,,*APT] ,,XV3 ,,RECAPITUL,N ,,& ,,3CLU.N ,Z ? :OLE VOLUME IS "O L;G >GU;T1 X MAY 2 3V5I5T 6! R1D] 6H ! L1D+ FACTS & 9F];ES BRIEFLY RECAPITULAT$4 ,T _M & S]I\S OBJEC;NS MAY 2 ADV.ED AG/ ! !ORY ( DESC5T ) MODIFIC,N "? V>I,N & NATURAL SELEC;N1 ,I D N D5Y4 ,I H 5D1V\R$ 6GIVE 6!M _! FULL =CE4 ,NO?+ AT F/ C APPE> M DI6ICULT 62LIEVE ?AN T ! M -PLEX ORGANS & 9/9CTS H BE5 P]FECT$1 N 0M1NS SUP]IOR TO1 ?\< ANALOG\S )1 HUMAN R1SON1 B 0! A3UMUL,N ( 9NUM]A# SLII,NS1 EA* GD =! 9DIVIDUAL POSSESSOR4 ,N"E!.S1 ? DI6ICULTY1 ?\< APPE>+ 6\R IMAG9,N 9SUP]ABLY GRT1 _C 2 3SID]$ R1L IF WE ADMIT ! FOLL[+ PROPOSI;NS1 "NLY1 T ALL "PS (! ORGANIS,N & 9/9CTS (F]1 AT L1/1 9DIVIDUAL DI6];ES- T "! IS A /RU7LE = EXI/;E L1D+ 6! PRES]V,N ( PR(ITA# DEVI,NS ( /RUCTURE OR 9/9CT- &1 LA/LY1 T GRAD,NS 9 ! /ATE ( P]FEC;N ( EA* ORGAN MAY H EXI/$1 EA* GD ( XS K9D4 ,! TRU? ( ^! PROPOSI;NS _C1 ,I ?9K1 2 4PUT$4 ,X IS1 NO D\BT1 EXTREMELY DI6ICULT EV5 63JECTURE 0:AT GRAD,NS _M /RUCTURES H BE5 P]FECT$1 M ESPECI,Y AM;G/ BROK5 & FAIL+ GR\PS ( ORGANIC 2+S1 : H SU6]$ M* EXT9C;N1 B WE SEE S _M /RANGE GRAD,NS 9 NATURE1 T WE "\ 6BE EXTREMELY CAUTI\S 9 SAY+ T ANY ORGAN OR 9/9CT1 OR ANY :OLE /RUCTURE1 CD N H >RIV$ AT XS PRES5T /ATE 0_M GRADUAT$ /EPS4 ,"! >E1 X M/ 2 ADMITT$1 CASES ( SPECIAL DI6ICULTY OPPOS$ 6! !ORY ( NATURAL SELEC;N2 & "O ( ! MO/ CURI\S ( ^! IS ! EXI/;E 9 ! SAME -MUN;Y ( TWO OR ?REE DEF9$ CA/ES ( "W]S OR /]ILE FEMALE ANTS2 B ,I H ATTEMPT$ 6%[ H[ ^! DI6ICULTIES C 2 MA/]$4 ,) RESPECT 6! ALM UNIV]SAL /]IL;Y ( SPECIES :5 F/ CROSS$1 : =MS S REM>KA# A 3TRA/ )! ALM UNIV]SAL F]TIL;Y ( V>IETIES :5 CROSS$1 ,I M/ REF] ! R1D] 6! RECAPITUL,N (! FACTS GIV5 AT ! 5D (! N9? *APT]1 : SEEM 6ME 3CLUSIVELY 6%[ T ? /]IL;Y IS NO M A SPECIAL 5D[;T ?AN IS ! 9CAPAC;Y ( TWO 4T9CT K9DS ( TREES 6BE GRAFT$ TGR2 B T X IS 9CID5TAL ON DI6];ES 3F9$ 6! REPRODUCTIVE SY/EMS (! 9T]CROSS$ SPECIES4 ,WE SEE ! TRU? ( ? 3CLU.N 9 ! VA/ DI6];E 9 ! RESULTS ( CROSS+ ! SAME TWO SPECIES RECIPROC,Y1- T IS1 :5 "O SPECIES IS F/ US$ Z ! "F & !N Z ! "M4 ,ANALOGY F ! 3SID],N ( DIMORPHIC & TRIMORPHIC PLANTS CLE>LY L1DS 6! SAME 3CLU.N1 = :5 ! =MS >E ILLEGITIMATELY UNIT$1 !Y YIELD FEW OR NO SE$1 & _! (FSPR+ >E M OR LESS /]ILE2 & ^! =MS 2L;G 6! SAME UND\BT$ SPECIES1 & DI6] F EA* O!R 9 NO RESPECT EXCEPT 9 _! REPRODUCTIVE ORGANS & FUNC;NS4 ,AL? ! F]TIL;Y ( V>IETIES :5 9T]CROSS$ &( _! M;GREL (FSPR+ HAS BE5 ASS]T$ 0S _M AU?ORS 6BE UNIV]SAL1 ? _C 2 3SID]$ Z Q CORRECT AF ! FACTS GIV5 ON ! HI< AU?OR;Y ( ,G>TN] & ,KOLREUT]4 ,MO/ (! V>IETIES : H BE5 EXP]I;T$ ON H BE5 PRODUC$ "U DOME/IC,N2 & Z DOME/IC,N 7,I D N M1N M]E 3F9E;T7 ALM C]TA9LY T5DS 6ELIM9ATE T /]IL;Y :1 JUDG+ F ANALOGY1 WD H A6ECT$ ! P>5T-SPECIES IF 9T]CROSS$1 WE "\ N 6EXPECT T DOME/IC,N WD LIKEWISE 9DUCE /]IL;Y 9 _! MODIFI$ DESC5DANTS :5 CROSS$4 ,? ELIM9,N ( /]IL;Y APP>5TLY FOLL[S F ! SAME CAUSE : ALL[S \R DOME/IC ANIMALS 6BRE$ FREELY "U DIV]SIFI$ CIRCUM/.ES2 & ? AG APP>5TLY FOLL[S F _! HAV+ BE5 GRADU,Y A3U/OM$ 6FREQU5T *ANGES 9 _! 3DI;NS ( LIFE4 ,A D\# & P>ALLEL S]IES ( FACTS SEEMS 6?R[ M* LIIETY1 & 2T 4T9CT V>IETIES1 9CR1SES ! NUMB] ( _! (FSPR+1 & C]TA9LY GIVES 6!M 9CR1S$ SIZE & VIG\R4 ,? IS *IEFLY [+ 6! =MS : >E CROSS$ HAV+ BE5 EXPOS$ 6"S:AT DI6]5T 3DI;NS ( LIFE2 = ,I H ASC]TA9$ 0A LABORI\S S]IES ( EXP]I;TS T IF ALL ! 9DIVIDUALS (! SAME V>IETY 2 SUBJECT$ DUR+ S"EAL G5],NS 6! SAME 3DI;NS1 ! GD DERIV$ F CROSS+ IS (T5 M* DIM9I%$ OR :OLLY 4APPE>S4 ,? IS "O SIDE (! CASE4 ,ON ! O!R SIDE1 WE "K T SPECIES : H L;G BE5 EXPOS$ 6NE>LY UNI=M 3DI;NS1 :5 !Y >E SUBJECT$ "U 3F9E;T 6NEW & GRTLY *ANG$ 3DI;NS1 EI P]I%1 OR IF !Y SURVIVE1 >E R5D]$ /]ILE1 ?\< RETA9+ P]FECT H1L?4 ,? DOES N O3UR1 OR ONLY 9 A V SLIE FEW 9 NUMB]1 [+ 6_! P]I%+ SOON AF 3CEP;N OR AT A V E>LY AGE1 OR IF SURVIV+ T !Y >E R5D]$ M OR LESS /]ILE1 X SEEMS HIE G5],Y R5D]$ M OR LESS /]ILE1 :IL/ TWO DOME/ICAT$ V>IETIES :5 CROSS$ & _! M;GREL (FSPR+ >E P]FECTLY F]TILE4 ,TURN+ 6GEOGRAPHICAL 4TRIBU;N1 ! DI6ICULTIES 5C.T]$ ON ! !ORY ( DESC5T ) MODIFIC,N >E S]I\S 5\<4 ,ALL ! 9DIVIDUALS (! SAME SPECIES1 & ALL ! SPECIES (! SAME G5US1 OR EV5 HI<] GR\P1 >E DESC5D$ F -MON P>5TS2 & "!=E1 9 H["E 4TANT & ISOLAT$ "PS (! _W !Y MAY N[ 2 F.D1 !Y M/ 9 ! C\RSE ( SU3ESSIVE G5],NS H TRAVELL$ F "S "O PO9T 6ALL ! O!RS4 ,WE >E (T5 :OLLY UNA# EV5 63JECTURE H[ ? CD H BE5 E6ECT$4 ,YET1 Z WE H R1SON 62LIEVE T "S SPECIES H RETA9$ ! SAME SPECIFIC =M = V L;G P]IODS ( "T1 IMM5SELY L;G Z M1SUR$ 0YE>S1 TOO M* /RESS "\ N 6BE LAID ON ! O3A.NAL WIDE DI6U.N (! SAME SPECIES2 = DUR+ V L;G P]IODS "! W ALW H BE5 A GD *.E = WIDE MIGR,N 0_M M1NS4 ,A BROK5 OR 9T]RUPT$ RANGE MAY (T5 2 A3.T$ = 0! EXT9C;N (! SPECIES 9 ! 9T]M$IATE REGIONS4 ,X _C 2 D5I$ T WE >E Z YET V IGNORANT Z 6! FULL EXT5T (! V>I\S CLIMATAL & GEOGRAPHICAL *ANGES : H A6ECT$ ! E>? DUR+ MOD]N P]IODS2 & S* *ANGES W (T5 H FACILITAT$ MIGR,N4 ,Z AN EXAMPLE1 ,I H ATTEMPT$ 6%[ H[ POT5T HAS BE5 ! 9FLU;E (! ,GLACIAL P]IOD ON ! 4TRIBU;N (! SAME &( ALLI$ SPECIES "?\T ! _W4 ,WE >E Z YET PROF.DLY IGNORANT (! _M O3A.NAL M1NS ( TRANSPORT4 ,) RESPECT 64T9CT SPECIES (! SAME G5US 9HABIT+ 4TANT & ISOLAT$ REGIONS1 Z ! PROCESS ( MODIFIC,N HAS NECESS>ILY BE5 SL[1 ALL ! M1NS ( MIGR,N W H BE5 POSSI# DUR+ A V L;G P]IOD2 & 3SEQU5TLY ! DI6ICULTY (! WIDE DI6U.N (! SPECIES (! SAME G5US IS 9 "S DEGREE LESS5$4 ,Z AC 6! !ORY ( NATURAL SELEC;N AN 9T]M9A# NUMB] ( 9T]M$IATE =MS M/ H EXI/$1 L9K+ TGR ALL ! SPECIES 9 EA* GR\P 0GRAD,NS Z F9E Z >E \R EXI/+ V>IETIES1 X MAY 2 ASK$3 ,:Y D WE N SEE ^! L9K+ =MS ALL >.D U8 ,:Y >E N ALL ORGANIC 2+S BL5D$ TGR 9 AN 9EXTRICA# *AOS8 ,) RESPECT 6EXI/+ =MS1 WE %D REMEMB] T WE H NO "R 6EXPECT 7EXCEPT+ 9 R>E CASES7 64COV] DIRECTLY 3NECT+ L9KS 2T !M1 B ONLY 2T EA* & "S EXT9CT & SUPPLANT$ =M4 ,EV5 ON A WIDE >EA1 : HAS DUR+ A L;G P]IOD REMA9$ 3T9U\S1 &( : ! CLIMATIC & O!R 3DI;NS ( LIFE *ANGE 9S5SIBLY 9 PROCE$+ F A 4TRICT O3UPI$ 0"O SPECIES 96ANO!R 4TRICT O3UPI$ 0A CLOSELY ALLI$ SPECIES1 WE H NO J "R 6EXPECT (T5 6F9D 9T]M$IATE V>IETIES 9 ! 9T]M$IATE Z"OS4 ,= WE H R1SON 62LIEVE T ONLY A FEW SPECIES (A G5US "E "UGO *ANGE2 ! O!R SPECIES 2COM+ UTT]LY EXT9CT & L1V+ NO MODIFI$ PROG5Y4 ,(! SPECIES : D *ANGE1 ONLY A FEW )9 ! SAME C.TRY *ANGE AT ! SAME "T2 & ALL MODIFIC,NS >E SL[LY E6ECT$4 ,I H AL %[N T ! 9T]M$IATE V>IETIES : PROBABLY AT F/ EXI/$ 9 ! 9T]M$IATE Z"OS1 WD 2 LIA# 6BE SUPPLANT$ 0! ALLI$ =MS ON EI H&2 =! LATT]1 F EXI/+ 9 GRT] NUMB]S1 WD G5],Y 2 MODIFI$ & IMPROV$ AT A QK] RATE ?AN ! 9T]M$IATE V>IETIES1 : EXI/$ 9 LESS] NUMB]S2 S T ! 9T]M$IATE V>IETIES WD1 9 ! L;G RUN1 2 SUPPLANT$ & EXT]M9AT$4 ,ON ? DOCTR9E (! EXT]M9,N ( AN 9F9ITUDE ( 3NECT+ L9KS1 2T ! LIV+ & EXT9CT 9HABITANTS (! _W1 & AT EA* SU3ESSIVE P]IOD 2T ! EXT9CT & / OLD] SPECIES1 :Y IS N E GEOLOGICAL =M,N *>G$ ) S* L9KS8 ,:Y DOES N E COLLEC;N ( FOSSIL REMA9S AF=D PLA9 EVID;E (! GRAD,N & MUT,N (! =MS ( LIFE8 ,AL? GEOLOGICAL RESE>* HAS UND\BT$LY REV1L$ ! =M] EXI/;E ( _M L9KS1 BR++ NUM]\S =MS ( LIFE M* CLOS] TGR1 X DOES N YIELD ! 9F9ITELY _M F9E GRAD,NS 2T PA/ & PRES5T SPECIES REQUIR$ ON ! !ORY2 & ? IS ! MO/ OBVI\S ( ! _M OBJEC;NS : MAY 2 URG$ AG/ X4 ,:Y1 AG1 D :OLE GR\PS ( ALLI$ SPECIES APPE>1 ?\< ? APPE>.E IS (T5 FALSE1 6H -E 9 SU45LY ON ! SU3ESSIVE GEOLOGICAL /AGES8 ,AL? WE N[ "K T ORGANIC 2+S APPE>$ ON ? GLOBE1 AT A P]IOD 9CALCULABLY REMOTE1 L;G 2F ! L[E/ B$ (! ,CAMBRIAN SY/EM 0 DEPOSIT$1 :Y D WE N F9D 2N ? SY/EM GRT PILES ( /RATA /OR$ )! REMA9S (! PROG5ITORS (! ,CAMBRIAN FOSSILS8 ,= ON ! !ORY1 S* /RATA M/ "S": H BE5 DEPOSIT$ AT ^! ANCI5T & UTT]LY UN"KN EPO*S (! _W'S HI/ORY4 ,I C ANSW] ^! "QS & OBJEC;NS ONLY ON ! SUPPOSI;N T ! GEOLOGICAL RECORD IS F> M IMP]FECT ?AN MO/ GEOLOGI/S 2LIEVE4 ,! NUMB] ( SPECIM5S 9 ALL \R MUSEUMS IS ABSOLUTELY Z NO?+ -P>$ )! C.T.S G5],NS ( C.T.S SPECIES : H C]TA9LY EXI/$4 ,! P>5T-=M ( ANY TWO OR M SPECIES WD N 2 9 ALL XS "*S DIRECTLY 9T]M$IATE 2T XS MODIFI$ (FSPR+1 ANY M ?AN ! ROCK-PIGEON IS DIRECTLY 9T]M$IATE 9 CROP & TAIL 2T XS DESC5DANTS1 ! P\T] & FANTAIL PIGEONS4 ,WE %D N 2 A# 6RECOGNISE A SPECIES Z ! P>5T ( ANO!R & MODIFI$ SPECIES1 IF WE 7 6EXAM9E ! TWO "E S CLOSELY1 UN.S WE POSSESS$ MO/ (! 9T]M$IATE L9KS2 & [+ 6! IMP]FEC;N (! GEOLOGICAL RECORD1 WE H NO J "R 6EXPECT 6F9D S _M L9KS4 ,IF TWO OR ?REE1 OR EV5 M L9K+ =MS 7 4COV]$1 !Y WD SIMPLY 2 RANK$ 0_M NATURALI/S Z S _M NEW SPECIES1 M ESPECI,Y IF F.D 9 DI6]5T GEOLOGICAL SUB-/AGES1 LET _! DI6];ES 2 "E S SLIE PROBABLY V>IETIES2 B :O W PRET5D T 9 FUTURE AGES S _M FOSSIL L9KS W 2 4COV]$1 T NATURALI/S W 2 A# 6DECIDE :E!R OR N ^! D\BT;L =MS "\ 6BE CALL$ V>IETIES8 ,ONLY A SMALL POR;N (! _W HAS BE5 GEOLOGIC,Y EXPLOR$4 ,ONLY ORGANIC 2+S ( C]TA9 CLASSES C 2 PRES]V$ 9 A FOSSIL 3DI;N1 AT L1/ 9 ANY GRT NUMB]4 ,_M SPECIES :5 ONCE =M$ N"E "UGO ANY FUR!R *ANGE B 2COME EXT9CT )\T L1V+ MODIFI$ DESC5DANTS2 &! P]IODS1 DUR+ : SPECIES H "UG"O MODIFIC,N1 ?\< L;G Z M1SUR$ 0YE>S1 H PROBABLY BE5 %ORT 9 -P>ISON )! P]IODS DUR+ : !Y RETA9 ! SAME =M4 ,X IS ! DOM9ANT & WIDELY RANG+ SPECIES : V>Y MO/ FREQU5TLY & V>Y MO/1 & V>IETIES >E (T5 AT F/ LOCAL- BO? CAUSES R5D]+ ! 4COV]Y ( 9T]M$IATE L9KS 9 ANY "O =M,N LESS LIKELY4 ,LOCAL V>IETIES W N SPR1D 96O!R & 4TANT REGIONS UNTIL !Y >E 3SID]ABLY MODIFI$ & IMPROV$2 & :5 !Y H SPR1D1 & >E 4COV]$ 9 A GEOLOGICAL =M,N1 !Y APPE> Z IF SU45LY CR1T$ "!1 & W 2 SIMPLY CLASS$ Z NEW SPECIES4 ,MO/ =M,NS H BE5 9T]MITT5T 9 _! A3UMUL,N2 & _! DUR,N HAS PROBABLY BE5 %ORT] ?AN ! AV]AGE DUR,N ( SPECIFIC =MS4 ,SU3ESSIVE =M,NS >E 9 MO/ CASES SEP>AT$ F EA* O!R 0BLANK 9T]VALS ( "T ( GRT L5G?2 = FOSSILIF]\S =M,NS ?ICK 5 6RESI/ FUTURE DEGRAD,NS C Z A G5]AL RULE 2 A3UMULAT$ ONLY ": M* S$I;T IS DEPOSIT$ ON ! SUBSID+ B$ (! SEA4 ,DUR+ ! ALT]NATE P]IODS ( ELEV,N &( /,N>Y LEVEL ! RECORD W G5],Y 2 BLANK4 ,DUR+ ^! LATT] P]IODS "! W PROBABLY 2 M V>IABIL;Y 9 ! =MS ( LIFE2 DUR+ P]IODS ( SUBSID;E1 M EXT9C;N4 ,) RESPECT 6! ABS;E ( /RATA RI* 9 FOSSILS 2N ! ,CAMBRIAN =M,N1 ,I C RECUR ONLY 6! HYPO!SIS GIV5 9 ! T5? *APT]2 "NLY1 T ?\< \R 3T95TS & OC1NS H 5DUR$ = AN ENORM\S P]IOD 9 NE>LY _! PRES5T RELATIVE POSI;NS1 WE H NO R1SON 6ASSUME T ? HAS ALW BE5 ! CASE2 3SEQU5TLY =M,NS M* OLD] ?AN ANY N[ "KN MAY LIE BURI$ 2N ! GRT OC1NS4 ,) RESPECT 6! LAPSE ( "T N HAV+ BE5 SU6ICI5T S9CE \R PLANET 0 3SOLIDAT$ =! ASSUM$ AM.T ( ORGANIC *ANGE1 & ? OBJEC;N1 Z URG$ 0,SIR ,WILLIAM ,?OMPSON1 IS PROBABLY "O (! GRAVE/ Z YET ADV.ED1 ,I C ONLY SAY1 F/LY1 T WE D N "K AT :AT RATE SPECIES *ANGE Z M1SUR$ 0YE>S1 & SECONDLY1 T _M PHILOSOPH]S >E N Z YET WILL+ 6ADMIT T WE "K 5 (! 3/ITU;N (! UNIV]SE &(! 9T]IOR ( \R GLOBE 6SPECULATE ) SAFETY ON XS PA/ DUR,N4 ,T ! GEOLOGICAL RECORD IS IMP]FECT ALL W ADMIT2 B T X IS IMP]FECT 6! DEGREE REQUIR$ 0\R !ORY1 FEW W 2 9CL9$ 6ADMIT4 ,IF WE LOOK 6L;G 5 9T]VALS ( "T1 GEOLOGY PLA9LY DCLS T SPECIES H ALL *ANG$2 & !Y H *ANG$ 9 ! MANN] REQUIR$ 0! !ORY1 = !Y H *ANG$ SL[LY & 9 A GRADUAT$ MANN]4 ,WE CLE>LY SEE ? 9 ! FOSSIL REMA9S F 3SECUTIVE =M,NS 9V>IABLY 2+ M* M CLOSELY RELAT$ 6EA* O!R1 ?AN >E ! FOSSILS F WIDELY SEP>AT$ =M,NS4 ,S* IS ! SUM (! S"EAL *IEF OBJEC;NS & DI6ICULTIES : MAY 2 JU/LY URG$ AG/ ! !ORY2 & ,I H N[ BRIEFLY RECAPITULAT$ ! ANSW]S & EXPLAN,NS :1 Z F> Z ,I C SEE1 MAY 2 GIV54 ,I H FELT ^! DI6ICULTIES F> TOO H1VILY DUR+ _M YE>S 6D\BT _! WEIE 3FESS$LY IGNORANT2 NOR D WE "K H[ IGNORANT WE >E4 ,WE D N "K ALL ! POSSI# TRANSI;NAL GRAD,NS 2T ! SIMPLE/ &! MO/ P]FECT ORGANS2 X _C 2 PRET5D$ T WE "K ALL ! V>I$ M1NS ( ,4TRIBU;N DUR+ ! L;G LAPSE ( YE>S1 OR T WE "K H[ IMP]FECT IS ! ,GEOLOGICAL ,RECORD4 ,S]I\S Z ^! S"EAL OBJEC;NS >E1 9 MY JUDG;T !Y >E 0NO M1NS SU6ICI5T 6OV]?R[ ! !ORY ( DESC5T ) SUBSEQU5T MODIFIC,N4 ,N[ LET U TURN 6! O!R SIDE (! >GU;T4 ,"U DOME/IC,N WE SEE M* V>IABIL;Y1 CAUS$1 OR AT L1/ EXCIT$1 0*ANG$ 3DI;NS ( LIFE2 B (T5 9 S OBSCURE A MANN]1 T WE >E TEMPT$ 63SID] ! V>I,NS Z SPONTANE\S4 ,V>IABIL;Y IS GOV]N$ 0_M -PLEX LAWS1- 0CORRELAT$ GR[?1 -P5S,N1 ! 9CR1S$ USE & 4USE ( "PS1 &! DEF9ITE AC;N (! SURR.D+ 3DI;NS4 ,"! IS M* DI6ICULTY 9 ASC]TA9+ H[ L>GELY \R DOME/IC PRODUC;NS H BE5 MODIFI$2 B WE MAY SAFELY 9F] T ! AM.T HAS BE5 L>GE1 & T MODIFIC,NS C 2 9H]IT$ = L;G P]IODS4 ,Z L;G Z ! 3DI;NS ( LIFE REMA9 ! SAME1 WE H R1SON 62LIEVE T A MODIFIC,N1 : HAS ALR BE5 9H]IT$ = _M G5],NS1 MAY 3T9UE 6BE 9H]IT$ = AN ALM 9F9ITE NUMB] ( G5],NS4 ,ON ! O!R H&1 WE H EVID;E T V>IABIL;Y :5 X HAS ONCE -E 96PLAY1 DOES N C1SE "U DOME/IC,N =A V L;G P]IOD2 NOR D WE "K T X "E C1SES1 = NEW V>IETIES >E / O3A.N,Y PRODUC$ 0\R OLDE/ DOME/ICAT$ PRODUC;NS4 ,V>IABIL;Y IS N ACTU,Y CAUS$ 0MAN2 HE ONLY UN9T5;N,Y EXPOSES ORGANIC 2+S 6NEW 3DI;NS ( LIFE1 & !N NATURE ACTS ON ! ORGANIS,N & CAUSES X 6V>Y4 ,B MAN C & DOES SELECT ! V>I,NS GIV5 6HM 0NATURE1 & ?US A3UMULATES !M 9 ANY DESIR$ MANN]4 ,HE ?US ADAPTS ANIMALS & PLANTS = 8 [N B5EFIT OR PL1SURE4 ,HE MAY D ? ME?ODIC,Y1 OR HE MAY D X UNCONSCI\SLY 0PRES]V+ ! 9DIVIDUALS MO/ USE;L OR PL1S+ 6HM )\T ANY 9T5;N ( ALT]+ ! BRE$4 ,X IS C]TA9 T HE C L>GELY 9FLU;E ! "* (A BRE$ 0SELECT+1 9 EA* SU3ESSIVE G5],N1 9DIVIDUAL DI6];ES S SLIGE EXT5T ! "* ( NATURAL SPECIES1 IS %[N 0! 9EXTRICA# D\BTS :E!R _M ( !M >E V>IETIES OR ABORIG9,Y 4T9CT SPECIES4 ,"! IS NO R1SON :Y ! PR9CIPLES : H ACT$ S E6ICI5TLY "U DOME/IC,N %D N H ACT$ "U NATURE4 ,9 ! SURVIVAL ( FAV\R$ 9DIVIDUALS & RACES1 DUR+ ! 3/ANTLY- RECURR5T ,/RU7LE = ,EXI/;E1 WE SEE A P[];L & "E-ACT+ =M ( ,SELEC;N4 ,! /RU7LE = EXI/;E 9EVITABLY FOLL[S F ! HI< GEOMETRICAL RATIO ( 9CR1SE : IS -MON1 6ALL ORGANIC 2+S4 ,? HI< RATE ( 9CR1SE IS PROV$ 0CALCUL,N1- 0! RAPID 9CR1SE ( _M ANIMALS & PLANTS DUR+ SU3ES.N ( PECULI> S1SONS1 & :5 NATURALIS$ 9 NEW C.TRIES4 ,M 9DIVIDUALS >E BORN ?AN C POSSIBLY SURVIVE4 ,A GRA9 9 ! BAL.E MAY DET]M9E : 9DIVIDUALS % LIVE & : % DIE1- : V>IETY OR SPECIES % 9CR1SE 9 NUMB]1 & : % DECR1SE1 OR F9,Y 2COME EXT9CT4 ,Z ! 9DIVIDUALS (! SAME SPECIES -E 9 ALL RESPECTS 96! CLOSE/ -PETI;N ) EA* O!R1 ! /RU7LE W G5],Y 2 MO/ SEV]E 2T !M2 X W 2 ALM EQU,Y SEV]E 2T ! V>IETIES (! SAME SPECIES1 & NEXT 9 SEV];Y 2T ! SPECIES (! SAME G5US4 ,ON ! O!R H& ! /RU7LE W (T5 2 SEV]E 2T 2+S REMOTE 9 ! SCALE ( NATURE4 ,! SLIAT$ SEXES1 "! W 2 9 MO/ CASES A /RU7LE 2T ! MALES =! POSSES.N (! FEMALES4 ,! MO/ VIGOR\S MALES1 OR ^? : H MO/ SU3ESS;LLY /RU7L$ ) _! 3DI;NS ( LIFE1 W G5],Y L1VE MO/ PROG5Y4 ,B SU3ESS W (T5 DEP5D ON ! MALES HAV+ SPECIAL W1PONS1 OR M1NS ( DEF;E1 OR *>MS2 ADD A SLII$ "U NATURE1 9 ! SAME WAY Z !Y H V>I$ "U DOME/IC,N4 ,& IF "! HAS BE5 ANY V>IABIL;Y "U NATURE1 X WD 2 AN UNA3.TA# FACT IF NATURAL SELEC;N _H N -E 96PLAY4 ,X HAS (T5 BE5 ASS]T$1 B ! ASS];N IS 9CAPA# ( PRO(1 T ! AM.T ( V>I,N "U NATURE IS A /RICTLY LIMIT$ QUANT;Y4 ,MAN1 ?\< ACT+ ON EXT]NAL "*S AL"O & (T5 CAPRICI\SLY1 C PRODUCE )9 A %ORT P]IOD A GRT RESULT 0A4+ UP M]E 9DIVIDUAL DI6];ES 9 8 DOME/IC PRODUC;NS2 & E "O ADMITS T SPECIES PRES5T 9DIVIDUAL DI6];ES4 ,B1 2SS S* DI6];ES1 ALL NATURALI/S ADMIT T NATURAL V>IETIES EXI/1 : >E 3SID]$ SU6ICI5TLY 4T9CT 6BE WOR?Y ( RECORD 9 SY/EMATIC "WS4 ,NO "O HAS DRAWN ANY CLE> 4T9C;N 2T 9DIVIDUAL DI6];ES & SLIIETIES2 OR 2T M PLA9LY M>K$ V>IETIES & SUB-SPECIES1 & SPECIES4 ,ON SEP>ATE 3T95TS1 & ON DI6]5T "PS (! SAME 3T95T :5 DIVID$ 0B>RI]S ( ANY K9D1 & ON \TLY+ ISL&S1 :AT A MULTITUDE ( =MS EXI/1 : "S EXP]I;ED NATURALI/S RANK Z V>IETIES1 O!RS Z GEOGRAPHICAL RACES OR SUB- SPECIES1 & O!RS Z 4T9CT1 ?\< CLOSELY ALLI$ SPECIES6 ,IF1 !N1 ANIMALS & PLANTS D V>Y1 LET X 2 "E S SLII,NS OR 9DIVIDUAL DI6];ES1 : >E 9 ANY WAY B5EFICIAL1 2 PRES]V$ & A3UMULAT$ "? NATURAL SELEC;N1 OR ! SURVIVAL (! FITTE/8 ,IF MAN C 0PATI;E SELECT V>I,NS USE;L 6HM1 :Y1 "U *ANG+ & -PLEX 3DI;NS ( LIFE1 %D N V>I,NS USE;L 6NATURE'S LIV+ PRODUCTS (T5 >ISE1 & 2 PRES]V$ OR SELECT$8 ,:AT LIMIT C 2 PUT 6? P[]1 ACT+ DUR+ L;G AGES & RIGIDLY SCRUT9IS+ ! :OLE 3/ITU;N1 /RUCTURE1 & HABITS ( EA* CR1TURE1- FAV\R+ ! GD & REJECT+ ! BAD8 ,I C SEE NO LIMIT 6? P[]1 9 SL[LY & B1UTI;LLY ADAPT+ EA* =M 6! MO/ -PLEX REL,NS ( LIFE4 ,! !ORY ( NATURAL SELEC;N1 EV5 IF WE LOOK NO F>!R ?AN ?1 SEEMS 6BE 9 ! HIGU;TS 9 FAV\R ( ! !ORY4 ,ON ! VIEW T SPECIES >E ONLY /R;GLY M>K$ & P]MAN5T V>IETIES1 & T EA* SPECIES F/ EXI/$ Z A V>IETY1 WE C SEE :Y X IS T NO L9E ( DEM>C,N C 2 DRAWN 2T SPECIES1 -MONLY SUPPOS$ 6H BE5 PRODUC$ 0SPECIAL ACTS ( CRE,N1 & V>IETIES : >E AC"KL$G$ 6H BE5 PRODUC$ 0SECOND>Y LAWS4 ,ON ? SAME VIEW WE C "U/& H[ X IS T 9 A REGION ": _M SPECIES (A G5US H BE5 PRODUC$1 & ": !Y N[ FL\RI%1 ^! SAME SPECIES %D PRES5T _M V>IETIES2 = ": ! MANUFACTORY ( SPECIES HAS BE5 ACTIVE1 WE MIIETIES 2 9CIPI5T SPECIES4 ,MOREOV]1 ! SPECIES (! L>G] G5]A1 : AF=D ! GRT] NUMB] ( V>IETIES OR 9CIPI5T SPECIES1 RETA9 6A C]TA9 DEGREE ! "* ( V>IETIES2 = !Y DI6] F EA* O!R 0A LESS AM.T ( DI6];E ?AN D ! SPECIES ( SMALL] G5]A4 ,! CLOSELY ALLI$ SPECIES AL (! L>G] G5]A APP>5TLY H RE/RICT$ RANGES1 & 9 _! A69ITIES !Y >E CLU/]$ 9 LL GR\PS R.D O!R SPECIES- 9 BO? RESPECTS RESEMBL+ V>IETIES4 ,^! >E /RANGE REL,NS ON ! VIEW T EA* SPECIES 0 9DEP5D5TLY CR1T$1 B >E 9TELLIGI# IF EA* EXI/$ F/ Z A V>IETY4 ,Z EA* SPECIES T5DS 0XS GEOMETRICAL RATE ( REPRODUC;N 69CR1SE 9ORD9ATELY 9 NUMB]2 & Z ! MODIFI$ DESC5DANTS ( EA* SPECIES W 2 5A#D 69CR1SE 0Z M* Z !Y 2COME M DIV]SIFI$ 9 HABITS & /RUCTURE1 S Z 6BE A# 6SEIZE ON _M & WIDELY DI6]5T PLACES 9 ! ECONOMY ( NATURE1 "! W 2 A 3/ANT T5D5CY 9 NATURAL SELEC;N 6PRES]VE ! MO/ DIV]G5T (FSPR+ ( ANY "O SPECIES4 ,H;E1 DUR+ A L;G-3T9U$ C\RSE ( MODIFIC,N1 ! SLIIETIES (! SAME SPECIES1 T5D 6BE AUG;T$ 96! GRT] DI6];ES "*I/IC (! SPECIES (! SAME G5US4 ,NEW & IMPROV$ V>IETIES W 9EVITABLY SUPPLANT & EXT]M9ATE ! OLD]1 LESS IMPROV$1 & 9T]M$IATE V>IETIES2 & ?US SPECIES >E R5D]$ 6A L>GE EXT5T DEF9$ & 4T9CT OBJECTS4 ,DOM9ANT SPECIES 2L;G+ 6! L>G] GR\PS )9 EA* CLASS T5D 6GIVE BIR? 6NEW & DOM9ANT =MS2 S T EA* L>GE GR\P T5DS 62COME / L>G]1 & AT ! SAME "T M DIV]G5T 9 "*4 ,B Z ALL GR\PS _C ?US G ON 9CR1S+ 9 SIZE1 =! _W WD N HOLD !M1 ! M DOM9ANT GR\PS B1T ! LESS DOM9ANT4 ,? T5D5CY 9 ! L>GE GR\PS 6G ON 9CR1S+ 9 SIZE & DIV]G+ 9 "*1 TGR )! 9EVITA# 3T+5CY ( M* EXT9C;N1 EXPLA9S ! >RANGE;T ( ALL ! =MS ( LIFE 9 GR\PS SUBORD9ATE 6GR\PS1 ALL )9 A FEW GRT CLASSES1 : HAS PREVAIL$ "?\T ALL "T4 ,? GR& FACT (! GR\P+ ( ALL ORGANIC 2+S "U :AT IS CALL$ ! ,NATURAL ,SY/EM1 IS UTT]LY 9EXPLICA# ON ! !ORY ( CRE,N4 ,Z NATURAL SELEC;N ACTS SOLELY 0A3UMULAT+ SLII,NS1 X C PRODUCE NO GRT OR SU45 MODIFIC,NS2 X C ACT ONLY 0%ORT & SL[ /EPS4 ,H;E1 ! CANON ( 8,NATURA NON FACIT SALTUM10 : E FRE% A4I;N 6\R K T5DS 63FIRM1 IS ON ? !ORY 9TELLIGI#4 ,WE C SEE :Y "?\T NATURE ! SAME G5]AL 5D IS GA9$ 0AN ALM 9F9ITE DIV]S;Y ( M1NS1 = E PECULI>;Y :5 ONCE ACQUIR$ IS L;G 9H]IT$1 & /RUCTURES ALR MODIFI$ 9 _M DI6]5T WAYS H 6BE ADAPT$ =! SAME G5]AL PURPOSE4 ,WE C1 9 %ORT1 SEE :Y NATURE IS PRODIGAL 9 V>IETY1 ?\< NI7>D 9 9NOV,N4 ,B :Y ? %D 2 A LAW ( NATURE IF EA* SPECIES HAS BE5 9DEP5D5TLY CR1T$ NO MAN C EXPLA94 ,_M O!R FACTS >E1 Z X SEEMS 6ME1 EXPLICA# ON ? !ORY4 ,H[ /RANGE X IS T A BIRD1 "U ! =M (A WOODPECK]1 %D PREY ON 9SECTS ON ! GR.D2 T UPL& GEESE : R>ELY OR N"E SWIM1 %D POSSESS WE2$ FEET2 T A ?RU%-L BIRD %D DIVE & FE$ ON SUB-AQUATIC 9SECTS2 & T A PETREL %D H ! HABITS & /RUCTURE FITT+ X =! LIFE ( AN AWK6 & S 9 5D.S O!R CASES4 ,B ON ! VIEW ( EA* SPECIES 3/ANTLY TRY+ 69CR1SE 9 NUMB]1 ) NATURAL SELEC;N ALW R1DY 6ADAPT ! SL[LY V>Y+ DESC5DANTS ( EA* 6ANY UNO3UPI$ OR ILL-O3UPI$ PLACE 9 NATURE1 ^! FACTS C1SE 6BE /RANGE1 OR MIGELY ATTRIBUT$ 6! AG5CY ( SELEC;N4 ,T B1UTY1 AC 6\R S5SE ( X1 IS N UNIV]SAL1 M/ 2 ADMITT$ 0E "O :O W LOOK AT "S V5OM\S SNAKES1 AT "S FI%ES1 & AT C]TA9 HIDE\S BATS )A 4TORT$ RESEMBL.E 6! HUMAN FACE4 ,SEXUAL SELEC;N HAS GIV5 ! MO/ BRILLIANT COL\RS1 ELEGANT PATT]NS1 & O!R ORNA;TS 6! MALES1 & "S"TS 6BO? SEXES ( _M BIRDS1 BUTT]FLIES1 & O!R ANIMALS4 ,) BIRDS X HAS (T5 R5D]$ ! VOICE (! MALE MUSICAL 6! FEMALE1 Z WELL Z 6\R E>S4 ,FL[]S & FRUIT H BE5 R5D]$ 3SPICU\S 0BRILLIANT COL\RS 9 3TRA/ )! GRE5 FOLIAGE1 9 ORD] T ! FL[]S MAY 2 R1DILY SE51 VISIT$ & F]TILIS$ 09SECTS1 &! SE$S 4SEM9AT$ 0BIRDS4 ,H[ X -ES T C]TA9 COL\RS1 S.DS1 & =MS %D GIVE PL1SURE 6MAN &! L[] ANIMALS1- T IS1 T IS1 H[ ! S5SE ( B1UTY 9 XS SIMPLE/ =M 0 F/ ACQUIR$1- WE D N "K ANY M ?AN H[ C]TA9 OD\RS & FLAV\RS 7 F/ R5D]$ AGREEA#4 ,Z NATURAL SELEC;N ACTS 0-PETI;N1 X ADAPTS & IMPROVES ! 9HABITANTS ( EA* C.TRY ONLY 9 REL,N 6_! CO-9HABITANTS2 S T WE NE$ FEEL NO SURPRISE AT ! SPECIES ( ANY "O C.TRY1 AL? ON ! ORD9>Y VIEW SUPPOS$ 6H BE5 CR1T$ & SPECI,Y ADAPT$ = T C.TRY1 2+ B1T5 & SUPPLANT$ 0! NATURALIS$ PRODUC;NS F ANO!R L&4 ,NOR "\ WE 6M>VEL IF ALL ! 3TRIV.ES 9 NATURE 2 N1 Z F>4 Z WE C JUDGE1 ABSOLUTELY P]FECT1 Z 9 ! CASE EV5 (! HUMAN EYE2 OR IF "S ( !M 2 ABHORR5T 6\R ID1S ( FIT;S4 ,WE NE$ N M>VEL AT ! /+ (! BEE1 :5 US$ AG/ AN 5EMY1 CAUS+ ! BEE'S [N D1?2 AT DR"OS 2+ PRODUC$ 9 S* GRT NUMB]S = "O S+LE ACT1 & 2+ !N SLAUS2 OR AT O!R S* CASES4 ,! WOND] 9DE$ IS1 ON ! !ORY ( NATURAL SELEC;N1 T M CASES (! WANT ( ABSOLUTE P]FEC;N H N BE5 DETECT$4 ,! -PLEX & LL "KN LAWS GOV]N+ ! PRODUC;N ( V>IETIES >E ! SAME1 Z F> Z WE C JUDGE1 )! LAWS : H GOV]N$ ! PRODUC;N ( 4T9CT SPECIES4 ,9 BO? CASES PHYSICAL 3DI;NS SEEM 6H PRODUC$ "S DIRECT & DEF9ITE E6ECT1 B H[ M* WE _C SAY4 ,?US1 :5 V>IETIES 5T] ANY NEW /,N1 !Y O3A.N,Y ASSUME "S (! "*S PROP] 6! SPECIES ( T /,N4 ,) BO? V>IETIES & SPECIES1 USE & 4USE SEEM 6H PRODUC$ A 3SID]A# E6ECT2 = X IS IMPOSSI# 6RESI/ ? 3CLU.N :5 WE LOOK1 = 9/.E1 AT ! LO7]-H1D$ DUCK1 : HAS W+S 9CAPA# ( FLILY ! SAME 3DI;N Z 9 ! DOME/IC DUCK2 OR :5 WE LOOK AT ! BURR[+ TUCU-TUCU1 : IS O3A.N,Y BL1 & !N AT C]TA9 MOLES1 : >E HABITU,Y BL & H _! EYES COV]$ ) SK92 OR :5 WE LOOK AT ! BL ANIMALS 9HABIT+ ! D>K CAVES ( ,AM]ICA & ,EUROPE4 ,) V>IETIES & SPECIES1 CORRELAT$ V>I,N SEEMS 6H PLAY$ AN IMPORTANT "P1 S T :5 "O "P HAS BE5 MODIFI$ O!R "PS H BE5 NECESS>ILY MODIFI$4 ,) BO? "PIES &4SPECIES1 REV].NS 6L;G-LO/ "*S O3A.N,Y O3UR4 ,H[ 9EXPLICA# ON ! !ORY ( CRE,N IS ! O3A.NAL APPE>.E ( /RIPES ON ! %\LD]S & LEGS (! S"EAL SPECIES (! HORSE-G5US &( _! HYBRIDS6 ,H[ SIMPLY IS ? FACT EXPLA9$ IF WE 2LIEVE T ^! SPECIES >E ALL DESC5D$ F A /RIP$ PROG5ITOR1 9 ! SAME MANN] Z ! S"EAL DOME/IC BRE$S (! PIGEON >E DESC5D$ F ! BLUE & B>R$ ROCK-PIGEON6 ,ON ! ORD9>Y VIEW ( EA* SPECIES HAV+ BE5 9DEP5D5TLY CR1T$1 :Y %D SPECIFIC "*S1 OR ^? 0: ! SPECIES (! SAME G5US DI6] F EA* O!R1 2 M V>IA# ?AN G5]IC "*S 9 : !Y ALL AGREE8 ,:Y1 = 9/.E1 %D ! COL\R (A FL[] 2 M LIKELY 6V>Y 9 ANY "O SPECIES (A G5US1 IF ! O!R SPECIES POSSESS DI6]5TLY COL\R$ FL[]S1 ?AN IF ALL POSSESS$ ! SAME COL\R$ FL[]S8 ,IF SPECIES >E ONLY WELL-M>K$ V>IETIES1 ( : ! "*S H 2COME 9 A HI< DEGREE P]MAN5T1 WE C "U/& ? FACT2 = !Y H ALR V>I$ S9CE !Y BRAN*$ (F F A -MON PROG5ITOR 9 C]TA9 "*S1 0: !Y H -E 6BE SPECIFIC,Y 4T9CT F EA* O!R2 "!=E ^! SAME "*S WD 2 M LIKELY AG 6V>Y ?AN ! G5]IC "*S : H BE5 9H]IT$ )\T *ANGE = AN IMM5SE P]IOD4 ,X IS 9EXPLICA# ON ! !ORY ( CRE,N :Y A "P DEVELOP$ 9 A V UNUSUAL MANN] 9 SPECIES AL"O (A G5US1 & "!=E1 Z WE MAY NATUR,Y 9F]1 ( GRT IMPORT.E 6T SPECIES1 %D 2 EM95TLY LIA# 6V>I,N2 B1 ON \R VIEW1 ? "P HAS "UG"O1 S9CE ! S"EAL SPECIES BRAN*$ (F F A -MON PROG5ITOR1 AN UNUSUAL AM.T ( V>IABIL;Y & MODIFIC,N1 & "!=E WE MIIA#4 ,B A "P MAY 2 DEVELOP$ 9 ! MO/ UNUSUAL MANN]1 L ! W+ (A BAT1 & YET N 2 M V>IA# ?AN ANY O!R /RUCTURE1 IF ! "P 2 -MON 6_M SUBORD9ATE =MS1 T IS1 IF X HAS BE5 9H]IT$ =A V L;G P]IOD2 = 9 ? CASE1 X W H BE5 R5D]$ 3/ANT 0L;G-3T9U$ NATURAL SELEC;N4 ,GLANC+ AT 9/9CTS1 M>VELL\S Z "S >E1 !Y (F] NO GRT] DI6ICULTY ?AN D CORPOR1L /RUCTURES ON ! !ORY (! NATURAL SELEC;N ( SU3ESSIVE SLI*ITECTURAL P[]S (! HIVE-BEE4 ,HABIT NO D\BT (T5 -ES 96PLAY 9 MODIFY+ 9/9CTS2 B X C]TA9LY IS N 9DISP5SA#1 Z WE SEE 9 ! CASE ( NEUT] 9SECTS1 : L1VE NO PROG5Y 69H]IT ! E6ECTS ( L;G-3T9U$ HABIT4 ,ON ! VIEW ( ALL ! SPECIES (! SAME G5US HAV+ DESC5D$ F A -MON P>5T1 & HAV+ 9H]IT$ M* 9 -MON1 WE C "U/& H[ X IS T ALLI$ SPECIES1 :5 PLAC$ "U WIDELY DI6]5T 3DI;NS ( LIFE1 YET FOLL[ NE>LY ! SAME 9/9CTS2 :Y ! ?RU%ES ( TROPICAL & TEMP]ATE ,S\? ,AM]ICA1 = 9/.E1 L9E _! NE/S ) MUD L \R ,BRITI% SPECIES4 ,ON ! VIEW ( 9/9CTS HAV+ BE5 SL[LY ACQUIR$ "? NATURAL SELEC;N1 WE NE$ N M>VEL AT "S 9/9CTS 2+ N P]FECT & LIA# 6MISTAKES1 & AT _M 9/9CTS CAUS+ O!R ANIMALS 6SU6]4 ,IF SPECIES 2 ONLY WELL-M>K$ & P]MAN5T V>IETIES1 WE C AT ONCE SEE :Y _! CROSS$ (FSPR+ %D FOLL[ ! SAME -PLEX LAWS 9 _! DEGREES & K9DS ( RESEMBL.E 6_! P>5TS1- 9 2+ ABSORB$ 96EA* O!R 0SU3ESSIVE CROSSES1 & 9 O!R S* PO9TS1- Z D ! CROSS$ (FSPR+ ( AC"KL$G$ V>IETIES4 ,? SIMIL>;Y WD 2 A /RANGE FACT1 IF SPECIES _H BE5 9DEP5D5TLY CR1T$ & V>IETIES _H BE5 PRODUC$ "? SECOND>Y LAWS4 ,IF WE ADMIT T ! GEOLOGICAL RECORD IS IMP]FECT 6AN EXTREME DEGREE1 !N ! FACTS1 : ! RECORD DOES GIVE1 /R;GLY SUPPORT ! !ORY ( DESC5T ) MODIFIC,N4 ,NEW SPECIES H -E ON ! /AGE SL[LY & AT SU3ESSIVE 9T]VALS2 &! AM.T ( *ANGE1 AF EQUAL 9T]VALS ( "T1 IS WIDELY DI6]5T 9 DI6]5T GR\PS4 ,! EXT9C;N ( SPECIES &( :OLE GR\PS ( SPECIES : HAS PLAY$ S 3SPICU\S A "P 9 ! HI/ORY (! ORGANIC _W ALM 9EVITABLY FOLL[S F ! PR9CIPLE ( NATURAL SELEC;N2 = OLD =MS >E SUPPLANT$ 0NEW & IMPROV$ =MS4 ,NEI S+LE SPECIES NOR GR\PS ( SPECIES REAPPE> :5 ! *A9 ( ORD9>Y G5],N IS ONCE BROK54 ,! GRADUAL DI6U.N ( DOM9ANT =MS1 )! SL[ MODIFIC,N ( _! DESC5DANTS1 CAUSES ! =MS ( LIFE1 AF L;G 9T]VALS ( "T1 6APPE> Z IF !Y _H *ANG$ SIMULTANE\SLY "?\T ! _W4 ,! FACT (! FOSSIL REMA9S ( EA* =M,N 2+ 9 "S DEGREE 9T]M$IATE 9 "* 2T ! FOSSILS 9 ! =M,NS ABV & 2L1 IS SIMPLY EXPLA9$ 0_! 9T]M$IATE POSI;N 9 ! *A9 ( DESC5T4 ,! GR& FACT T ALL EXT9CT 2+S C 2 CLASS$ ) ALL REC5T 2+S1 NATUR,Y FOLL[S F ! LIV+ & ! EXT9CT 2+ ! (FSPR+ ( -MON P>5TS4 ,Z SPECIES H G5],Y DIV]G$ 9 "* DUR+ _! L;G C\RSE ( DESC5T & MODIFIC,N1 WE C "U/& :Y X IS T ! M ANCI5T =MS1 OR E>LY PROG5ITORS ( EA* GR\P1 S (T5 O3UPY A POSI;N 9 "S DEGREE 9T]M$IATE 2T EXI/+ GR\PS4 ,REC5T =MS >E G5],Y LOOK$ ^U Z 2+1 ON ! :OLE1 HI<] 9 ! SCALE ( ORGANIS,N ?AN ANCI5T =MS2 & !Y M/ 2 HI<]1 9SOF> Z ! LAT] & M IMPROV$ =MS H 3QU]$ ! OLD] & LESS IMPROV$ =MS 9 ! /RU7LE = LIFE2 !Y H AL G5],Y _H _! ORGANS M SPECIALIS$ = DI6]5T FUNC;NS4 ,? FACT IS P]FECTLY -PATI# ) NUM]\S 2+S / RETA9+ SIMPLE & B LL IMPROV$ /RUCTURES1 FITT$ = SIMPLE 3DI;NS ( LIFE2 X IS LIKEWISE -PATI# ) "S =MS HAV+ RETROGRAD$ 9 ORGANIS,N1 0HAV+ 2COME AT EA* /AGE ( DESC5T BETT] FITT$ = NEW & DEGRAD$ HABITS ( LIFE4 ,LA/LY1 ! WOND];L LAW (! L;G 5DUR.E ( ALLI$ =MS ON ! SAME 3T95T1- ( M>SUPIALS 9 ,AU/RALIA1 ( ,ED5TATA 9 ,AM]ICA1 & O!R S* CASES1- IS 9TELLIGI#1 = )9 ! SAME C.TRY ! EXI/+ &! EXT9CT W 2 CLOSELY ALLI$ 0DESC5T4 ,LOOK+ 6GEOGRAPHICAL 4TRIBU;N1 IF WE ADMIT T "! HAS BE5 DUR+ ! L;G C\RSE ( AGES M* MIGR,N F "O "P (! _W 6ANO!R1 [+ 6=M] CLIMATAL & GEOGRAPHICAL *ANGES & 6! _M O3A.NAL & UN"KN M1NS ( 4P]SAL1 !N WE C "U/&1 ON ! !ORY ( DESC5T ) MODIFIC,N1 MO/ (! GRT L1D+ FACTS 9 ,4TRIBU;N4 ,WE C SEE :Y "! %D 2 S /RIK+ A P>ALLELISM 9 ! 4TRIBU;N ( ORGANIC 2+S "?\T SPACE1 & 9 _! GEOLOGICAL SU3ES.N "?\T "T2 = 9 BO? CASES ! 2+S H BE5 3NECT$ 0! BOND ( ORD9>Y G5],N1 &! M1NS ( MODIFIC,N H BE5 ! SAME4 ,WE SEE ! FULL M1N+ (! WOND];L FACT1 : HAS /RUCK E TRAVELL]1 "NLY1 T ON ! SAME 3T95T1 "U ! MO/ DIV]SE 3DI;NS1 "U H1T & COLD1 ON M.TA9 & L[L&1 ON DES]TS & M>%ES1 MO/ (! 9HABITANTS )9 EA* GRT CLASS >E PLA9LY RELAT$2 = !Y >E ! DESC5DANTS (! SAME PROG5ITORS & E>LY COLONI/S4 ,ON ? SAME PR9CIPLE ( =M] MIGR,N1 -B9$ 9 MO/ CASES ) MODIFIC,N1 WE C "U/&1 0! AID (! ,GLACIAL P]IOD1 ! ID5T;Y ( "S FEW PLANTS1 &! CLOSE ALLI.E ( _M O!RS1 ON ! MO/ 4TANT M.TA9S1 & 9 ! NOR!RN & S\!RN TEMP]ATE Z"OS2 & LIKEWISE ! CLOSE ALLI.E ( "S (! 9HABITANTS (! SEA 9 ! NOR!RN & S\!RN TEMP]ATE LATITUDES1 ?\< SEP>AT$ 0! :OLE 9T]TROPICAL OC1N4 ,AL? TWO C.TRIES MAY PRES5T PHYSICAL 3DI;NS Z CLOSELY SIMIL> Z ! SAME SPECIES "E REQUIRE1 WE NE$ FEEL NO SURPRISE AT _! 9HABITANTS 2+ WIDELY DI6]5T1 IF !Y H BE5 =A L;G P]IOD -PLETELY S"U$ F EA* O!R2 = Z ! REL,N ( ORGANISM 6ORGANISM IS ! MO/ IMPORTANT ( ALL REL,NS1 & Z ! TWO C.TRIES W H RCVD COLONI/S AT V>I\S P]IODS & 9 DI6]5T PROPOR;NS1 F "S O!R C.TRY OR F EA* O!R1 ! C\RSE ( MODIFIC,N 9 ! TWO >1S W 9EVITABLY H BE5 DI6]5T4 ,ON ? VIEW ( MIGR,N1 ) SUBSEQU5T MODIFIC,N1 WE SEE :Y OC1NIC ISL&S >E 9HABIT$ 0ONLY FEW SPECIES1 B ( ^!1 :Y _M >E PECULI> OR 5DEMIC =MS4 ,WE CLE>LY SEE :Y SPECIES 2L;G+ 6^? GR\PS ( ANIMALS : _C CROSS WIDE SPACES (! OC1N1 Z FROGS & T]RE/RIAL MAMMALS1 D N 9HABIT OC1NIC ISL&S2 & :Y1 ON ! O!R H&1 NEW & PECULI> SPECIES ( BATS1 ANIMALS : C TRAV]SE ! OC1N1 >E F.D ON ISL&S F> 4TANT F ANY 3T95T4 ,S* CASES Z ! PRES;E ( PECULI> SPECIES ( BATS ON OC1NIC ISL&S &! ABS;E ( ALL O!R T]RE/RIAL MAMMALS1 >E FACTS UTT]LY 9EXPLICA# ON ! !ORY ( 9DEP5D5T ACTS ( CRE,N4 ,! EXI/;E ( CLOSELY ALLI$ OR REPRES5TATIVE SPECIES 9 ANY TWO >1S1 IMPLIES1 ON ! !ORY ( DESC5T ) MODIFIC,N1 T ! SAME P>5T-=MS =M]LY 9HABIT$ BO? >1S2 & WE ALM 9V>IABLY F9D T :]"E _M CLOSELY ALLI$ SPECIES 9HABIT TWO >1S1 "S ID5TICAL SPECIES >E / -MON 6BO?4 ,:]"E _M CLOSELY ALLI$ YET 4T9CT SPECIES O3UR1 D\BT;L =MS & V>IETIES 2L;G+ 6! SAME GR\PS LIKEWISE O3UR4 ,X IS A RULE ( HI< G5]AL;Y T ! 9HABITANTS ( EA* >EA >E RELAT$ 6! 9HABITANTS (! NE>E/ S\RCE :;E IMMIGRANTS MILY ALL PLANTS & ANIMALS (! ,GALAPAGOS ,>*IPELAGO1 ( ,JUAN ,F]N&EZ1 &(! O!R ,AM]ICAN ISL&S1 6! PLANTS & ANIMALS (! NEI*IPELAGO1 &(! O!R ,AFRICAN ISL&S 6! ,AFRICAN MA9L&4 ,X M/ 2 ADMITT$ T ^! FACTS RCV NO EXPLAN,N ON ! !ORY ( CRE,N4 ,! FACT1 Z WE H SE51 T ALL PA/ & PRES5T ORGANIC 2+S C 2 >RANG$ )9 A FEW GRT CLASSES1 9 GR\PS SUBORD9ATE 6GR\PS1 &)! EXT9CT GR\PS (T5 FALL+ 9 2T ! REC5T GR\PS1 IS 9TELLIGI# ON ! !ORY ( NATURAL SELEC;N ) XS 3T+5CIES ( EXT9C;N & DIV]G;E ( "*4 ,ON ^! SAME PR9CIPLES WE SEE H[ X IS1 T ! MUTUAL A69ITIES (! =MS )9 EA* CLASS >E S -PLEX & CIRCUIT\S4 ,WE SEE :Y C]TA9 "*S >E F> M S]VICEA# ?AN O!RS = CLASSIFIC,N2- :Y ADAPTIVE "*S1 ?\< ( P>AM.T IMPORT.E 6! 2+S1 >E ( H>DLY ANY IMPORT.E 9 CLASSIFIC,N2 :Y "*S DERIV$ F RUDI;T>Y "PS1 ?\< ( NO S]VICE 6! 2+S1 >E (T5 ( HI< CLASSIFICATORY VALUE2 & :Y EMBRYOLOGICAL "*S >E (T5 ! MO/ VALUA# ( ALL4 ,! R1L A69ITIES ( ALL ORGANIC 2+S1 9 3TRADIST9C;N 6_! ADAPTIVE RESEMBL.ES1 >E DUE 69H]IT.E OR -MUN;Y ( DESC5T4 ,! ,NATURAL ,SY/EM IS A G5EALOGICAL >RANGE;T1 )! ACQUIR$ GRADES ( DI6];E1 M>K$ 0! T]MS1 V>IETIES1 SPECIES1 G5]A1 FAMILIES1 &C42 & WE H 64COV] ! L9ES ( DESC5T 0! MO/ P]MAN5T "*S :AT"E !Y MAY 2 &( H["E SLI FRAME"W ( B"OS 9 ! H& (A MAN1 W+ (A BAT1 F9 (! PORPOISE1 & LEG (! HORSE1- ! SAME NUMB] ( V]TEBRAE =M+ ! NECK (! GIRA6E &(! ELEPHANT1- & 9NUM]A# O!R S* FACTS1 AT ONCE EXPLA9 !MVS ON ! !ORY ( DESC5T ) SL[ & SLI;Y ( PATT]N 9 ! W+ & 9 ! LEG (A BAT1 ?\< US$ = S* DI6]5T PURPOSE1- 9 ! JAWS & LEGS (A CRAB1- 9 ! PETALS1 /AM5S1 & PI/ILS (A FL[]1 IS LIKEWISE1 6A L>GE EXT5T1 9TELLIGI# ON ! VIEW (! GRADUAL MODIFIC,N ( "PS OR ORGANS1 : 7 ABORIG9,Y ALIKE 9 AN E>LY PROG5ITOR 9 EA* ( ^! CLASSES4 ,ON ! PR9CIPLE ( SU3ESSIVE V>I,NS N ALW SUP]V5+ AT AN E>LY AGE1 & 2+ 9H]IT$ AT A CORRESPOND+ N E>LY P]IOD ( LIFE1 WE CLE>LY SEE :Y ! EMBRYOS ( MAMMALS1 BIRDS1 REPTILES1 & FI%ES %D 2 S CLOSELY SIMIL>1 & S UNLIKE ! ADULT =MS4 ,WE MAY C1SE M>VELL+ AT ! EMBRYO ( AN AIR-BR1?+ MAMMAL OR BIRD HAV+ BRAN*IAL SLITS & >T]IES RUNN+ 9 LOOPS1 L ^? (A FI% : HAS 6BR1! ! AIR 4SOLV$ 9 WAT] 0! AID ( WELL- DEVELOP$ BRAN*IAE4 ,4USE1 AID$ "S"TS 0NATURAL SELEC;N1 W (T5 H REDUC$ ORGANS :5 R5D]$ USE.S "U *ANG$ HABITS OR 3DI;NS ( LIFE2 & WE C "U/& ON ? VIEW ! M1N+ ( RUDI;T>Y ORGANS4 ,B 4USE & SELEC;N W G5],Y ACT ON EA* CR1TURE1 :5 X HAS -E 6MATUR;Y & HAS 6PLAY XS FULL "P 9 ! /RU7LE = EXI/;E1 & W ?US H LL P[] ON AN ORGAN DUR+ E>LY LIFE2 H;E ! ORGAN W N 2 REDUC$ OR R5D]$ RUDI;T>Y AT ? E>LY AGE4 ,! CALF1 = 9/.E1 HAS 9H]IT$ TEE?1 : N"E CUT "? ! GUMS (! UPP] JAW1 F AN E>LY PROG5ITOR HAV+ WELL- DEVELOP$ TEE?2 & WE MAY 2LIEVE1 T ! TEE? 9 ! MATURE ANIMAL 7 =M]LY REDUC$ 04USE1 [+ 6! T;GUE & PALATE1 OR LIPS1 HAV+ 2COME EXCELL5TLY FITT$ "? NATURAL SELEC;N 6BR[SE )\T _! AID2 ":AS 9 ! CALF1 ! TEE? H BE5 LEFT UNA6ECT$1 & ON ! PR9CIPLE ( 9H]IT.E AT CORRESPOND+ AGES H BE5 9H]IT$ F A REMOTE P]IOD 6! PRES5T "D4 ,ON ! VIEW ( EA* ORGANISM ) ALL XS SEP>ATE "PS HAV+ BE5 SPECI,Y CR1T$1 H[ UTT]LY 9EXPLICA# IS X T ORGANS BE>+ ! PLA9 /AMP ( 9UTIL;Y1 S* Z ! TEE? 9 ! EMBRYONIC CALF OR ! %RIVELL$ W+S "U ! SOLD]$ W+COV]S ( _M BEETLES1 %D S FREQU5TLY O3UR4 ,NATURE MAY 2 SD 6H TAK5 PA9S 6REV1L H] S*EME ( MODIFIC,N1 0M1NS ( RUDI;T>Y ORGANS1 ( EMBRYOLOGICAL & HOMOLOG\S /RUCTURES1 B WE >E TOO BL 6"U/& H] M1N+4 ,I H N[ RECAPITULAT$ ! FACTS & 3SID],NS : H ?OR\I,NS2 AID$ 9 AN IMPORTANT MANN] 0! 9H]IT$ E6ECTS (! USE & 4USE ( "PS2 & 9 AN UNIMPORTANT MANN]1 T IS 9 REL,N 6ADAPTIVE /RUCTURES1 :E!R PA/ OR PRES5T1 0! DIRECT AC;N ( EXT]NAL 3DI;NS1 & 0V>I,NS : SEEM 6U 9 \R IGNOR.E 6>ISE SPONTANE\SLY4 ,X APPE>S T ,I =M]LY "URAT$ ! FREQU5CY & VALUE ( ^! LATT] =MS ( V>I,N1 Z L1D+ 6P]MAN5T MODIFIC,NS ( /RUCTURE 9DEP5D5TLY ( NATURAL SELEC;N4 ,B Z MY 3CLU.NS H LATELY BE5 M* MISREPRES5T$1 & X HAS BE5 /AT$ T ,I ATTRIBUTE ! MODIFIC,N ( SPECIES EXCLUSIVELY 6NATURAL SELEC;N1 ,I MAY 2 P]MITT$ 6REM>K T 9 ! F/ EDI;N ( ? "W1 & SUBSEQU5TLY1 ,I PLAC$ 9 A MO/ 3SPICU\S POSI;N- "NLY1 AT ! CLOSE (! ,9TRODUC;N- ! FOLL[+ ^WS3 8,I AM 3V9C$ T NATURAL SELEC;N HAS BE5 ! MA9 B N ! EXCLUSIVE M1NS ( MODIFIC,N40 ,? HAS BE5 ( NO AVAIL4 ,GRT IS ! P[] ( /1DY MISREPRES5T,N2 B ! HI/ORY ( SCI;E %[S T =TUNATELY ? P[] DOES N L;G 5DURE4 ,X C H>DLY 2 SUPPOS$ T A FALSE !ORY WD EXPLA91 9 S SATISFACTORY A MANN] Z DOES ! !ORY ( NATURAL SELEC;N1 ! S"EAL L>GE CLASSES ( FACTS ABV SPECIFI$4 ,X HAS REC5TLY BE5 OBJECT$ T ? IS AN UNSAFE ME?OD ( >GU+2 B X IS A ME?OD US$ 9 JUDG+ (! -MON EV5TS ( LIFE1 & HAS (T5 BE5 US$ 0! GRTE/ NATURAL PHILOSOPH]S4 ,! UNDULATORY !ORY ( LIRIV$ AT2 &! 2LIEF 9 ! REVOLU;N (! E>? ON XS [N AXIS 0 UNTIL LATELY SUPPORT$ 0H>DLY ANY DIRECT EVID;E4 ,X IS NO VALID OBJEC;N T SCI;E Z YET ?R[S NO LI HI<] PRO#M (! ESS;E OR ORIG9 ( LIFE4 ,:O C EXPLA9 :AT IS ! ESS;E (! ATTRAC;N ( GRAV;Y8 ,NO "O N[ OBJECTS 6FOLL[+ \ ! RESULTS 3SEQU5T ON ? UN"KN ELE;T ( ATTRAC;N2 NOT)/&+ T ,LEIBNITZ =M]LY A3US$ ,NEWTON ( 9TRODUC+ 8O3ULT QUALITIES & MIRACLES 96PHILOSOPHY40 ,I SEE NO GD R1SON :Y ! VIEWS GIV5 9 ? VOLUME %D %OCK ! RELIGI\S FEEL+S ( ANY "O4 ,X IS SATISFACTORY1 Z %[+ H[ TRANSI5T S* IMPRES.NS >E1 6REMEMB] T ! GRTE/ 4COV]Y "E MADE 0MAN1 "NLY1 ! LAW ( ! ATTRAC;N ( GRAV;Y1 0 AL ATTACK$ 0,LEIBNITZ1 8Z SUBV]SIVE ( NATURAL1 & 9F]5TI,Y ( REV1L$1 RELIGION40 ,A CELEBRAT$ AU?OR & DIV9E HAS WRITT5 6ME T 8HE HAS GRADU,Y LE>NT 6SEE T X IS J Z NO# A 3CEP;N (! ,DE;Y 62LIEVE T ,HE CR1T$ A FEW ORIG9AL =MS CAPA# ( SELF- DEVELOP;T 96O!R & NE$;L =MS1 Z 62LIEVE T ,HE REQUIR$ A FRE% ACT ( CRE,N 6SUPPLY ! VOIDS CAUS$ 0! AC;N ( ,8 LAWS40 ,:Y1 X MAY 2 ASK$1 UNTIL REC5TLY DID NE>LY ALL ! MO/ EM95T LIV+ NATURALI/S & GEOLOGI/S 4BELIEVE 9 ! MUTABIL;Y ( SPECIES8 ,X _C 2 ASS]T$ T ORGANIC 2+S 9 A /ATE ( NATURE >E SUBJECT 6NO V>I,N2 X _C 2 PROV$ T ! AM.T ( V>I,N 9 ! C\RSE ( L;G AGES IS A LIMIT$ QUAL;Y2 NO CLE> 4T9C;N HAS BE51 OR C BE1 DRAWN 2T SPECIES & WELL-M>K$ V>IETIES4 ,X _C 2 MA9TA9$ T SPECIES :5 9T]CROSS$ >E 9V>IABLY /]ILE1 & V>IETIES 9V>IABLY F]TILE2 OR T /]IL;Y IS A SPECIAL 5D[;T & SIGN ( CRE,N4 ,! 2LIEF T SPECIES 7 IMMUTA# PRODUC;NS 0 ALM UNAVOIDA# Z L;G Z ! HI/ORY (! _W 0 ?"\ 6BE ( %ORT DUR,N2 & N[ T WE H ACQUIR$ "S IDEA (! LAPSE ( "T1 WE >E TOO APT 6ASSUME1 )\T PRO(1 T ! GEOLOGICAL RECORD IS S P]FECT T X WD H AF=D$ U PLA9 EVID;E (! MUT,N ( SPECIES1 IF !Y _H "UG"O MUT,N4 ,B ! *IEF CAUSE ( \R NATURAL UNWILL+;S 6ADMIT T "O SPECIES HAS GIV5 BIR? 6CLE> & 4T9CT SPECIES1 IS T WE >E ALW SL[ 9 ADMITT+ GRT *ANGES ( : WE D N SEE ! /EPS4 ,! DI6ICULTY IS ! SAME Z T FELT 0S _M GEOLOGI/S1 :5 ,LYELL F/ 9SI/$ T L;G L9ES ( 9L& CLI6S _H BE5 =M$1 & GRT VALLEYS EXCAVAT$1 0! AG5CIES : WE SEE / AT "W4 ,! M9D _C POSSIBLY GRASP ! FULL M1N+ (! T]M ( EV5 A MILLION YE>S2 X _C ADD UP & P]CV ! FULL E6ECTS ( _M SLII,NS1 A3UMULAT$ DUR+ AN ALM 9F9ITE NUMB] ( G5],NS4 ,AL? ,I AM FULLY 3V9C$ (! TRU? (! VIEWS GIV5 9 ? VOLUME "U ! =M ( AN AB/RACT1 ,I 0NO M1NS EXPECT 63V9CE EXP]I;ED NATURALI/S ^: M9DS >E /OCK$ )A MULTITUDE ( FACTS ALL VIEW$1 DUR+ A L;G C\RSE ( YE>S1 F A PO9T ( VIEW DIRECTLY OPPOSITE 6M9E4 ,X IS S EASY 6HIDE \R IGNOR.E "U S* EXPRES.NS Z ! 8PLAN ( CRE,N0 OR 8UN;Y ( DESIGN10 &C41 & 6?9K T WE GIVE AN EXPLAN,N :5 WE ONLY RE/ATE A FACT4 ,ANY "O ^: 4POSI;N L1DS HM 6ATTA* M WEIE MUTA# W D GD S]VICE 03SCI5TI\SLY EXPRESS+ 8 3VIC;N2 = ?US ONLY C ! LOAD ( PREJUDICE 0: ? SUBJECT IS OV]:ELM$ 2 REMOV$4 ,S"EAL EM95T NATURALI/S H ( LATE PUBLI%$ _! 2LIEF T A MULTITUDE ( REPUT$ SPECIES 9 EA* G5US >E N R1L SPECIES2 B T O!R SPECIES >E R1L1 T IS1 H BE5 9DEP5D5TLY CR1T$4 ,? SEEMS 6ME A /RANGE 3CLU.N 6>RIVE AT4 ,!Y ADMIT T A MULTITUDE ( =MS1 : TILL LATELY !Y !MVS ?"\ 7 SPECIAL CRE,NS1 & : >E / ?US LOOK$ AT 0! MAJOR;Y ( NATURALI/S1 & : 3SEQU5TLY H ALL ! EXT]NAL "*I/IC F1TURES ( TRUE SPECIES1- !Y ADMIT T ^! H BE5 PRODUC$ 0V>I,N1 B !Y REFUSE 6EXT5D ! SAME VIEW 6O!R & SLIE ! CR1T$ =MS ( LIFE1 & : >E ^? PRODUC$ 0SECOND>Y LAWS4 ,!Y ADMIT V>I,N Z A V]A CAUSA 9 "O CASE1 !Y >BITR>ILY REJECT X 9 ANO!R1 )\T ASSIGN+ ANY 4T9C;N 9 ! TWO CASES4 ,! "D W -E :5 ? W 2 GIV5 Z A CURI\S ILLU/R,N (! BL;S ( PRECONCEIV$ OP9ION4 ,^! AU?ORS SEEM NO M />TL$ AT A MIRACUL\S ACT ( CRE,N ?AN AT AN ORD9>Y BIR?4 ,B D !Y RE,Y 2LIEVE T AT 9NUM]A# P]IODS 9 ! E>?'S HI/ORY C]TA9 ELE;TAL ATOMS H BE5 -M&$ SU45LY 6FLA% 96LIV+ TISSUES8 ,D !Y 2LIEVE T AT EA* SUPPOS$ ACT ( CRE,N "O 9DIVIDUAL OR _M 7 PRODUC$8 ,7 ALL ! 9F9ITELY NUM]\S K9DS ( ANIMALS & PLANTS CR1T$ Z E7S OR SE$1 OR Z FULL GR[N8 & 9 ! CASE ( MAMMALS1 7 !Y CR1T$ BE>+ ! FALSE M>KS ( N\RI%;T F ! "M'S WOMB8 ,UND\BT$LY "S ( ^! SAME "QS _C 2 ANSW]$ 0^? :O 2LIEVE 9 ! APPE>.E OR CRE,N ( ONLY A FEW =MS ( LIFE1 OR ( "S "O =M AL"O4 ,X HAS BE5 MA9TA9$ 0S"EAL AU?ORS T X IS Z EASY 62LIEVE 9 ! CRE,N ( A MILLION 2+S Z ( "O2 B ,MAUP]TUIS' PHILOSOPHICAL AXIOM 8( L1/ AC;N0 L1DS ! M9D M WILL+LY 6ADMIT ! SMALL] NUMB]2 & C]TA9LY WE "\ N 62LIEVE T 9NUM]A# 2+S )9 EA* GRT CLASS H BE5 CR1T$ ) PLA91 B DECEPTIVE1 M>KS ( DESC5T F A S+LE P>5T4 ,Z A RECORD (A =M] /ATE ( ?+S1 ,I H RETA9$ 9 ! =EGO+ P>AGRAPHS1 & ELSE":1 S"EAL S5T;ES : IMPLY T NATURALI/S 2LIEVE 9 ! SEP>ATE CRE,N ( EA* SPECIES2 & ,I H BE5 M* C5SUR$ = HAV+ ?US EXPRESS$ MYF4 ,B UND\BT$LY ? 0 ! G5]AL 2LIEF :5 ! F/ EDI;N (! PRES5T "W APPE>$4 ,I =M]LY SPOKE 6V _M NATURALI/S ON ! SUBJECT ( EVOLU;N1 & N"E ONCE MET ) ANY SYMPA!TIC AGREE;T4 ,X IS PROBA# T "S DID !N 2LIEVE 9 EVOLU;N1 B !Y 7 EI SIL5T1 OR EXPRESS$ !MVS S AMBIGU\SLY T X 0 N EASY 6"U/& _! M1N+4 ,N[ ?+S >E :OLLY *ANG$1 & ALM E NATURALI/ ADMITS ! GRT PR9CIPLE ( EVOLU;N4 ,"! >E1 H["E1 "S :O / ?9K T SPECIES H SU45LY GIV5 BIR?1 "? Q UNEXPLA9$ M1NS1 6NEW & TOT,Y DI6]5T =MS3 B1 Z ,I H ATTEMPT$ 6%[1 WEIE SU45LY DEVELOP$ 9 AN 9EXPLICA# MANN] F OLD & WIDELY DI6]5T =MS1 OV] ! OLD 2LIEF 9 ! CRE,N ( SPECIES F ! DU/ (! E>?4 ,X MAY 2 ASK$ H[ F> ,I EXT5D ! DOCTR9E (! MODIFIC,N ( SPECIES4 ,! "Q IS DI6ICULT 6ANSW]1 2C ! M 4T9CT ! =MS >E : WE 3SID]1 0S M* ! >GU;TS 9 FAV\R ( -MUN;Y ( DESC5T 2COME FEW] 9 NUMB] & LESS 9 =CE4 ,B "S >GU;TS (! GRTE/ WEI4 ,ALL ! MEMB]S ( :OLE CLASSES >E 3NECT$ TGR 0A *A9 ( A69ITIES1 & ALL C 2 CLASS$ ON ! SAME PR9CIPLE1 9 GR\PS SUBORD9ATE 6GR\PS4 ,FOSSIL REMA9S "S"TS T5D 6FILL UP V WIDE 9T]VALS 2T EXI/+ ORD]S4 ,ORGANS 9 A RUDI;T>Y 3DI;N PLA9LY %[ T AN E>LY PROG5ITOR _H ! ORGAN 9 A FULLY DEVELOP$ 3DI;N2 & ? 9 "S CASES IMPLIES AN ENORM\S AM.T ( MODIFIC,N 9 ! DESC5DANTS4 ,"?\T :OLE CLASSES V>I\S /RUCTURES >E =M$ ON ! SAME PATT]N1 & AT A V E>LY AGE ! EMBRYOS CLOSELY RESEM# EA* O!R4 ,"!=E ,I _C D\BT T ! !ORY ( DESC5T ) MODIFIC,N EMBRACES ALL ! MEMB]S (! SAME GRT CLASS OR K+DOM4 ,I 2LIEVE T ANIMALS >E DESC5D$ F AT MO/ ONLY F\R OR FIVE PROG5ITORS1 & PLANTS F AN EQUAL OR LESS] NUMB]4 ,ANALOGY WD L1D ME "O /EP F>!R1 "NLY1 6! 2LIEF T ALL ANIMALS & PLANTS >E DESC5D$ F "S "O PROTOTYPE4 ,B ANALOGY MAY 2 A DECEIT;L GUIDE4 ,N"E!.S ALL LIV+ ?+S H M* 9 -MON1 9 _! *EMICAL -POSI;N1 _! CELLUL> /RUCTURE1 _! LAWS ( GR[?1 & _! LIABIL;Y 69JURI\S 9FLU;ES4 ,WE SEE ? EV5 9 S TRIFL+ A FACT Z T ! SAME POISON (T5 SIMIL>LY A6ECTS PLANTS & ANIMALS2 OR T ! POISON SECRET$ 0! GALLFLY PRODUCES MON/R\S GR[?S ON ! WILD ROSE OR OAK- TREE4 ,) ALL ORGANIC 2+S EXCEPT+ P]H "S (! V L[E/1 SEXUAL PRODUC;N SEEMS 6BE ESS5TI,Y SIMIL>4 ,) ALL1 Z F> Z IS AT PRES5T "KN ! G]M9AL VESICLE IS ! SAME2 S T ALL ORGANISMS />T F A -MON ORIG94 ,IF WE LOOK EV5 6! TWO MA9 DIVI.NS- "NLY1 6! ANIMAL & VEGETA# K+DOMS- C]TA9 L[ =MS >E S F> 9T]M$IATE 9 "* T NATURALI/S H 4PUT$ 6: K+DOM !Y %D 2 REF]R$4 ,Z ,PROFESSOR ,ASA ,GRAY HAS REM>K$1 8,! SPORES & O!R REPRODUCTIVE BODIES ( _M (! L[] ALGAE MAY CLAIM 6H F/ A "*I/IC,Y ANIMAL1 & !N AN UNEQUIVOC,Y VEGETA# EXI/;E40 ,"!=E1 ON ! PR9CIPLE ( NATURAL SELEC;N ) DIV]G;E ( "*1 X DOES N SEEM 9CR$I# T1 F S* L[ & 9T]M$IATE =M1 BO? ANIMALS & PLANTS MAY H BE5 DEVELOP$2 &1 IF WE ADMIT ?1 WE M/ LIKEWISE ADMIT T ALL ! ORGANIC 2+S : H "E LIV$ ON ? E>? MAY 2 DESC5D$ F "S "O PRIMORDIAL =M4 ,B ? 9F];E IS *IEFLY GR.D$ ON ANALOGY & X IS IMMAT]IAL :E!R OR N X 2 A3EPT$4 ,NO D\BT X IS POSSI#1 Z ,MR4 ,G4 ,H4 ,LEWES HAS URG$1 T AT ! F/ -M;E;T ( LIFE _M DI6]5T =MS 7 EVOLV$2 B IF S WE MAY 3CLUDE T ONLY A V FEW H LEFT MODIFI$ DESC5DANTS4 ,=1 Z ,I H REC5TLY REM>K$ 9 REG>D 6! MEMB]S ( EA* GRT K+DOM1 S* Z ! ,V]TEBRATA1 ,>TICULATA1 &C41 WE H 4T9CT EVID;E 9 _! EMBRYOLOGICAL HOMOLOG\S & RUDI;T>Y /RUCTURES T )9 EA* K+DOM ALL ! MEMB]S >E DESC5D$ F A S+LE PROG5ITOR4 ,:5 ! VIEWS ADV.ED 0ME 9 ? VOLUME1 & 0,MR4 ,WALLACE1 OR :5 ANALOG\S VIEWS ON ! ORIG9 ( SPECIES >E G5],Y ADMITT$1 WE C DIMLY =ESEE T "! W 2 A 3SID]A# REVOLU;N 9 NATURAL HI/ORY4 ,SY/EMATI/S W 2 A# 6PURSUE _! LAB\RS Z AT PRES5T2 B !Y W N 2 9CESSANTLY HAUNT$ 0! %AD[Y D\BT :E!R ? OR T =M 2 A TRUE SPECIES4 ,?1 ,I FEEL SURE & ,I SP1K AF EXP]I;E1 W 2 NO SLIE GD SPECIES W C1SE4 ,SY/EMATI/S W H ONLY 6DECIDE 7N T ? W 2 EASY7 :E!R ANY =M 2 SU6ICI5TLY 3/ANT & 4T9CT F O!R =MS1 6BE CAPA# ( DEF9I;N2 & IF DEF9A#1 :E!R ! DI6];ES 2 SU6ICI5TLY IMPORTANT 6DES]VE A SPECIFIC "N4 ,? LATT] PO9T W 2COME A F> M ESS5TIAL 3SID],N ?AN X IS AT PRES5T2 = DI6];ES1 H["E SLIE LOOK$ AT 0MO/ NATURALI/S Z SU6ICI5T 6RAISE BO? =MS 6! RANK ( SPECIES4 ,"HAF WE % 2 -PELL$ 6AC"KL$GE T ! ONLY 4T9C;N 2T SPECIES & WELL-M>K$ V>IETIES IS1 T ! LATT] >E "KN1 OR 2LIEV$1 6BE 3NECT$ AT ! PRES5T "D 09T]M$IATE GRAD,NS1 ":AS SPECIES 7 =M]LY ?US 3NECT$4 ,H;E1 )\T REJECT+ ! 3SID],N (! PRES5T EXI/;E ( 9T]M$IATE GRAD,NS 2T ANY TWO =MS WE % 2 L$ 6WEI< M C>E;LLY & 6VALUE HI<] ! ACTUAL AM.T ( DI6];E 2T !M4 ,X IS Q POSSI# T =MS N[ G5],Y AC"KL$G$ 6BE M]ELY V>IETIES MAY "HAF 2 ?"\ WOR?Y ( SPECIFIC "NS2 & 9 ? CASE SCI5TIFIC & -MON LANGUAGE W -E 96A3ORD.E4 ,9 %ORT1 WE % H 6TR1T SPECIES 9 ! SAME MANN] Z ^? NATURALI/S TR1T G5]A1 :O ADMIT T G5]A >E M]ELY >TIFICIAL -B9,NS MADE = 3V5I;E4 ,? MAY N 2 A *E]+ PROSPECT2 B WE % AT L1/ 2 FREE F ! VA9 SE>* =! UNDISCOV]$ & UNDISCOV]A# ESS;E ( ! T]M SPECIES4 ,! O!R & M G5]AL DE"P;TS ( NATURAL HI/ORY W RISE GRTLY 9 9T]E/4 ,! T]MS US$ 0NATURALI/S1 ( A69;Y1 REL,N%IP1 -MUN;Y ( TYPE1 PAT]N;Y1 MORPHOLOGY1 ADAPTIVE "*S1 RUDI;T>Y & ABORT$ ORGANS1 &C41 W C1SE 6BE METAPHORICAL1 & W H A PLA9 SIGNIFIC,N4 ,:5 WE NO L;G] LOOK AT AN ORGANIC 2+ Z A SAVAGE LOOKS AT A %IP1 Z "S?+ :OLLY 2Y 8 -PREH5.N2 :5 WE REG>D E PRODUC;N ( NATURE Z "O : HAS _H A L;G HI/ORY2 :5 WE 3TEMPLATE E -PLEX /RUCTURE & 9/9CT Z ! SUMM+ UP ( _M 3TRIV.ES1 EA* USE;L 6! POSSESSOR1 9 ! SAME WAY Z ANY GRT ME*ANICAL 9V5;N IS ! SUMM+ UP (! LAB\R1 ! EXP]I;E1 ! R1SON1 & EV5 ! BL"US ( NUM]\S "WM52 :5 WE ?US VIEW EA* ORGANIC 2+1 H[ F> M 9T]E/+- ,I SP1K F EXP]I;E- DOES ! /UDY ( NATURAL HI/ORY 2COME6 ,A GR& & ALM UNTRO45 FIELD ( 9QUIRY W 2 OP5$1 ON ! CAUSES & LAWS ( V>I,N1 ON CORREL,N1 ON ! E6ECTS ( USE & 4USE1 ON ! DIRECT AC;N ( EXT]NAL 3DI;NS1 & S =?4 ,! /UDY ( DOME/IC PRODUC;NS W RISE IMM5SELY 9 VALUE4 ,A NEW V>IETY RAIS$ 0MAN W 2 A M IMPORTANT & 9T]E/+ SUBJECT = /UDY ?AN "O M SPECIES A4$ 6! 9F9ITUDE ( ALR RECORD$ SPECIES4 ,\R CLASSIFIC,NS W -E 6BE1 Z F> Z !Y C 2 S MADE1 G5EALOGIES2 & W !N TRULY GIVE :AT MAY 2 CALL$ ! PLAN ( CRE,N4 ,! RULES = CLASSIFY+ W NO D\BT 2COME SIMPL] :5 WE H A DEF9ITE OBJECT 9 VIEW4 ,WE POSSESS NO P$IGREES OR >MORIAL BE>+S2 & WE H 64COV] & TRACE ! _M DIV]G+ L9ES ( DESC5T 9 \R NATURAL G5EALOGIES1 0"*S ( ANY K9D : H L;G BE5 9H]IT$4 ,RUDI;T>Y ORGANS W SP1K 9FALLIBLY ) RESPECT 6! NATURE ( L;G-LO/ /RUCTURES4 ,SPECIES & GR\PS ( SPECIES : >E CALL$ AB]RANT1 & : MAY FANCI;LLY 2 CALL$ LIV+ FOSSILS1 W AID U 9 =M+ A PICTURE (! ANCI5T =MS ( LIFE4 ,EMBRYOLOGY W (T5 REV1L 6U ! /RUCTURE1 9 "S DEGREE OBSCUR$1 (! PROTOTYPE ( EA* GRT CLASS4 ,:5 WE FEEL ASSUR$ T ALL ! 9DIVIDUALS (! SAME SPECIES1 & ALL ! CLOSELY ALLI$ SPECIES ( MO/ G5]A1 H )9 A N V REMOTE P]IOD DESC5D$ F "O P>5T1 & H MIGRAT$ F "S "O BIR?-PLACE2 & :5 WE BETT] "K ! _M M1NS ( MIGR,N1 !N1 0! LI+ ! DI6];ES 2T ! 9HABITANTS (! SEA ON ! OPPOSITE SIDES (A 3T95T1 &! NATURE (! V>I\S 9HABITANTS ON T 3T95T1 9 REL,N 6_! APP>5T M1NS ( IMMIGR,N1 "S LI? ) XS IMB$D$ REMA9S M/ N 2 LOOK$ AT Z A WELL-FILL$ MUSEUM1 B Z A POOR COLLEC;N MADE AT HAZ>D & AT R>E 9T]VALS4 ,! A3UMUL,N ( EA* GRT FOSSILIF]\S =M,N W 2 RECOGNIS$ Z HAV+ DEP5D$ ON AN UNUSUAL 3CURR;E ( FAV\RA# CIRCUM/.ES1 &! BLANK 9T]VALS 2T ! SU3ESSIVE /AGES Z HAV+ BE5 ( VA/ DUR,N4 ,B WE % 2 A# 6GAUGE ) "S SECUR;Y ! DUR,N ( ^! 9T]VALS 0A -P>ISON (! PREC$+ & SU3E$+ ORGANIC =MS4 ,WE M/ 2 CAUTI\S 9 ATTEMPT+ 6CORRELATE Z /RICTLY 3TEMPORANE\S TWO =M,NS1 : D N 9CLUDE _M ID5TICAL SPECIES1 0! G5]AL SU3ES.N (! =MS ( LIFE4 ,Z SPECIES >E PRODUC$ & EXT]M9AT$ 0SL[LY ACT+ & / EXI/+ CAUSES1 & N 0MIRACUL\S ACTS ( CRE,N2 & Z ! MO/ IMPORTANT ( ALL CAUSES ( ORGANIC *ANGE IS "O : IS ALM 9DEP5D5T ( ALT]$ & P]H SU45LY ALT]$ PHYSICAL 3DI;NS1 "NLY1 ! MUTUAL REL,N ( ORGANISM 6ORGANISM1- ! IMPROVE;T ( "O ORGANISM 5TAIL+ ! IMPROVE;T OR ! EXT]M9,N ( O!RS2 X FOLL[S1 T ! AM.T ( ORGANIC *ANGE 9 ! FOSSILS ( 3SECUTIVE =M,NS PROBABLY S]VES Z A FAIR M1SURE (! RELATIVE ?\< N ACTUAL LAPSE ( "T4 ,A NUMB] ( SPECIES1 H["E1 KEEP+ 9 A BODY MI M IMPORTANT RESE>*ES4 ,PSY*OLOGY W 2 SECURELY BAS$ ON ! F.D,N ALR WELL LAID 0,MR4 ,H]B]T ,SP;ER1 T (! NEC ACQUIRE;T ( EA* M5TAL P[] & CAPAC;Y 0GRAD,N4 ,M* LIY CAUSES1 L ^? DET]M9+ ! BIR? & D1? (! 9DIVIDUAL4 ,:5 ,I VIEW ALL 2+S N Z SPECIAL CRE,NS1 B Z ! L91L DESC5DANTS ( "S FEW 2+S : LIV$ L;G 2F ! F/ B$ (! ,CAMBRIAN SY/EM 0 DEPOSIT$1 !Y SEEM 6ME 62COME 5NO#D4 ,JUDG+ F ! PA/1 WE MAY SAFELY 9F] T N "O LIV+ SPECIES W TRANSMIT XS UNALT]$ LIKE;S 6A 4TANT FUTUR;Y4 ,&(! SPECIES N[ LIV+ V FEW W TRANSMIT PROG5Y ( ANY K9D 6A F> 4TANT FUTUR;Y2 =! MANN] 9 : ALL ORGANIC 2+S >E GR\P$1 %[S T ! GRT] NUMB] ( SPECIES 9 EA* G5US1 & ALL ! SPECIES 9 _M G5]A1 H LEFT NO DESC5DANTS1 B H 2COME UTT]LY EXT9CT4 ,WE C S F> TAKE A PROPHETIC GL.E 96FUTUR;Y Z 6=ETELL T X W 2 ! -MON & WIDELY-SPR1D SPECIES1 2L;G+ 6! L>G] & DOM9ANT GR\PS )9 EA* CLASS1 : W ULTIMATELY PREVAIL & PROCR1TE NEW & DOM9ANT SPECIES4 ,Z ALL ! LIV+ =MS ( LIFE >E ! L91L DESC5DANTS ( ^? : LIV$ L;G 2F ! ,CAMBRIAN EPO*1 WE MAY FEEL C]TA9 T ! ORD9>Y SU3ES.N 0G5],N HAS N"E ONCE BE5 BROK51 & T NO CATACLYSM HAS DESOLAT$ ! :OLE _W4 ,H;E WE MAY LOOK ) "S 3FID;E 6SECURE FUTURE ( GRT L5G?4 ,& Z NATURAL SELEC;N "WS SOLELY 0&=! GD ( EA* 2+1 ALL CORPOR1L & M5TAL 5D[;TS W T5D 6PROGRESS T[>DS P]FEC;N4 ,X IS 9T]E/+ 63TEMPLATE A TANGL$ BANK1 CLO!D ) _M PLANTS ( _M K9DS1 ) BIRDS S++ ON ! BU%ES1 ) V>I\S 9SECTS FLITT+ AB1 &) WORMS CRAWL+ "? ! DAMP E>?1 & 6REFLECT T ^! ELABORATELY 3/RUCT$ =MS1 S DI6]5T F EA* O!R1 & DEP5D5T ^U EA* O!R 9 S -PLEX A MANN]1 H ALL BE5 PRODUC$ 0LAWS ACT+ >.D U4 ,^! LAWS1 TAK5 9 ! L>GE/ S5SE1 2+ ,GR[? ) ,REPRODUC;N2 ,9H]IT.E : IS ALM IMPLI$ 0REPRODUC;N2 ,V>IABIL;Y F ! 9DIRECT & DIRECT AC;N (! 3DI;NS ( LIFE & F USE & 4USE3 A ,RATIO ( ,9CR1SE S HI< Z 6L1D 6A ,/RU7LE = ,LIFE1 & Z A 3SEQU;E 6,NATURAL ,SELEC;N1 5TAIL+ ,DIV]G;E ( ,"* &! ,EXT9C;N ( LESS-IMPROV$ =MS4 ,?US1 F ! W> ( NATURE1 F FAM9E & D1?1 ! MO/ EXALT$ OBJECT : WE >E CAPA# ( 3CVG1 "NLY1 ! PRODUC;N (! HI<] ANIMALS1 DIRECTLY FOLL[S4 ,"! IS GR&EUR 9 ? VIEW ( LIFE1 ) XS S"EAL P[]S1 HAV+ BE5 ORIG9,Y BR1!D 0! ,CR1TOR 96A FEW =MS OR 96"O2 & T1 :IL/ ? PLANET HAS G"O CYCL+ ON AC 6! FIX$ LAW ( GRAV;Y1 F S SIMPLE A 2G9N+ 5D.S =MS MO/ B1UTI;L & MO/ WOND];L H BE51 & >E 2+ EVOLV$4 ,,! ,,5D ------------