
,K+'S (FIC]S LIES \R DUTY 9 A SPH]E
CORRESPOND+LY NATURAL8 ,S LL IS T
TRUE1 T 9 RCVG \R -MIS.NS WE 9 ! MO/
IMPORTANT REG>DS C1S$ 6BE NATURAL
FREE-AG5TS4 ,:5 W> IS DCLD >E WE !
-MIS.N$ FI<T]S PREVI\SLY 3SULT$8 ,WE
FI<T AT -M&4 ,IF \R JUDGE;TS APPROVE
! W>1 T IS B CO9CID;E4 ,S 9 O!R
"PICUL>S4 ,S N[4 ,= SUPPOSE 3DEMN,N
6FOLL[ ^! PRES5T PROCE$+S4 ,WD X 2 S
M* WE \RVS T WD 3DEMN Z X WD 2 M>TIAL
LAW OP]AT+ "? U8 ,= T LAW &! RIG\R (
X1 WE >E N RESPONSI#4 ,\R AV[$
RESPONSIBIL;Y IS 9 ?3 ,T H["E
PITI.SLY T LAW MAY OP]ATE1 WE N"E!.S
AD"H 6X & ADM9I/] X4
  8,B ! EXCEP;NAL 9 ! MATT] MOVES !
HE>TS )9 Y4 ,EV5 S TOO IS M9E MOV$4
,B LET N W>M HE>TS 2TRAY H1DS T %D 2
COOL4 ,A%ORE 9 A CRIM9AL CASE W AN
UP"R JUDGE ALL[ HMF (F ! B5* 6BE
WAYLAID 0"S T5D] K9SWOMAN (! A3US$
SEEK+ 6T\* HM ) H] TE>;L PLEA8 ,WELL

! HE>T "H DENOTES ! FEM99E 9 MAN IS Z
T PITE\S WOMAN1 & H>D ?O0' X BE1 %E
M/ "H 2 RUL$ \40
  ,HE PAUS$1 E>NE/LY /UDY+ !M =A
MO;T2 !N RESUM$4
  8,B "S?+ 9 YR ASPECT SEEMS 6URGE T
X IS N SOLELY ! HE>T T MOVES 9 Y1 B
AL ! 3SCI;E1 ! PRIVATE 3SCI;E4 ,B
TELL ME :E!R OR N1 O3UPY+ ! POSI;N WE
D1 PRIVATE 3SCI;E %D N YIELD 6T
IMP]IAL "O =MULAT$ 9 ! CODE "U : AL"O
WE (FICI,Y PROCE$80
  ,"H ! ?REE M5 MOV$ 9 _! S1TS1 LESS
3V9C$ ?AN AGITAT$ 0! C\RSE ( AN >GU;T
TR\BL+ B ! M ! SPONTANE\S 3FLICT )94
  ,P]CVG :1 ! SP1K] PAUS$ =A MO;T2 !N
ABRUPTLY *ANG+ 8 T"O1 W5T ON4
  8,6/1DY U A BIT1 LET U RECUR 6!
FACTS4- ,9 W>-"T AT SEA A MAN-(-W>'S-
MAN /RIKES 8 SUP]IOR 9 GRADE1 &! BL[
KILLS4 ,A"P F XS E6ECT1 ! BL[ XF IS1
AC 6! ,>TICLES ( ,W>1 A CAPITAL
CRIME4 ,FUR!RMORE-0
  8,AY1 ,SIR10 EMO;N,Y BROKE 9 !
(FIC] ( M>9ES1 8IN "O S5SE X WAS4 ,B

SURELY ,BUDD PURPOS$ NEI MUT9Y NOR
HOMICIDE40
  8,SURELY N1 MY GD MAN4 ,& 2F A C\RT
LESS >BITR>Y & M M]CI;L ?AN A M>TIAL
"O1 T PLEA WD L>GELY EXT5UATE4 ,AT !
,LA/ ,ASSIZES X % ACQUIT4 ,B H[ "H8
,WE PROCE$ "U ! LAW (! ,MUT9Y ,ACT4
,9 F1TURE NO * C RESEM# 8 "F M ?AN T
,ACT RESEM#S 9 _S ! ?+ F : X DERIVES-
,W>4 ,9 ,8 ,MAJE/Y'S S]VICE- 9 ? %IP
9DE$- "! >E ,5GLI%M5 =C$ 6FI<T =! ,K+
AG/ _! W4 ,AG/ _! 3SCI;E1 = AU<T WE
"K4 ,?O0' Z _! FELL[-CR1TURES "S ( U
MAY APPRECIATE _! POSI;N1 YET Z NAVY
(FIC]S1 :AT RECK WE ( X8 ,/ LESS
RECKS ! 5EMY4 ,\R IMPRESS$ M5 HE WD
FA9 CUT D[N 9 ! SAME SWA? ) \R
VOLUNTE]S4 ,Z REG>DS ! 5EMY'S NAVAL
3SCRIPTS1 "S ( :OM MAY EV5 %>E \R [N
ABHORR;E (! REGICIDAL ,FR5*
,DIRECTORY1 X IS ! SAME ON \R SIDE4
,W> LOOKS B 6! FRONTAGE1 ! APPE>.E4
,&! ,MUT9Y ,ACT1 ,W>'S *1 TAKES AF !
"F4 ,BUDD'S 9T5T OR NON-9T5T IS NO?+
6! PURPOSE4

  8,B :ILE1 PUT 6X 0^! ANXIETIES 9 Y
: ,I C N B RESPECT1 ,I ONLY REP1T
MYF- :ILE ?US /RANGELY WE PROL;G
PROCE$+S T %D 2 SUMM>Y- ! 5EMY MAY 2
SI<T$ & AN 5GAGE;T RESULT4 ,WE M/ D2
& "O ( TWO ?+S M/ WE D- 3DEMN OR LET
G40
  8,C WE N 3VICT & YET MITIGATE !
P5ALTY80 ASK$ ! JUNIOR ,LIEUT5ANT "H
SP1K+1 & FALT]+LY1 =! F/4
  8,LIEUT5ANT1 7 T CLE>LY LAW;L = U
"U ! CIRCUM/.ES1 3SID] ! 3SEQU;ES (
S* CLEM5CY4 ,! P0 7M1N+ ! %IP'S
-PANY7 8H NATIVE-S5SE2 MO/ ( !M >E
FAMILI> ) \R NAVAL USAGE & TRADI;N2 &
H[ WD !Y TAKE X8 ,EV5 CD Y EXPLA9
6!M- : \R (FICIAL POSI;N =BIDS- !Y1
L;G M\LD$ 0>BITR>Y 4CIPL9E H N T K9D
( 9TELLIG5T RESPONSIVE;S T MI<T
QUALIFY !M 6-PREH5D & 4CRIM9ATE4 ,NO1
6! P ! ,=ETOPMAN'S DE$1 H["E X 2 ^W$
9 ! ANN\NCE;T1 W 2 PLA9 HOMICIDE
-MITT$ 9 A FLAGRANT ACT ( MUT9Y4 ,:AT
P5ALTY = T %D FOLL[1 !Y "K4 ,B X DOES
N FOLL[4 ,:Y8 !Y W RUM9ATE4 ,Y "K :AT

SAILORS >E4 ,W !Y N REV]T 6! REC5T
\TBR1K AT ! ,NORE8 ,AY4 ,!Y "K !
WELL-F.D$ AL>M- ! PANIC X /RUCK "?\T
,5GL&4 ,YR CLE;T S5T;E !Y WD A3.T
PUSILLANIM\S4 ,!Y WD ?9K T WE FL9*1 T
WE >E AFRAID ( !M- AFRAID ( PRACTIS+
A LAW;L RIG\R S+UL>LY DEM&$ AT ?
JUNCTURE LE/ X %D PROVOKE NEW TR\#S4
,:AT %AME 6U S* A 3JECTURE ON _! "P1
& H[ D1DLY 64CIPL9E4 ,Y SEE !N1 :I!R1
PROMPT$ 0DUTY &! LAW1 ,I /1DFA/LY
DRIVE4 ,B ,I 2SEE* Y1 MY FRS1 D N
TAKE ME AMISS4 ,I FEEL Z Y D = ?
UN=TUNATE BOY4 ,B DID HE "K \R HE>TS1
,I TAKE HM 6BE ( T G5]\S NATURE T HE
WD FEEL EV5 = U ON :OM 9 ? MILIT>Y
NECESS;Y S H1VY A -PUL.N IS LAID40
  ,) T1 CROSS+ ! DECK HE RESUM$ 8
PLACE 0! SA%$ PORT-HOLE1 TACITLY L1V+
! ?REE 6-E 6A DECI.N4 ,ON ! CAB9'S
OPPOSITE SIDE ! TR\#D C\RT SAT SIL5T4
,LOYAL LIEGES1 PLA9 & PRACTICAL1 ?\<
AT BOTTOM !Y 4S5T$ F "S PO9TS ,CAPTA9
,V]E _H PUT 6!M1 !Y 7 )\T ! FACULTY1
H>DLY _H ! 9CL9,N1 6GA9SAY "O :OM !Y

FELT 6BE AN E>NE/ MAN1 "O TOO N LESS
_! SUP]IOR 9 M9D ?AN 9 NAVAL RANK4 ,B
X IS N IMPROBA# T EV5 S* ( 8 ^WS Z 7
N )\T 9FLU;E OV] !M1 LESS CAME HOME
6!M ?AN 8 CLOS+ APP1L 6_! 9/9CT Z
SEA-(FIC]S 9 ! =E?"\ HE ?REW \ Z 6!
PRACTICAL 3SEQU;ES 64CIPL9E1 3SID]+ !
UNCONFIRM$ T"O (! FLEET AT ! "T1 %D A
MAN-(-W>'S-MAN'S VIOL5T KILL+ AT SEA
(A SUP]IOR 9 GRADE 2 ALL[$ 6PASS =
AU<T ELSE ?AN A CAPITAL CRIME DEM&+
PROMPT 9FLIC;N (! P5ALTY4
  ,N UNLIKELY !Y 7 BR"\ 6"S?+ M OR
LESS AK9 6T H>ASS$ FRAME ( M9D : 9 !
YE> #AHDB ACTUAT$ ! ,-M&] (! ,U4,S4
BRIG-(-W> ,SOM]S 6RESOLVE1 "U ! S-
CALL$ ,>TICLES ( ,W>1 ,>TICLES
MODELL$ ^U ! ,5GLI% ,MUT9Y ,ACT1
6RESOLVE ^U ! EXECU;N AT SEA (A
MID%IPMAN & TWO PETTY-(FIC]S Z
MUT9E]S DESIGN+ ! SEIZURE (! BRIG4 ,:
RESOLU;N 0 C>RI$ \ ?\< 9 A "T ( P1CE
& )9 N _M "DS' ( HOME4 ,AN ACT
V9DICAT$ 0A NAVAL C\RT ( 9QUIRY
SUBSEQU5TLY 3V5$ A%ORE4 ,HI/ORY1 & "H

CIT$ )\T -;T4 ,TRUE1 ! CIRCUM/.ES ON
BO>D ! ,SOM]S 7 DI6]5T F ^? ON BO>D !
,9DOMITA#4 ,B ! URG5CY FELT1 WELL-
W>RANT$ OR O!RWISE1 0 M* ! SAME4
  ,SAYS A WRIT] :OM FEW "K1 8,=TY
YE>S AF A BATTLE X IS EASY =A NON-
-BATANT 6R1SON AB H[ X "\ 6H BE5 F"\4
,X IS ANO!R ?+ P]SON,Y & "U FIRE
6DIRECT ! FI<T+ :ILE 9VOLV$ 9 !
OBSCUR+ SMOKE ( X4 ,M* S ) RESPECT
6O!R EM]G5CIES 9VOLV+ 3SID],NS BO?
PRACTICAL & MORAL1 & :5 X IS
IMP]ATIVE PROMPTLY 6ACT4 ,! GRT] !
FOG ! M X IMP]ILS ! /1M]1 & SPE$ IS
PUT ON ?O0' AT ! HAZ>D ( RUNN+ "SBODY
D[N4 ,LL WE5 ! SNUG C>D-PLAY]S 9 !
CAB9 (! RESPONSIBILITIES (! SLEEP.S
MAN ON ! BRIDGE40
  ,9 BRIEF1 ,BILLY ,BUDD 0 =M,Y
3VICT$ & S5T;ED 6BE HUNG AT ! Y>D->M
9 ! E>LY MORN+ WAT*1 X 2+ N[ NI<T4
,O!RWISE1 Z IS CU/OM>Y 9 S* CASES1 !
S5T;E WD =?) H BE5 C>RI$ \4 ,9 W>-"T
ON ! FIELD OR 9 ! FLEET1 A MORTAL
PUNI%;T DECRE$ 0A DRUM-H1D C\RT- ON !

FIELD "S"TS DECRE$ 0B A NOD F !
,G5]AL- FOLL[S )\T DELAY ON ! HEEL (
3VIC;N )\T APP1L4