,,BOOK ;,V #A ,) REG>DS 6JU/ICE & 9JU/ICE WE M/ 7#A7 3SID] :AT K9D ( AC;NS !Y >E 3C]N$ )1 7#B7 :AT SORT ( M1N JU/ICE IS1 & 7#C7 2T :AT EXTREMES ! J ACT IS 9T]M$IATE4 ,\R 9VE/IG,N % FOLL[ ! SAME C\RSE Z ! PREC$+ 4CUS.NS4 ,WE SEE T ALL M5 M1N 0JU/ICE T K9D ( /ATE ( "* : MAKES P 4POS$ 6D :AT IS J & MAKES !M ACT JU/LY & WI% = :AT IS J2 & SIMIL>LY 09JU/ICE T /ATE : MAKES !M ACT UNJU/LY & WI% = :AT IS UNJU/4 ,LET U TOO1 !N1 LAY ? D[N Z A G5]AL BASIS4 ,=! SAME IS N TRUE (! SCI;ES &! FACULTIES Z ( /ATES ( "*4 ,A FACULTY OR A SCI;E : IS "O &! SAME IS HELD 6RELATE 63TR>Y OBJECTS1 B A /ATE ( "* : IS "O ( TWO 3TR>IES DOES N PRODUCE ! 3TR>Y RESULTS2 E4G4 Z A RESULT ( H1L? WE D N D :AT IS ! OPPOSITE ( H1L?Y1 B ONLY :AT IS H1L?Y2 = WE SAY A MAN WALKS H1L?ILY1 :5 HE WALKS Z A H1L?Y MAN WD4 ,N[ (T5 "O 3TR>Y /ATE IS RECOGNIZ$ F XS 3TR>Y1 & (T5 /ATES >E RECOGNIZ$ F ! SUBJECTS T EXHIBIT !M2 = 7,A7 IF GD 3DI;N IS "KN1 BAD 3DI;N AL 2COMES "KN1 & 7,B7 GD 3DI;N IS "KN F ! ?+S T >E 9 GD 3DI;N1 & !Y F X4 ,IF GD 3DI;N IS FIRM;S ( FLE%1 X IS NEC BO? T BAD 3DI;N %D 2 FLA2I;S ( FLE% & T ! :OLE"S %D 2 T : CAUSES FIRM;S 9 FLE%4 ,& X FOLL[S =! MO/ "P T IF "O 3TR>Y IS AMBIGU\S ! O!R AL W 2 AMBIGU\S2 E4G4 IF ,8J0' IS S1 T ,8UNJU/0' W 2 S TOO4 ,N[ ,8JU/ICE0' & ,89JU/ICE0' SEEM 6BE AMBIGU\S1 B 2C _! DI6]5T M1N+S APPROA* NE> 6"O ANO!R ! AMBIGU;Y ESCAPES NOTICE & IS N OBVI\S Z X IS1 -P>ATIVELY1 :5 ! M1N+S >E F> A"P1 E4G4 7= "H ! DI6];E 9 \TW>D =M IS GRT7 Z ! AMBIGU;Y 9 ! USE ( KLEIS =! COLL>-B"O ( AN ANIMAL &= T ) : WE LOCK A DOOR4 ,LET U TAKE Z A />T+- PO9T1 !N1 ! V>I\S M1N+S ( ,8AN UNJU/ MAN0'4 ,BO? ! LAW.S MAN &! GRASP+ & UNFAIR MAN >E ?"\ 6BE UNJU/1 S T EVID5TLY BO? ! LAW-ABID+ &! FAIR MAN W 2 J4 ,! J1 !N1 IS ! LAW;L &! FAIR1 ! UNJU/ ! UNLAW;L &! UNFAIR4 ,S9CE ! UNJU/ MAN IS GRASP+1 HE M/ 2 3C]N$ ) GDS-N ALL GDS1 B ^? ) : PROSP];Y & ADV]S;Y H 6D1 : TAK5 ABSOLUTELY >E ALW GD1 B =A "PICUL> P]SON >E N ALW GD4 ,N[ M5 PRAY =& PURSUE ^! ?+S2 B !Y %D N1 B %D PRAY T ! ?+S T >E GD ABSOLUTELY MAY AL 2 GD = !M1 & %D *OOSE ! ?+S T >E GD = !M4 ,! UNJU/ MAN DOES N ALW *OOSE ! GRT]1 B AL ! LESS-IN ! CASE ( ?+S BAD ABSOLUTELY2 B 2C ! LESS] EVIL IS XF ?"\ 6BE 9 A S5SE GD1 & GRASP+;S IS DIRECT$ AT ! GD1 "!=E HE IS ?"\ 6BE GRASP+4 ,& HE IS UNFAIR2 = ? 3TA9S & IS -MON 6BO?4 ,S9CE ! LAW.S MAN 0 SE5 6BE UNJU/ &! LAW-ABID+ MAN J1 EVID5TLY ALL LAW;L ACTS >E 9 A S5SE J ACTS2 =! ACTS LAID D[N 0! LEGISLATIVE >T >E LAW;L1 & EA* ( ^!1 WE SAY1 IS J4 ,N[ ! LAWS 9 _! 5ACT;TS ON ALL SUBJECTS AIM AT ! -MON ADVANTAGE EI ( ALL OR (! BE/ OR ( ^? :O HOLD P[]1 OR "S?+ (! SORT2 S T 9 "O S5SE WE CALL ^? ACTS J T T5D 6PRODUCE & PRES]VE HAPPI;S & XS -PON5TS =! POLITICAL SOCIETY4 ,&! LAW BIDS U D BO? ! ACTS (A BRAVE MAN 7E4G4 N 6DES]T \R PO/ NOR TAKE 6FLIMS71 & ^? (A TEMP]ATE MAN 7E4G4 N 6-MIT ADULT]Y NOR 6GRATIFY "O'S LU/71 & ^? (A GD-TEMP]$ MAN 7E4G4 N 6/RIKE ANO!R NOR 6SP1K EVIL71 & SIMIL>LY ) REG>D 6! O!R VIRTUES & =MS ( WICK$;S1 -M&+ "S ACTS & =BI4+ O!RS2 &! "RLY-FRAM$ LAW DOES ? "RLY1 &! HA/ILY 3CVD "O LESS WELL4 ,? =M ( JU/ICE1 !N1 IS -PLETE VIRTUE1 B N ABSOLUTELY1 B 9 REL,N 6\R NEI0' IS S WOND];L2 & PROV]BI,Y ,8IN JU/ICE IS E VIRTUE -PREH5D$0'4 ,& X IS -PLETE VIRTUE 9 XS FULLE/ S5SE1 2C X IS ! ACTUAL EX]CISE ( -PLETE VIRTUE4 ,X IS -PLETE 2C HE :O POSSESSES X C EX]CISE 8 VIRTUE N ONLY 9 HMF B T[>DS 8 NEIILY 9 REL,N 6O!R M5 &A MEMB] (A SOCIETY4 ,= ? SAME R1SON JU/ICE1 AL"O (! VIRTUES1 IS ?"\ 6BE ,8ANO!R'S GD0'1 2C X IS RELAT$ 6\R NEIDS HMF & T[>DS 8 FRS1 & ! BE/ MAN IS N HE :O EX]CISES 8 VIRTUE T[>DS HMF B HE :O EX]CISES X T[>DS ANO!R2 = ? IS A DI6ICULT TASK4 ,JU/ICE 9 ? S5SE1 !N1 IS N "P ( VIRTUE B VIRTUE 5TIRE1 NOR IS ! 3TR>Y 9JU/ICE A "P ( VICE B VICE 5TIRE4 ,:AT ! DI6];E IS 2T VIRTUE & JU/ICE 9 ? S5SE IS PLA9 F :AT WE H SD2 !Y >E ! SAME B _! ESS;E IS N ! SAME2 :AT1 Z A REL,N 6"O'S NEIE 9VE/IGAT+ IS ! JU/ICE : IS A "P ( VIRTUE2 = "! IS A JU/ICE ( ? K9D1 Z WE MA9TA94 ,SIMIL>LY X IS ) 9JU/ICE 9 ! "PICUL> S5SE T WE >E 3C]N$4 ,T "! IS S* A ?+ IS 9DICAT$ 0! FACT T :ILE ! MAN :O EXHIBITS 9 AC;N ! O!R =MS ( WICK$;S ACTS WR;GLY 9DE$1 B N GRASP+LY 7E4G4 ! MAN :O ?R[S AWAY 8 %IELD "? C[>DICE OR SP1KS H>%LY "? BAD TEMP] OR FAILS 6HELP A FR ) M"OY "? M1N;S71 :5 A MAN ACTS GRASP+LY HE (T5 EXHIBITS N"O ( ^! VICES1-NO1 NOR ALL TGR1 B C]TA9LY WICK$;S ( "S K9D 7= WE BLAME HM7 & 9JU/ICE4 ,"! IS1 !N1 ANO!R K9D ( 9JU/ICE : IS A "P ( 9JU/ICE 9 ! WIDE S5SE1 &A USE (! ^W ,8UNJU/0' : ANSW]S 6A "P ( :AT IS UNJU/ 9 ! WIDE S5SE ( ,83TR>Y 6! LAW0'4 ,AG IF "O MAN -MITS ADULT]Y =! SAKE ( GA9 & MAKES M"OY 0X1 :ILE ANO!R DOES S AT ! BI4+ ( APPETITE ?\< HE LOSES M"OY & IS P5ALIZ$ = X1 ! LATT] WD 2 HELD 6BE SELF-9DULG5T R ?AN GRASP+1 B ! =M] IS UNJU/1 B N SELF-9DULG5T2 EVID5TLY1 "!=E1 HE IS UNJU/ 0R1SON ( 8 MAK+ GA9 0HIS ACT4 ,AG1 ALL O!R UNJU/ ACTS >E ASCRIB$ 9V>IABLY 6"S "PICUL> K9D ( WICK$;S1 E4G4 ADULT]Y 6SELF-9DULG;E1 ! DES];N (A -RADE 9 BATTLE 6C[>DICE1 PHYSICAL VIOL;E 6ANG]2 B IF A MAN MAKES GA91 8 AC;N IS ASCRIB$ 6NO =M ( WICK$;S B 9JU/ICE4 ,EVID5TLY1 "!=E1 "! IS A"P F 9JU/ICE 9 ! WIDE S5SE ANO!R1 ,8"PICUL>0'1 9JU/ICE : %>ES ! "N & NATURE (! F/1 2C XS DEF9I;N FALLS )9 ! SAME G5US2 =! SIGNIFIC.E ( BO? 3SI/S 9 A REL,N 6"O'S NEIISES F GA92 :ILE ! O!R IS 3C]N$ ) ALL ! OBJECTS ) : ! GD MAN IS 3C]N$4 ,X IS CLE>1 !N1 T "! IS M ?AN "O K9D ( JU/ICE1 & T "! IS "O : IS 4T9CT F VIRTUE 5TIRE2 WE M/ TRY 6GRASP XS G5US & DI6]5TIA4 ,! UNJU/ HAS BE5 DIVID$ 96! UNLAW;L &! UNFAIR1 &! J 96! LAW;L &! FAIR4 ,6! UNLAW;L ANSW]S ! A=E-M5;N$ S5SE ( 9JU/ICE4 ,B S9CE UNFAIR &! UNLAW;L >E N ! SAME1 B >E DI6]5T Z A "P IS F XS :OLE 7= ALL T IS UNFAIR IS UNLAW;L1 B N ALL T IS UNLAW;L IS UNFAIR71 ! UNJU/ & 9JU/ICE 9 ! S5SE (! UNFAIR >E N ! SAME Z B DI6]5T F ! =M] K9D1 Z "P F :OLE2 = 9JU/ICE 9 ? S5SE IS A "P ( 9JU/ICE 9 ! WIDE S5SE1 & SIMIL>LY JU/ICE 9 ! "O S5SE ( JU/ICE 9 ! O!R4 ,"!=E WE M/ SP1K AL AB "PICUL> JU/ICE & "PICUL> & SIMIL>LY AB ! J &! UNJU/4 ,! JU/ICE1 !N1 : ANSW]S 6! :OLE ( VIRTUE1 &! CORRESPOND+ 9JU/ICE1 "O 2+ ! EX]CISE ( VIRTUE Z A :OLE1 &! O!R T ( VICE Z A :OLE1 T[>DS "O'S NEIE 6BE 4T+UI%$ IS EVID5T2 = PRACTIC,Y ! MAJOR;Y (! ACTS -M&$ 0! LAW >E ^? : >E PRESCRIB$ F ! PO9T ( VIEW ( VIRTUE TAK5 Z A :OLE2 =! LAW BIDS U PRACTISE E VIRTUE & =BIDS U 6PRACTISE ANY VICE4 ,&! ?+S T T5D 6PRODUCE VIRTUE TAK5 Z A :OLE >E ^? (! ACTS PRESCRIB$ 0! LAW : H BE5 PRESCRIB$ )A VIEW 6$UC,N =! -MON GD4 ,B ) REG>D 6! $UC,N (! 9DIVIDUAL Z S*1 : MAKES HM )\T QUALIFIC,N A GD MAN1 WE M/ DET]M9E LAT] :E!R ? IS ! FUNC;N (! POLITICAL >T OR ( ANO!R2 = P]H X IS N ! SAME 6BE A GD MAN &A GD CITIZ5 ( ANY /ATE TAK5 AT R&OM4 ,( "PICUL> JU/ICE & T : IS J 9 ! CORRESPOND+ S5SE1 7,A7 "O K9D IS T : IS MANIFE/$ 9 4TRIBU;NS ( HON\R OR M"OY OR ! O!R ?+S T FALL 6BE DIVID$ AM;G ^? :O H A %>E 9 ! 3/ITU;N 7= 9 ^! X IS POSSI# = "O MAN 6H A %>E EI UNEQUAL OR EQUAL 6T ( ANO!R71 & 7,B7 "O IS T : PLAYS A RECTIFY+ "P 9 TRANSAC;NS 2T MAN & MAN4 ,( ? "! >E TWO DIVI.NS2 ( TRANSAC;NS 7#A7 "S >E VOLUNT>Y & 7#B7 O!RS 9VOLUNT>Y- VOLUNT>Y S* TRANSAC;NS Z SALE1 PUR*ASE1 LOAN = 3SUMP;N1 PL$G+1 LOAN = USE1 DEPOSIT+1 LETT+ 7!Y >E CALL$ VOLUNT>Y 2C ! ORIG9 ( ^! TRANSAC;NS IS VOLUNT>Y71 :ILE (! 9VOLUNT>Y 7A7 "S >E CL&E/9E1 S* Z !FT1 ADULT]Y1 POISON+1 PROCUR+1 5TICE;T ( SLAVES1 ASSASS9,N1 FALSE WIT;S1 & 7B7 O!RS >E VIOL5T1 S* Z ASSAULT1 IMPRISON;T1 MURD]1 RO2]Y ) VIOL;E1 MUTIL,N1 ABUSE1 9SULT4 #C 7,A7 ,WE H %[N T BO? ! UNJU/ MAN &! UNJU/ ACT >E UNFAIR OR UNEQUAL2 N[ X IS CLE> T "! IS AL AN 9T]M$IATE 2T ! TWO UNEQUALS 9VOLV$ 9 EI CASE4 ,& ? IS ! EQUAL2 = 9 ANY K9D ( AC;N 9 : "!'S A M & A LESS "! IS AL :AT IS EQUAL4 ,IF1 !N1 ! UNJU/ IS UNEQUAL1 J IS EQUAL1 Z ALL M5 SUPPOSE X 6BE1 EV5 A"P F >GU;T4 ,& S9CE ! EQUAL IS 9T]M$IATE1 ! J W 2 AN 9T]M$IATE4 ,N[ EQUAL;Y IMPLIES AT L1/ TWO ?+S4 ,! J1 !N1 M/ 2 BO? 9T]M$IATE & EQUAL & RELATIVE 7I4E4 = C]TA9 P]SONS74 ,& S9CE ! EQUALL 9T]M$IATE X M/ 2 2T C]TA9 ?+S 7: >E RESPECTIVELY GRT] & LESS72 EQUAL1 X 9VOLVES TWO ?+S2 QUA J1 X IS = C]TA9 P4 ,! J1 "!=E1 9VOLVES AT L1/ F\R T]MS2 =! P]SONS = :OM X IS 9 FACT J >E TWO1 &! ?+S 9 : X IS MANIFE/$1 ! OBJECTS 4TRIBUT$1 >E TWO4 ,&! SAME EQUAL;Y W EXI/ 2T ! P]SONS & 2T ! ?+S 3C]N$2 = Z ! LATT] ! ?+S 3C]N$->E RELAT$1 S >E ! =M]2 IF !Y >E N EQUAL1 !Y W N H :AT IS EQUAL1 B ? IS ! ORIG9 ( QU>RELS & -PLA9TS-:5 EI EQUALS H & >E AW>D$ UNEQUAL %>ES1 OR UNEQUALS EQUAL %>ES4 ,FUR!R1 ? IS PLA9 F ! FACT T AW>DS %D 2 ,8AC 6M]IT0'2 = ALL M5 AGREE T :AT IS J 9 4TRIBU;N M/ 2 AC 6M]IT 9 "S S5SE1 ?\< !Y D N ALL SPECIFY ! SAME SORT ( M]IT1 B DEMOCRATS ID5TIFY X )! /ATUS ( FREEMAN1 SUPPORT]S ( OLIG>*Y ) W1L? 7OR ) NO# BIR?71 & SUPPORT]S ( >I/OCRACY ) EXCELL;E4 ,! J1 !N1 IS A SPECIES (! PROPOR;NATE 7PROPOR;N 2+ N A PROP]TY ONLY (! K9D ( NUMB] : 3SI/S ( AB/RACT UNITS1 B ( NUMB] 9 G5]AL74 ,= PROPOR;N IS EQUAL;Y ( RATIOS1 & 9VOLVES F\R T]MS AT L1/ 7T 4CRETE PROPOR;N 9VOLVES F\R T]MS IS PLA91 B S DOES 3T9U\S PROPOR;N1 = X USES "O T]M Z TWO & M5;NS X TWICE2 E4G4 ,8Z ! L9E ,A IS 6! L9E ;,B1 S IS ! L9E ;,B 6! L9E ,C0'2 ! L9E ;,B1 !N1 HAS BE5 M5;N$ TWICE1 S T IF ! L9E ;,B 2 ASSUM$ TWICE1 ! PROPOR;NAL T]MS W 2 F\R72 &! J1 TOO1 9VOLVES AT L1/ F\R T]MS1 &! RATIO 2T "O PAIR IS ! SAME Z T 2T ! O!R PAIR2 = "! IS A SIMIL> 4T9C;N 2T ! P]SONS & 2T ! ?+S4 ,Z ! T]M ;,A1 !N1 IS TO ;,B1 S W ;,C 2 TO ;,D1 & "!=E1 ALT]N&O1 Z ,A IS TO ;,C1 ;,B W 2 TO ;,D4 ,"!=E AL ! :OLE IS 9 ! SAME RATIO 6! :OLE2 & ? C\PL+ ! 4TRIBU;N E6ECTS1 &1 IF ! T]MS >E S -B9$1 E6ECTS JU/LY4 ,! 3JUNC;N1 !N1 (! T]M ;,A ) ;,C &( ;,B ) ;,D IS :AT IS J 9 4TRIBU;N1 & ? SPECIES (! J IS 9T]M$IATE1 &! UNJU/ IS :AT VIOLATES ! PROPOR;N2 =! PROPOR;NAL IS 9T]M$IATE1 &! J IS PROPOR;NAL4 7,MA!MATICIANS CALL ? K9D ( PROPOR;N GEOMETRICAL2 = X IS 9 GEOMETRICAL PROPOR;N T X FOLL[S T ! :OLE IS 6! :OLE Z EI "P IS 6! CORRESPOND+ "P47 ,? PROPOR;N IS N 3T9U\S2 = WE _C GET A S+LE T]M /&+ =A P]SON &A ?+4 ,?1 !N1 IS :AT ! J IS-! PROPOR;NAL2 ! UNJU/ IS :AT VIOLATES ! PROPOR;N4 ,H;E "O T]M 2COMES TOO GRT1 ! O!R TOO SMALL1 Z 9DE$ HAPP5S 9 PRACTICE2 =! MAN :O ACTS UNJU/LY HAS TOO M*1 &! MAN :O IS UNJU/LY TR1T$ TOO LL1 ( :AT IS GD4 ,9 ! CASE ( EVIL ! REV]SE IS TRUE2 =! LESS] EVIL IS RECKON$ A GD 9 -P>ISON )! GRT] EVIL1 S9CE ! LESS] EVIL IS R 6BE *OS5 ?AN ! GRT]1 & :AT IS WOR?Y ( *OICE IS GD1 & :AT IS WOR?I] ( *OICE A GRT] GD4 ,?1 !N1 IS "O SPECIES (! J4 #D 7,B7 ,! REMA9+ "O IS ! RECTIFICATORY1 : >ISES 9 3NEXION ) TRANSAC;NS BO? VOLUNT>Y & 9VOLUNT>Y4 ,? =M (! J HAS A DI6]5T SPECIFIC "* F ! =M]4 ,=! JU/ICE : 4TRIBUTES -MON POSSES.NS IS ALW 9 A3ORD.E )! K9D ( PROPOR;N M5;N$ ABV 7= 9 ! CASE AL 9 : ! 4TRIBU;N IS MADE F ! -MON FUNDS (A "PN]%IP X W 2 AC 6! SAME RATIO : ! FUNDS PUT 96! BUSI;S 0! "PN]S BE> 6"O ANO!R72 &! 9JU/ICE OPPOS$ 6? K9D ( JU/ICE IS T : VIOLATES ! PROPOR;N4 ,B ! JU/ICE 9 TRANSAC;NS 2T MAN & MAN IS A SORT ( EQUAL;Y 9DE$1 &! 9JU/ICE A SORT ( 9EQUAL;Y2 N AC 6T K9D ( PROPOR;N1 H["E1 B AC 6>I?METICAL PROPOR;N4 ,= X MAKES NO DI6];E :E!R A GD MAN HAS DEFRAUD$ A BAD MAN OR A BAD MAN A GD "O1 NOR :E!R X IS A GD OR A BAD MAN T HAS -MITT$ ADULT]Y2 ! LAW LOOKS ONLY 6! 4T9CTIVE "* (! 9JURY1 & TR1TS ! "PIES Z EQUAL1 IF "O IS 9 ! WR;G &! O!R IS 2+ WR;G$1 & IF "O 9FLICT$ 9JURY &! O!R HAS RCVD X4 ,"!=E1 ? K9D ( 9JU/ICE 2+ AN 9EQUAL;Y1 ! JUDGE TRIES 6EQUALIZE X2 = 9 ! CASE AL 9 : "O HAS RCVD &! O!R HAS 9FLICT$ A W.D1 OR "O HAS SLA9 &! O!R BE5 SLA91 ! SU6]+ &! AC;N H BE5 UNEQU,Y 4TRIBUT$2 B ! JUDGE TRIES 6EQUALIZE 0M1NS (! P5ALTY1 TAK+ AWAY F ! GA9 (! ASSAILANT4 ,=! T]M ,8GA9' IS APPLI$ G5],Y 6S* CASES1 EV5 IF X 2 N A T]M APPROPRIATE 6C]TA9 CASES1 E4G4 6! P]SON :O 9FLICTS A W.D& ,8LOSS0' 6! SU6]]2 AT ALL EV5TS :5 ! SU6]+ HAS BE5 E/IMAT$1 ! "O IS CALL$ LOSS &! O!R GA94 ,"!=E ! EQUAL IS 9T]M$IATE 2T ! GRT] &! LESS1 B ! GA9 &! LOSS >E RESPECTIVELY GRT] & LESS 9 3TR>Y WAYS2 M (! GD & LESS (! EVIL >E GA91 &! 3TR>Y IS LOSS2 9T]M$IATE 2T !M IS1 Z WE SAW1 EQUAL1 : WE SAY IS J2 "!=E CORRECTIVE JU/ICE W 2 ! 9T]M$IATE 2T LOSS & GA94 ,? IS :Y1 :5 P 4PUTE1 !Y TAKE REFUGE 9 ! JUDGE2 & 6G 6! JUDGE IS 6G 6JU/ICE2 =! NATURE (! JUDGE IS 6BE A SORT ( ANIMATE JU/ICE2 & !Y SEEK ! JUDGE Z AN 9T]M$IATE1 & 9 "S /ATES !Y CALL JUDGES M$IATORS1 ON ! ASSUMP;N T IF !Y GET :AT IS 9T]M$IATE !Y W GET :AT IS J4 ,! J1 !N1 IS AN 9T]M$IATE1 S9CE ! JUDGE IS S4 ,N[ ! JUDGE RE/ORES EQUAL;Y2 X IS Z ?\< "! 7 A L9E DIVID$ 96UNEQUAL "PS1 & HE TOOK AWAY T 0: ! GRT] SEG;T EXCE$S ! HALF1 & A4$ X 6! SMALL] SEG;T4 ,& :5 ! :OLE HAS BE5 EQU,Y DIVID$1 !N !Y SAY !Y H ,8_! [N'-I4E4 :5 !Y H GOT :AT IS EQUAL4 ,! EQUAL IS 9T]M$IATE 2T ! GRT] & ! LESS] L9E AC 6>I?METICAL PROPOR;N4 ,X IS = ? R1SON AL T X IS CALL$ J 7SIKAION71 2C X IS A DIVI.N 96TWO EQUAL "PS 7SI*A71 J Z IF "O 7 6CALL X SI*AION2 &! JUDGE 7SIKA/ES7 IS "O :O BISECTS 7SI*A/ES74 ,= :5 "S?+ IS SUBTRACT$ F "O ( TWO EQUALS & A4$ 6! O!R1 ! O!R IS 9 EXCESS 0^! TWO2 S9CE IF :AT 0 TAK5 F ! "O _H N BE5 A4$ 6! O!R1 ! LATT] WD H BE5 9 EXCESS 0"O ONLY4 ,X "!=E EXCE$S ! 9T]M$IATE 0"O1 &! 9T]M$IATE EXCE$S 0"O T F : "S?+ 0 TAK54 ,0?1 !N1 WE % RECOGNIZE BO? :AT WE M/ SUBTRACT F T : HAS M1 & :AT WE M/ ADD 6T : HAS LESS2 WE M/ ADD 6! LATT] T 0: ! 9T]M$IATE EXCE$S X1 & SUBTRACT F ! GRTE/ T 0: X EXCE$S ! 9T]M$IATE4 ,LET ! L9ES ,,AA0'1 ,,BB0'1 ,,CC0' 2 EQUAL 6"O ANO!R2 F ! L9E ,,AA0' LET ! SEG;T ,,AE H BE5 SUBTRACT$1 & 6! L9E ,,CC0' LET ! SEG;T ;,,CD H BE5 A4$1 S T ! :OLE L9E ,,DCC0' EXCE$S ! L9E ,,EA0' 0! SEG;T ;,,CD &! SEG;T ,,CF2 "!=E X EXCE$S ! L9E ,,BB0' 0! SEG;T ;,,CD4 7,SEE DIAGRAM47 ,^! "NS1 BO? LOSS & GA91 H -E F VOLUNT>Y EX*ANGE2 = 6H M ?AN "O'S [N IS CALL$ GA9+1 & 6H LESS ?AN "O'S ORIG9AL %>E IS CALL$ LOS+1 E4G4 9 BUY+ & SELL+ & 9 ALL O!R MATT]S 9 : ! LAW HAS LEFT P FREE 6MAKE _! [N T]MS2 B :5 !Y GET NEI M NOR LESS B J :AT 2L;GS 6!MVS1 !Y SAY T !Y H _! [N & T !Y NEI LOSE NOR GA94 ,"!=E ! J IS 9T]M$IATE 2T A SORT ( GA9 &A SORT ( LOSS1 VIZ4 ^? : >E 9VOLUNT>Y2 X 3SI/S 9 HAV+ AN EQUAL AM.T 2F & AF ! TRANSAC;N4 #E ,"S ?9K T RECIPROC;Y IS )\T QUALIFIC,N J1 Z ! ,PY?AGOR1NS SD2 = !Y DEF9$ JU/ICE )\T QUALIFIC,N Z RECIPROC;Y4 ,N[ ,8RECIPROC;Y0' FITS NEI 4TRIBUTIVE NOR RECTIFICATORY JU/ICE-YET P WANT EV5 ! JU/ICE ( ,RHADAMAN?US 6M1N ?3 ,%D A MAN SU6] :AT HE DID1 "R JU/ICE WD 2 D"O -= 9 _M CASES RECIPROC;Y & RECTIFICATORY JU/ICE >E N 9 A3ORD2 E4G4 7#A7 IF AN (FICIAL HAS 9FLICT$ A W.D1 HE %D N 2 W.D$ 9 RETURN1 & IF "S "O HAS W.D$ AN (FICIAL1 HE "\ N 6BE W.D$ ONLY B PUNI%$ 9 A4I;N4 ,FUR!R 7#B7 "! IS A GRT DI6];E 2T A VOLUNT>Y & AN 9VOLUNT>Y ACT4 ,B 9 ASSOCI,NS = EX*ANGE ? SORT ( JU/ICE DOES HOLD M5 TGR-RECIPROC;Y 9 A3ORD.E )A PROPOR;N & N ON ! BASIS ( PRECISELY EQUAL RETURN4 ,= X IS 0PROPOR;NATE REQUITAL T ! C;Y HOLDS TGR4 ,M5 SEEK 6RETURN EI EVIL = EVIL-& IF !Y CANA N D S1 ?9K _! POSI;N M]E SLAV]Y-OR GD = GD-& IF !Y _C D S "! IS NO EX*ANGE1 B X IS 0EX*ANGE T !Y HOLD TGR4 ,? IS :Y !Y GIVE A PROM95T PLACE 6! TEMPLE (! ,GRACES-TO PROMOTE ! REQUITAL ( S]VICES2 = ? IS "*I/IC ( GRACE-WE %D S]VE 9 RETURN "O :O HAS %[N GRACE 6U1 & %D ANO!R "T TAKE ! 9ITIATIVE 9 %[+ X4 ,N[ PROPOR;NATE RETURN IS SECUR$ 0CROSS-3JUNC;N4 ,LET ,A 2 A BUILD]1 ;,B A %OEMAK]1 ;,C A H\SE1 ;,D A %OE4 ,! BUILD]1 !N1 M/ GET F ! %OEMAK] ! LATT]'S "W1 & M/ HMF GIVE HM 9 RETURN 8 [N4 ,IF1 !N1 F/ "! IS PROPOR;NATE EQUAL;Y ( GDS1 & !N RECIPROCAL AC;N TAKES PLACE1 ! RESULT WE M5;N W 2 E6ECT$4 ,IF N1 ! B>GA9 IS N EQUAL1 & DOES N HOLD2 = "! IS NO?+ 6PREV5T ! "W (! "O 2+ BETT] ?AN T ( ! O!R2 !Y M/ "!=E 2 EQUAT$4 7,& ? IS TRUE (! O!R >TS AL2 = !Y WD H BE5 DE/ROY$ IF :AT ! PATI5T SU6]$ _H N BE5 J :AT ! AG5T DID1 &(! SAME AM.T & K9D47 ,= X IS N TWO DOCTORS T ASSOCIATE = EX*ANGE1 B A DOCTOR &A F>M]1 OR 9 G5]AL P :O >E DI6]5T & UNEQUAL2 B ^! M/ 2 EQUAT$4 ,? IS :Y ALL ?+S T >E EX*ANG$ M/ 2 "SH[ -P>A#4 ,X IS = ? 5D T M"OY HAS BE5 9TRODUC$1 & X 2COMES 9 A S5SE AN 9T]M$IATE2 = X M1SURES ALL ?+S1 & "!=E ! EXCESS &! DEFECT-H[ _M %OES >E EQUAL 6A H\SE OR 6A GIV5 AM.T ( FOOD4 ,! NUMB] ( %OES EX*ANG$ =A H\SE 7OR =A GIV5 AM.T ( FOOD7 M/ "!=E CORRESPOND 6! RATIO ( BUILD] 6%OEMAK]4 ,= IF ? 2 N S1 "! W 2 NO EX*ANGE & NO 9T]C\RSE4 ,& ? PROPOR;N W N 2 E6ECT$ UN.S ! GDS >E "SH[ EQUAL4 ,ALL GDS M/ "!=E 2 M1SUR$ 0"S "O ?+1 Z WE SD 2F4 ,N[ ? UNIT IS 9 TRU? DEM&1 : HOLDS ALL ?+S TGR 7= IF M5 DID N NE$ "O ANO!R'S GDS AT ALL1 OR DID N NE$ !M EQU,Y1 "! WD 2 EI NO EX*ANGE OR N ! SAME EX*ANGE72 B M"OY HAS 2COME 03V5;N A SORT ( REPRES5TATIVE ( DEM&2 & ? IS :Y X HAS ! "N ,8M"OY0' 7NOMISMA7-BECAUSE X EXI/S N 0NATURE B 0LAW 7NOMOS7 & X IS 9 \R P[] 6*ANGE X & MAKE X USE.S4 ,"! W1 !N1 2 RECIPROC;Y :5 ! T]MS H BE5 EQUAT$ S T Z F>M] IS 6%OEMAK]1 ! AM.T (! %OEMAK]'S "W IS 6T (! F>M]'S "W = : X EX*ANGES4 ,B WE M/ N BR+ !M 96A FIGURE ( PROPOR;N :5 !Y H ALR EX*ANG$ 7O!RWISE "O EXTREME W H BO? EXCESSES71 B :5 !Y / H _! [N GDS4 ,?US !Y >E EQUALS & ASSOCIATES J 2C ? EQUAL;Y C 2 E6ECT$ 9 _! CASE4 ,LET ,A 2 A F>M]1 ;,C FOOD1 ;,B A %OEMAK]1 ;,D 8 PRODUCT EQUAT$ TO ;,C4 ,IF X _H N BE5 POSSI# = RECIPROC;Y 6BE ?US E6ECT$1 "! WD H BE5 NO ASSOCI,N (! "PIES4 ,T DEM& HOLDS ?+S TGR Z A S+LE UNIT IS %[N 0! FACT T :5 M5 D N NE$ "O ANO!R1 I4E4 :5 NEI NE$S ! O!R OR "O DOES N NE$ ! O!R1 !Y D N EX*ANGE1 Z WE D :5 "S "O WANTS :AT "O HAS "OF1 E4G4 :5 P P]MIT ! EXPORT,N ( CORN 9 EX*ANGE = W9E4 ,? EQU,N "!=E M/ 2 E/ABLI%$4 ,&=! FUTURE EX*ANGE-T IF WE D N NE$ A ?+ N[ WE % H X IF "E WE D NE$ X-M"OY IS Z X 7 \R SURETY2 = X M/ 2 POSSI# = U 6GET :AT WE WANT 0BR++ ! M"OY4 ,N[ ! SAME ?+ HAPP5S 6M"OY XF Z 6GDS-X IS N ALW WOR? ! SAME2 YET X T5DS 6BE /1DI]4 ,? IS :Y ALL GDS M/ H A PRICE SET ON !M2 = !N "! W ALW 2 EX*ANGE1 & IF S1 ASSOCI,N ( MAN ) MAN4 ,M"OY1 !N1 ACT+ Z A M1SURE1 MAKES GDS -M5SURATE & EQUATES !M2 = NEI WD "! H BE5 ASSOCI,N IF "! 7 N EX*ANGE1 NOR EX*ANGE IF "! 7 N EQUAL;Y1 NOR EQUAL;Y IF "! 7 N -M5SURABIL;Y4 ,N[ 9 TRU? X IS IMPOSSI# T ?+S DI6]+ S M* %D 2COME -M5SURATE1 B ) REF];E 6DEM& !Y MAY 2COME S SU6ICI5TLY4 ,"! M/1 !N1 2 A UNIT1 & T FIX$ 0AGREE;T 7= : R1SON X IS CALL$ M"OY72 = X IS ? T MAKES ALL ?+S -M5SURATE1 S9CE ALL ?+S >E M1SUR$ 0M"OY4 ,LET ,A 2 A H\SE1 ;,B T5 M9AE1 ;,C A B$4 ,A IS HALF ( ;,B1 IF ! H\SE IS WOR? FIVE M9AE OR EQUAL 6!M2 ! B$1 ;,C1 IS A T5? ( ;,B2 X IS PLA91 !N1 H[ _M B$S >E EQUAL 6A H\SE1 VIZ4 FIVE4 ,T EX*ANGE TOOK PLACE ?US 2F "! 0 M"OY IS PLA92 = X MAKES NO DI6];E :E!R X IS FIVE B$S T EX*ANGE =A H\SE1 OR ! M"OY VALUE ( FIVE B$S4 ,WE H N[ DEF9$ ! UNJU/ &! J4 ,^! HAV+ BE5 M>K$ (F F EA* O!R1 X IS PLA9 T J AC;N IS 9T]M$IATE 2T ACT+ UNJU/LY & 2+ UNJU/LY TR1T$2 =! "O IS 6H TOO M* &! O!R 6H TOO LL4 ,JU/ICE IS A K9D ( M1N1 B N 9 ! SAME WAY Z ! O!R VIRTUES1 B 2C X RELATES 6AN 9T]M$IATE AM.T1 :ILE 9JU/ICE RELATES 6! EXTREMES4 ,& JU/ICE IS T 9 VIRTUE ( : ! J MAN IS SD 6BE A DO]1 0*OICE1 ( T : IS J1 & "O :O W 4TRIBUTE EI 2T HMF & ANO!R OR 2T TWO O!RS N S Z 6GIVE M ( :AT IS DESIRA# 6HMF & LESS 6HIS NEIM;L71 B S Z 6GIVE :AT IS EQUAL 9 A3ORD.E ) PROPOR;N2 & SIMIL>LY 9 4TRIBUT+ 2T TWO O!R P]SONS4 ,9JU/ICE ON ! O!R H& IS SIMIL>LY RELAT$ 6! UNJU/1 : IS EXCESS & DEFECT1 3TR>Y 6PROPOR;N1 (! USE;L OR HURT;L4 ,= : R1SON 9JU/ICE IS EXCESS & DEFECT1 VIZ4 2C X IS PRODUCTIVE ( EXCESS & DEFECT-IN "O'S [N CASE EXCESS ( :AT IS 9 XS [N NATURE USE;L & DEFECT ( :AT IS HURT;L1 :ILE 9 ! CASE ( O!RS X IS Z A :OLE L :AT X IS 9 "O'S [N CASE1 B PROPOR;N MAY 2 VIOLAT$ 9 EI DIREC;N4 ,9 ! UNJU/ ACT 6H TOO LL IS 6BE UNJU/LY TR1T$2 6H TOO M* IS 6ACT UNJU/LY4 ,LET ? 2 TAK5 Z \R A3.T (! NATURE ( JU/ICE & 9JU/ICE1 & SIMIL>LY (! J &! UNJU/ 9 G5]AL4 #F ,S9CE ACT+ UNJU/LY DOES N NECESS>ILY IMPLY 2+ UNJU/1 WE M/ ASK :AT SORT ( UNJU/ ACTS IMPLY T ! DO] IS UNJU/ ) RESPECT 6EA* TYPE ( 9JU/ICE1 E4G4 A ?IEF1 AN ADULT]]1 OR A BRIG&4 ,SURELY ! ANSW] DOES N TURN ON ! DI6];E 2T ^! TYPES4 ,=A MAN MILY 9 ALL O!R CASES4 ,N[ WE H PREVI\SLY /AT$ H[ ! RECIPROCAL IS RELAT$ 6! J2 B WE M/ N =GET T :AT WE >E LOOK+ = IS N ONLY :AT IS J )\T QUALIFIC,N B AL POLITICAL JU/ICE4 ,? IS F.D AM;G M5 :O %>E _! LIFE )A VIEW 6SELFSU6ICI5CY1 M5 :O >E FREE & EI PROPOR;NATELY OR >I?METIC,Y EQUAL1 S T 2T ^? :O D N FULFIL ? 3DI;N "! IS NO POLITICAL JU/ICE B JU/ICE 9 A SPECIAL S5SE & 0ANALOGY4 ,= JU/ICE EXI/S ONLY 2T M5 ^: MUTUAL REL,NS >E GOV]N$ 0LAW2 & LAW EXI/S = M5 2T :OM "! IS 9JU/ICE2 = LEGAL JU/ICE IS ! 4CRIM9,N (! J &! UNJU/4 ,& 2T M5 2T :OM "! IS 9JU/ICE "! IS AL UNJU/ AC;N 7?\< "! IS N 9JU/ICE 2T ALL 2T :OM "! IS UNJU/ AC;N71 & ? IS ASSIGN+ TOO M* 6"OF ( ?+S GD 9 !MVS & TOO LL ( ?+S EVIL 9 !MVS4 ,? IS :Y WE D N ALL[ A MAN 6RULE1 B R,NAL PR9CIPLE1 2C A MAN 2HAVES ?US 9 8 [N 9T]E/S & 2COMES A TYRANT4 ,! MAGI/RATE ON ! O!R H& IS ! GU>DIAN ( JU/ICE1 &1 IF ( JU/ICE1 !N ( EQUAL;Y AL4 ,& S9CE HE IS ASSUM$ 6H NO M ?AN 8 %>E1 IF HE IS J 7= HE DOES N ASSIGN 6HMF M ( :AT IS GD 9 XF1 UN.S S* A %>E IS PROPOR;NAL 6HIS M]ITS-S T X IS = O!RS T HE LAB\RS1 & X IS = ? R1SON T M51 Z WE /AT$ PREVI\SLY1 SAY T JU/ICE IS ,8ANO!R'S GD0'71 "!=E A REW>D M/ 2 GIV5 HM1 & ? IS HON\R & PRIVILEGE2 B ^? = :OM S* ?+S >E N 5 2COME TYRANTS4 ,! JU/ICE (A MA/] & T (A "F >E N ! SAME Z ! JU/ICE ( CITIZ5S1 ?\< !Y >E L X2 = "! C 2 NO 9JU/ICE 9 ! UNQUALIFI$ S5SE T[>DS ?+ T >E "O'S [N1 B A MAN'S *ATTEL1 & 8 * UNTIL X R1*ES A C]TA9 AGE & SETS UP = XF1 >E Z X 7 "P ( HMF1 & NO "O *OOSES 6HURT HMF 7= : R1SON "! C 2 NO 9JU/ICE T[>DS "OF74 ,"!=E ! JU/ICE OR 9JU/ICE ( CITIZ5S IS N MANIFE/$ 9 ^! REL,NS2 = X 0 Z WE SAW AC 6LAW1 & 2T P NATUR,Y SUBJECT 6LAW1 & ^! Z WE SAW0' >E P :O H AN EQUAL %>E 9 RUL+ & 2+ RUL$4 ,H;E JU/ICE C M TRULY 2 MANIFE/$ T[>DS A WIFE ?AN T[>DS *N & *ATTELS1 =! =M] IS H\SEHOLD JU/ICE2 B EV5 ? IS DI6]5T F POLITICAL JU/ICE4 #G ,( POLITICAL JU/ICE "P IS NATURAL1 "P LEGAL1 NATURAL1 T : "EY": HAS ! SAME =CE & DOES N EXI/ 0P'S ?9K+ ? OR T2 LEGAL1 T : IS ORIG9,Y 9DI6]5T1 B :5 X HAS BE5 LAID D[N IS N 9DI6]5T1 E4G4 T A PRISON]'S RANSOM % 2 A M9A1 OR T A GOAT & N TWO %EEP % 2 SACRIFIC$1 & AG ALL ! LAWS T >E PASS$ = "PICUL> CASES1 E4G4 T SACRIFICE % 2 MADE 9 HON\R ( ,BRASIDAS1 &! PROVI.NS ( DECREES4 ,N[ "S ?9K T ALL JU/ICE IS ( ? SORT1 2C T : IS 0NATURE IS UN*ANGEA# & HAS "EY": ! SAME =CE 7Z FIRE BURNS BO? "H & 9 ,P]SIA71 :ILE !Y SEE *ANGE 9 ! ?+S RECOGNIZ$ Z J4 ,?1 H["E1 IS N TRUE 9 ? UNQUALIFI$ WAY1 B IS TRUE 9 A S5SE2 OR R1 )! GODS X IS P]H N TRUE AT ALL1 :ILE ) U "! IS "S?+ T IS J EV5 0NATURE1 YET ALL ( X IS *ANGEA#2 B / "S IS 0NATURE1 "S N 0NATURE4 ,X IS EVID5T : SORT ( ?+1 AM;G ?+S CAPA# ( 2+ O!RWISE1 IS 0NATURE1 & : IS N B IS LEGAL & 3V5;NAL1 ASSUM+ T BO? >E EQU,Y *ANGEA#4 ,& 9 ALL O!R ?+S ! SAME 4T9C;N W APPLY2 0NATURE ! "R H& IS /R;G]1 YET X IS POSSI# T ALL M5 %D -E 6BE AMBIDEXTR\S4 ,! ?+S : >E J 0VIRTUE ( 3V5;N & EXP$I5CY >E L M1SURES2 = W9E & CORN M1SURES >E N "EY": EQUAL1 B L>G] 9 :OLESALE & SMALL] 9 RETAIL M>KETS4 ,SIMIL>LY1 ! ?+S : >E J N 0NATURE B 0HUMAN 5ACT;T >E N "EY": ! SAME1 S9CE 3/ITU;NS AL >E N ! SAME1 ?\< "! IS B "O : IS "EY": 0NATURE ! BE/4 ,( ?+S J & LAW;L EA* IS RELAT$ Z ! UNIV]SAL 6XS "PICUL>S2 =! ?+S T >E D"O >E _M1 B ( !M EA* IS "O1 S9CE X IS UNIV]SAL4 ,"! IS A DI6];E 2T ! ACT ( 9JU/ICE & :AT IS UNJU/1 & 2T ! ACT ( JU/ICE & :AT IS J2 =A ?+ IS UNJU/ 0NATURE OR 05ACT;T2 & ? V ?+1 :5 X HAS BE5 D"O1 IS AN ACT ( 9JU/ICE1 B 2F X IS D"O IS N YET T B IS UNJU/4 ,S1 TOO1 ) AN ACT ( JU/ICE 7?\< ! G5]AL T]M IS R ,8J AC;N0'1 & ,8ACT ( JU/ICE0' IS APPLI$ 6! CORREC;N (! ACT ( 9JU/ICE74 ,EA* ( ^! M/ LAT] 2 EXAM9$ SEP>ATELY ) REG>D 6! NATURE & NUMB] ( XS SPECIES &! NATURE (! ?+S ) : X IS 3C]N$4 #H ,ACTS J & UNJU/ 2+ Z WE H DESCRIB$ !M1 A MAN ACTS UNJU/LY OR JU/LY :5"E HE DOES S* ACTS VOLUNT>ILY2 :5 9VOLUNT>ILY1 HE ACTS NEI UNJU/LY NOR JU/LY EXCEPT 9 AN 9CID5TAL WAY2 = HE DOES ?+S : HAPP5 6BE J OR UNJU/4 ,:E!R AN ACT IS OR IS N "O ( 9JU/ICE 7OR ( JU/ICE7 IS DET]M9$ 0XS VOLUNT>I;S OR 9VOLUNT>I;S2 = :5 X IS VOLUNT>Y X IS BLAM$1 & AT ! SAME "T IS !N AN ACT ( 9JU/ICE2 S T "! W 2 ?+S T >E UNJU/ B N YET ACTS ( 9JU/ICE1 IF VOLUNT>I;S 2 N PRES5T Z WELL4 ,0! VOLUNT>Y ,I M1N1 Z HAS BE5 SD 2F1 ANY (! ?+S 9 A MAN'S [N P[] : HE DOES ) K1 I4E4 N 9 IGNOR.E EI (! P]SON ACT$ ON OR (! 9/RU;T US$ OR (! 5D T W 2 ATTA9$ 7E4G4 :OM HE IS /RIK+1 ) :AT1 & 6:AT 5D71 EA* S* ACT 2+ D"O N 9CID5T,Y NOR "U -PUL.N 7E4G4 IF ,A TAKES ;,B'S H& & "!) /RIKES ;,C1 ;,B DOES N ACT VOLUNT>ILY2 =! ACT 0 N 9 8 [N P[]74 ,! P]SON /RUCK MAY 2 ! /RIK]'S "F1 &! /RIK] MAY "K T X IS A MAN OR "O (! P]SONS PRES5T1 B N "K T X IS 8 "F2 A SIMIL> 4T9C;N MAY 2 MADE 9 ! CASE (! 5D1 &) REG>D 6! :OLE AC;N4 ,"!=E T : IS D"O 9 IGNOR.E1 OR ?\< N D"O 9 IGNOR.E IS N 9 ! AG5T'S P[]1 OR IS D"O "U -PUL.N1 IS 9VOLUNT>Y 7= _M NATURAL PROCESSES1 EV51 WE "K+LY BO? P]=M & EXP]I;E1 N"O ( : IS EI VOLUNT>Y OR 9VOLUNT>Y2 E4G4 GR[+ OLD OR DY+74 ,B 9 ! CASE ( UNJU/ & J ACTS ALIKE ! 9JU/ICE OR JU/ICE MAY 2 ONLY 9CID5TAL2 =A MAN MI1 & !N HE M/ N 2 SD EI 6D :AT IS J OR 6ACT JU/LY1 EXCEPT 9 AN 9CID5TAL WAY4 ,SIMIL>LY ! MAN :O "U -PUL.N & UNWILL+LY FAILS 6RETURN ! DEPOSIT M/ 2 SD 6ACT UNJU/LY1 & 6D :AT IS UNJU/1 ONLY 9CID5T,Y4 ,( VOLUNT>Y ACTS WE D "S 0*OICE1 O!RS N 0*OICE2 0*OICE ^? : WE D AF DELIB],N1 N 0*OICE ^? : WE D )\T PREVI\S DELIB],N4 ,?US "! >E ?REE K9DS ( 9JURY 9 TRANSAC;NS 2T MAN & MAN2 ^? D"O 9 IGNOR.E >E MISTAKES :5 ! P]SON ACT$ ON1 ! ACT1 ! 9/RU;T1 OR ! 5D T W 2 ATTA9$ IS O!R ?AN ! AG5T SUPPOS$2 ! AG5T ?"\ EI T HE 0 N HIT+ ANY "O OR T HE 0 N HITT+ ) ? MISSILE OR N HITT+ ? P]SON OR 6? 5D1 B A RESULT FOLL[$ O!R ?AN T : HE ?"\ LIKELY 7E4G4 HE ?REW N ) 9T5T 6W.D B ONLY 6PRICK71 OR ! P]SON HIT OR ! MISSILE 0 O!R ?AN HE SUPPOS$4 ,N[ :5 7#A7 ! 9JURY TAKES PLACE 3TR>Y 6R1SONA# EXPECT,N1 X IS A MISADV5TURE4 ,:5 7#B7 X IS N 3TR>Y 6R1SONA# EXPECT,N1 B DOES N IMPLY VICE1 X IS A MISTAKE 7=A MAN MAKES A MISTAKE :5 ! FAULT ORIG9ATES 9 HM1 B IS ! VICTIM ( A3ID5T :5 ! ORIG9 LIES \TSIDE HM74 ,:5 7#C7 HE ACTS ) K B N AF DELIB],N1 X IS AN ACT ( 9JU/ICE-E4G4 ! ACTS DUE 6ANG] OR 6O!R PAS.NS NEC OR NATURAL 6MAN2 = :5 M5 D S* H>M;L & MISTAK5 ACTS !Y ACT UNJU/LY1 &! ACTS >E ACTS ( 9JU/ICE1 B ? DOES N IMPLY T ! DO]S >E UNJU/ OR WICK$2 =! 9JURY IS N DUE 6VICE4 ,B :5 7#D7 A MAN ACTS F *OICE1 HE IS AN UNJU/ MAN &A VICI\S MAN4 ,H;E ACTS PROCE$+ F ANG] >E "RLY JUDG$ N 6BE D"O ( MALICE A=E?"\2 = X IS N ! MAN :O ACTS 9 ANG] B HE :O 5RAG$ HM T />TS ! MIS*IEF4 ,AG1 ! MATT] 9 4PUTE IS N :E!R ! ?+ HAPP5$ OR N1 B XS JU/ICE2 = X IS APP>5T 9JU/ICE T O3A.NS RAGE4 ,= !Y D N 4PUTE AB ! O3URR;E (! ACT-Z 9 -M]CIAL TRANSAC;NS ": "O (! TWO "PIES M/ 2 VICI\S-UN.S !Y D S [+ 6=GET;L;S2 B1 AGREE+ AB ! FACT1 !Y 4PUTE ON : SIDE JU/ICE LIES 7":AS A MAN :O HAS DELIB]ATELY 9JUR$ ANO!R _C HELP "K+ T HE HAS D"O S71 S T ! "O ?9KS HE IS 2+ TR1T$ UNJU/LY &! O!R 4AGREES4 ,B IF A MAN H>MS ANO!R 0*OICE1 HE ACTS UNJU/LY2 & ^! >E ! ACTS ( 9JU/ICE : IMPLY T ! DO] IS AN UNJU/ MAN1 PROVID$ T ! ACT VIOLATES PROPOR;N OR EQUAL;Y4 ,SIMIL>LY1 A MAN IS J :5 HE ACTS JU/LY 0*OICE2 B HE ACTS JU/LY IF HE M]ELY ACTS VOLUNT>ILY4 ,( 9VOLUNT>Y ACTS "S >E EXCUSA#1 O!RS N4 ,=! MISTAKES : M5 MAKE N ONLY 9 IGNOR.E B AL F IGNOR.E >E EXCUSA#1 :ILE ^? : M5 D N F IGNOR.E B 7?\< !Y D !M 9 IGNOR.E7 [+ 6A PAS.N : IS NEI NATURAL NOR S* Z MAN IS LIA# TO1 >E N EXCUSA#4 #I ,ASSUM+ T WE H SU6ICI5TLY DEF9$ ! SU6]+ & DO+ ( 9JU/ICE1 X MAY 2 ASK$ 7#A7 :E!R ! TRU? 9 EXPRESS$ 9 ,EURIPIDES' P>ADOXICAL ^WS3 ,I SLEW MY "M1 T'S MY TALE 9 BRIEF4 ,7 Y BO? WILL+1 OR UNWILL+ BO?8 ,IS X TRULY POSSI# 6BE WILL+LY TR1T$ UNJU/LY1 OR IS ALL SU6]+ ( 9JU/ICE ! 3TR>Y 9VOLUNT>Y1 Z ALL UNJU/ AC;N IS VOLUNT>Y8 ,& IS ALL SU6]+ ( 9JU/ICE (! LATT] K9D OR ELSE ALL (! =M]1 OR IS X "S"TS VOLUNT>Y1 "S"TS 9VOLUNT>Y8 ,S1 TOO1 )! CASE ( 2+ JU/LY TR1T$2 ALL J AC;N IS VOLUNT>Y1 S T X IS R1SONA# T "! %D 2 A SIMIL> OPPOSI;N 9 EI CASE-T BO? 2+ UNJU/LY & 2+ JU/LY TR1T$ %D 2 EI ALIKE VOLUNT>Y OR ALIKE 9VOLUNT>Y4 ,B X WD 2 ?"\ P>ADOXICAL EV5 9 ! CASE ( 2+ JU/LY TR1T$1 IF X 7 ALW VOLUNT>Y2 = "S >E UNWILL+LY TR1T$ JU/LY4 ,"O MITAKE ( JU/ICE 9CID5T,Y1 & SIMIL>LY 7X IS PLA97 ( 9JU/ICE2 = 6D :AT IS UNJU/ IS N ! SAME Z 6ACT UNJU/LY1 NOR 6SU6] :AT IS UNJU/ Z 6BE TR1T$ UNJU/LY1 & SIMIL>LY 9 ! CASE ( ACT+ JU/LY & 2+ JU/LY TR1T$2 = X IS IMPOSSI# 6BE UNJU/LY TR1T$ IF ! O!R DOES N ACT UNJU/LY1 OR JU/LY TR1T$ UN.S HE ACTS JU/LY4 ,N[ IF 6ACT UNJU/LY IS SIMPLY 6H>M "S "O VOLUNT>ILY1 & ,8VOLUNT>ILY0' M1NS ,8"K+ ! P]SON ACT$ ON1 ! 9/RU;T1 &! MANN] ( "O'S ACT+0'1 &! 9CONT95T MAN VOLUNT>ILY H>MS HMF1 N ONLY W HE VOLUNT>ILY 2 UNJU/LY TR1T$ B X W 2 POSSI# 6TR1T "OF UNJU/LY4 7,? AL IS "O (! "QS 9 D\BT1 :E!R A MAN C TR1T HMF UNJU/LY47 ,AG1 A MAN MAY VOLUNT>ILY1 [+ 69CONT9;E1 2 H>M$ 0ANO!R :O ACTS VOLUNT>ILY1 S T X WD 2 POSSI# 6BE VOLUNT>ILY TR1T$ UNJU/LY4 ,OR IS \R DEF9I;N 9CORRECT2 M/ WE TO ,8H>M+ ANO!R1 ) K BO? (! P]SON ACT$ ON1 (! 9/RU;T1 &(! MANN]0' ADD ,83TR>Y 6! WI% ( ! P]SON ACT$ ON0'8 ,!N A MAN MAY 2 VOLUNT>ILY H>M$ & VOLUNT>ILY SU6] :AT IS UNJU/1 B NO "O IS VOLUNT>ILY TR1T$ UNJU/LY2 = NO "O WI%ES 6BE UNJU/LY TR1T$1 N EV5 ! 9CONT95T MAN4 ,HE ACTS 3TR>Y 6HIS WI%2 = NO "O WI%ES = :AT HE DOES N ?9K 6BE GD1 B ! 9CONT95T MAN DOES D ?+S T HE DOES N ?9K HE "\ 6D4 ,AG1 "O :O GIVES :AT IS 8 [N1 Z ,HOM] SAYS ,GLAUCUS GAVE ,DIOM$E ,>M\R ( GOLD = BRAZ51 ! PRICE (A HUNDR$ BEEVES = N9E1 IS N UNJU/LY TR1T$2 = ?\< 6GIVE IS 9 8 P[]1 6BE UNJU/LY TR1T$ IS N1 B "! M/ 2 "S "O 6TR1T HM UNJU/LY4 ,X IS PLA91 !N1 T 2+ UNJU/LY TR1T$ IS N VOLUNT>Y4 ,(! "QS WE 9T5D$ 64CUSS TWO / REMA9 = 4CUS.N2 7#C7 :E!R X IS ! MAN :O HAS ASSIGN$ 6ANO!R M ?AN 8 %>E T ACTS UNJU/LY1 OR HE :O HAS ! EXCESSIVE %>E1 & 7#D7 :E!R X IS POSSI# 6TR1T "OF UNJU/LY4 ,! "QS >E 3NECT$2 = IF ! =M] ALT]NATIVE IS POSSI# &! 4TRIBUTOR ACTS UNJU/LY & N ! MAN :O HAS ! EXCESSIVE %>E1 !N IF A MAN ASSIGNS M 6ANO!R ?AN 6HMF1 "K+LY & VOLUNT>ILY1 HE TR1TS HMF UNJU/LY2 : IS :AT MODE/ P SEEM 6D1 S9CE ! VIRTU\S MAN T5DS 6TAKE LESS ?AN 8 %>E4 ,OR DOES ? /ATE;T TOO NE$ QUALIFIC,N8 ,= 7A7 HE P]H GETS M ?AN 8 %>E ( "S O!R GD1 E4G4 ( HON\R OR ( 9TR9SIC NOBIL;Y4 7B7 ,! "Q IS SOLV$ 0APPLY+ ! 4T9C;N WE APPLI$ 6UNJU/ AC;N2 = HE SU6]S NO?+ 3TR>Y 6HIS [N WI%1 S T HE IS N UNJU/LY TR1T$ Z F> Z ? GOES1 B AT MO/ ONLY SU6]S H>M4 ,X IS PLA9 TOO T ! 4TRIBUTOR ACTS UNJU/LY1 B N ALW ! MAN :O HAS ! EXCESSIVE %>E2 = X IS N HE 6:OM :AT IS UNJU/ APP]TA9S T ACTS UNJU/LY1 B HE 6:OM X APP]TA9S 6D ! UNJU/ ACT VOLUNT>ILY1 I4E4 ! P]SON 9 :OM LIES ! ORIG9 (! AC;N1 & ? LIES 9 ! 4TRIBUTOR1 N 9 ! RCVR4 ,AG1 S9CE ! ^W ,8D0' IS AMBIGU\S1 & "! IS A S5SE 9 : LIFE.S ?+S1 OR A H&1 OR A S]VANT :O OBEYS AN ORD]1 MAY 2 SD 6SLAY1 HE :O GETS AN EXCESSIVE %>E DOES N ACT UNJU/LY1 ?\< HE ,8DOES0' :AT IS UNJU/4 ,AG1 IF ! 4TRIBUTOR GAVE 8 JUDGE;T 9 IGNOR.E1 HE DOES N ACT UNJU/LY 9 RESPECT ( LEGAL JU/ICE1 & 8 JUDGE;T IS N UNJU/ 9 ? S5SE1 B 9 A S5SE X IS UNJU/ 7= LEGAL JU/ICE & PRIMORDIAL JU/ICE >E DI6]5T72 B IF ) K HE JUDG$ UNJU/LY1 HE IS HMF AIM+ AT AN EXCESSIVE %>E EI ( GRATITUDE OR ( REV5GE4 ,Z M*1 !N1 Z IF HE 7 6%>E 9 ! PL"U1 ! MAN :O HAS JUDG$ UNJU/LY = ^! R1SONS HAS GOT TOO M*2 ! FACT T :AT HE GETS IS DI6]5T F :AT HE 4TRIBUTES MAKES NO DI6];E1 = EV5 IF HE AW>DS L& )A VIEW 6%>+ 9 ! PL"U HE GETS N L& B M"OY4 ,M5 ?9K T ACT+ UNJU/LY IS 9 _! P[]1 & "!=E T 2+ J IS EASY4 ,B X IS N2 6LIE ) "O'S NEILY 6"K :AT IS J & :AT IS UNJU/ REQUIRES1 M5 ?9K1 NO GRT WISDOM1 2C X IS N H>D 6"U/& ! MATT]S D1LT ) 0! LAWS 7?\< ^! >E N ! ?+S T >E J1 EXCEPT 9CID5T,Y72 B H[ AC;NS M/ 2 D"O & 4TRIBU;NS E6ECT$ 9 ORD] 6BE J1 6"K ? IS A GRT] A*IEVE;T ?AN "K+ :AT IS GD =! H1L?2 ?\< EV5 "!1 :ILE X IS EASY 6"K T H"OY1 W9E1 HELLEBORE1 CAUT]Y1 &! USE (! KNIFE >E S1 6"K H[1 6:OM1 & :5 ^! %D 2 APPLI$ )A VIEW 6PRODUC+ H1L?1 IS NO LESS AN A*IEVE;T ?AN T ( 2+ A PHYSICIAN4 ,AG1 = ? V R1SON M5 ?9K T ACT+ UNJU/LY IS "*I/IC (! J MAN NO LESS ?AN (! UNJU/1 2C HE WD 2 N LESS B EV5 M CAPA# ( DO+ EA* ( ^! UNJU/ ACTS2 = HE CD LIE )A WOMAN OR W.D A NEID OR 6ACT UNJU/LY 3SI/S N 9 DO+ ^! ?+S1 EXCEPT 9CID5T,Y1 B 9 DO+ !M Z ! RESULT (A C]TA9 /ATE ( "*1 J Z 6PRACTISE M$IC9E & H1L+ 3SI/S N 9 APPLY+ OR N APPLY+ ! KNIFE1 9 US+ OR N US+ M$IC9ES1 B 9 DO+ S 9 A C]TA9 WAY4 ,J ACTS O3UR 2T P :O "PICIPATE 9 ?+S GD 9 !MVS & C H TOO M* OR TOO LL ( !M2 = "S 2+S 7E4G4 PRESUMABLY ! GODS7 _C H TOO M* ( !M1 & 6O!RS1 ^? :O >E 9CURABLY BAD1 N EV5 ! SMALLE/ %>E 9 !M IS B5EFICIAL B ALL S* GDS >E H>M;L1 :ILE 6O!RS !Y >E B5EFICIAL UP 6A PO9T2 "!=E JU/ICE IS ESS5TI,Y "S?+ HUMAN4 #AJ ,\R NEXT SUBJECT IS EQU;Y &! EQUITA# 76EPIEKES71 & _! RESPECTIVE REL,NS 6JU/ICE &! J4 ,= ON EXAM9,N !Y APPE> 6BE NEI ABSOLUTELY ! SAME NOR G5]IC,Y DI6]5T2 & :ILE WE "S"T PRAISE :AT IS EQUITA# &! EQUITA# MAN 7S T WE APPLY ! "N 0WAY ( PRAISE EV5 69/.ES (! O!R VIRTUES1 9/1D ( ,8GD0' M1N+ 0EPIEIKE/EBON T A ?+ IS BETT]71 AT O!R "TS1 :5 WE R1SON X \1 X SEEMS /RANGE IF ! EQUITA#1 2+ "S?+ DI6]5T F ! J1 IS YET PRAISEWOR?Y2 = EI ! J OR ! EQUITA# IS N GD1 IF !Y >E DI6]5T2 OR1 IF BO? >E GD1 !Y >E ! SAME4 ,^!1 !N1 >E PRETTY M* ! 3SID],NS T GIVE RISE 6! PRO#M AB ! EQUITA#2 !Y >E ALL 9 A S5SE CORRECT & N OPPOS$ 6"O ANO!R2 =! EQUITA#1 ?\< X IS BETT] ?AN "O K9D ( JU/ICE1 YET IS J1 & X IS N Z 2+ A DI6]5T CLASS ( ?+ T X IS BETT] ?AN ! J4 ,! SAME ?+1 !N1 IS J & EQUITA#1 & :ILE BO? >E GD ! EQUITA# IS SUP]IOR4 ,:AT CR1TES ! PRO#M IS T ! EQUITA# IS J1 B N ! LEG,Y J B A CORREC;N ( LEGAL JU/ICE4 ,! R1SON IS T ALL LAW IS UNIV]SAL B AB "S ?+S X IS N POSSI# 6MAKE A UNIV]SAL /ATE;T : % 2 CORRECT4 ,9 ^? CASES1 !N1 9 : X IS NEC 6SP1K UNIV]S,Y1 B N POSSI# 6D S CORRECTLY1 ! LAW TAKES ! USUAL CASE1 ?\< X IS N IGNORANT (! POSSIBIL;Y ( ]ROR4 ,& X IS N"O ! LESS CORRECT2 =! ]ROR IS 9 ! LAW NOR 9 ! LEGISLATOR B 9 ! NATURE (! ?+1 S9CE ! MATT] ( PRACTICAL A6AIRS IS ( ? K9D F ! />T4 ,:5 ! LAW SP1KS UNIV]S,Y1 !N1 &A CASE >ISES ON X : IS N COV]$ 0! UNIV]SAL /ATE;T1 !N X IS "R1 ": ! LEGISLATOR FAILS U & HAS ]R$ 0OV]SIMPLIC;Y1 6CORRECT ! OMIS.N-TO SAY :AT ! LEGISLATOR HMF WD H SD _H HE BE5 PRES5T1 & WD H PUT 96HIS LAW IF HE _H "KN4 ,H;E ! EQUITA# IS J1 & BETT] ?AN "O K9D ( JU/ICE-N BETT] ?AN ABSOLUTE JU/ICE B BETT] ?AN ! ]ROR T >ISES F ! ABSOLUTE;S (! /ATE;T4 ,& ? IS ! NATURE (! EQUITA#1 A CORREC;N ( LAW ": X IS DEFECTIVE [+ 6XS UNIV]SAL;Y4 ,9 FACT ? IS ! R1SON :Y ALL ?+S >E N DET]M9$ 0LAW1 T AB "S ?+S X IS IMPOSSI# 6LAY D[N A LAW1 S T A DECREE IS NE$$4 ,= :5 ! ?+ IS 9DEF9ITE ! RULE AL IS 9DEF9ITE1 L ! L1D5 RULE US$ 9 MAK+ ! ,LESBIAN M\LD+2 ! RULE ADAPTS XF 6! %APE (! /"O & IS N RIGID1 & S TOO ! DECREE IS ADAPT$ 6! FACTS4 ,X IS PLA91 !N1 :AT ! EQUITA# IS1 & T X IS J & IS BETT] ?AN "O K9D ( JU/ICE4 ,X IS EVID5T AL F ? :O ! EQUITA# MAN IS2 ! MAN :O *OOSES & DOES S* ACTS1 & IS NO /ICKL] = 8 "RS 9 A BAD S5SE B T5DS 6TAKE LESS ?AN 8 %>E ?\< HE HAS ! LAW (T 8 SIDE1 IS EQUITA#1 & ? /ATE ( "* IS EQU;Y1 : IS A SORT ( JU/ICE & N A DI6]5T /ATE ( "*4 #AA ,:E!R A MAN C TR1T HMF UNJU/LY OR N1 IS EVID5T F :AT HAS BE5 SD4 ,= 7A7 "O CLASS ( J ACTS >E ^? ACTS 9 A3ORD.E ) ANY VIRTUE : >E PRESCRIB$ 0! LAW2 E4G4 ! LAW DOES N EXPRESSLY P]MIT SUICIDE1 & :AT X DOES N EXPRESSLY P]MIT X =BIDS4 ,AG1 :5 A MAN 9 VIOL,N (! LAW H>MS ANO!R 7O!RWISE ?AN 9 RETALI,N7 VOLUNT>ILY1 HE ACTS UNJU/LY1 &A VOLUNT>Y AG5T IS "O :O "KS BO? ! P]SON HE IS A6ECT+ 0HIS AC;N & ! 9/RU;T HE IS US+2 & HE :O "? ANG] VOLUNT>ILY /ABS HMF DOES ? 3TR>Y 6! "R RULE ( LIFE1 & ? ! LAW DOES N ALL[2 "!=E HE IS ACT+ UNJU/LY4 ,B T[>DS :OM8 ,SURELY T[>DS ! /ATE1 N T[>DS HMF4 ,= HE SU6]S VOLUNT>ILY1 B NO "O IS VOLUNT>ILY TR1T$ UNJU/LY4 ,? IS AL ! R1SON :Y ! /ATE PUNI%ES2 A C]TA9 LOSS ( CIVIL "RS ATTA*ES 6! MAN :O DE/ROYS HMF1 ON ! GR.D T HE IS TR1T+ ! /ATE UNJU/LY4 ,FUR!R 7B7 9 T S5SE ( ,8ACT+ UNJU/LY0' 9 : ! MAN :O ,8ACTS UNJU/LY0' IS UNJU/ ONLY & N BAD ALL R.D1 X IS N POSSI# 6TR1T "OF UNJU/LY 7? IS DI6]5T F ! =M] S5SE2 ! UNJU/ MAN 9 "O S5SE (! T]M IS WICK$ 9 A "PICUL>IZ$ WAY J Z ! C[>D IS1 N 9 ! S5SE ( 2+ WICK$ ALL R.D1 S T 8 ,8UNJU/ ACT0' DOES N MANIFE/ WICK$;S 9 G5]AL74 ,= 7I7 T WD IMPLY ! POSSIBIL;Y ( ! SAME ?+'S HAV+ BE5 SUBTRACT$ F & A4$ 6! SAME ?+ AT ! SAME "T2 B ? IS IMPOSSI#-! J &! UNJU/ ALW 9VOLVE M ?AN "O P]SON4 ,FUR!R1 7;II7 UNJU/ AC;N IS VOLUNT>Y & D"O 0*OICE1 & TAKES ! 9ITIATIVE 7=! MAN :O 2C HE HAS SU6]$ DOES ! SAME 9 RETURN IS N ?"\ 6ACT UNJU/LY72 B IF A MAN H>MS HMF HE SU6]S & DOES ! SAME ?+S AT ! SAME "T4 ,FUR!R1 7;III7 IF A MAN CD TR1T HMF UNJU/LY1 HE CD 2 VOLUNT>ILY TR1T$ UNJU/LY4 ,2SS1 7;IV7 NO "O ACTS UNJU/LY )\T -MITT+ "PICUL> ACTS ( 9JU/ICE2 B NO "O C -MIT ADULT]Y ) 8 [N WIFE OR H\SEBR1K+ ON 8 [N H\SE OR !FT ON 8 [N PROP]TY1 ,9 G5]AL1 ! "Q ,8C A MAN TR1T HMF UNJU/LY80' IS SOLV$ AL 0! 4T9C;N WE APPLI$ 6! "Q ,8C A MAN 2 VOLUNT>ILY TR1T$ UNJU/LY80' 7,X IS EVID5T TOO T BO? >E BAD1 2+ UNJU/LY TR1T$ & ACT+ UNJU/LY2 =! "O M1NS HAV+ LESS &! O!R HAV+ M ?AN ! 9T]M$IATE AM.T1 : PLAYS ! "P "H T ! H1L?Y DOES 9 ! M$ICAL >T1 & T GD 3DI;N DOES 9 ! >T ( BODILY TRA9+4 ,B / ACT+ UNJU/LY IS ! WORSE1 = X 9VOLVES VICE & IS BLAMEWOR?Y- 9VOLVES VICE : IS EI (! -PLETE & UNQUALIFI$ K9D OR ALM S 7WE M/ ADMIT ! LATT] ALT]NATIVE1 2C N ALL VOLUNT>Y UNJU/ AC;N IMPLIES 9JU/ICE Z A /ATE ( "*71 :ILE 2+ UNJU/LY TR1T$ DOES N 9VOLVE VICE & 9JU/ICE 9 "OF4 ,9 XF1 !N1 2+ UNJU/LY TR1T$ IS LESS BAD1 B "! IS NO?+ 6PREV5T XS 2+ 9CID5T,Y A GRT] EVIL4 ,B !ORY C>ES NO?+ = ?2 X CALLS PLEURISY A M S]I\S MIS*IEF ?AN A /UM#2 YET ! LATT] MAY 2COME 9CID5T,Y ! M S]I\S1 IF ! FALL DUE 6X L1DS 6YR 2+ TAK5 PRISON] OR PUT 6D1? ! 5EMY47 ,METAPHORIC,Y & 9 VIRTUE (A C]TA9 RESEMBL.E "! IS A JU/ICE1 N 9DE$ 2T A MAN & HMF1 B 2T C]TA9 "PS ( HM2 YET N E K9D ( JU/ICE B T ( MA/] & S]VANT OR T ( HUSB& & WIFE4 ,= ^! >E ! RATIOS 9 : ! "P (! S\L T HAS A R,NAL PR9CIPLE /&S 6! IRR,NAL "P2 & X IS )A VIEW 6^! "PS T P AL ?9K A MAN C 2 UNJU/ 6HMF1 VIZ4 2C ^! "PS >E LIA# 6SU6] "S?+ 3TR>Y 6_! RESPECTIVE DESIRES2 "! IS "!=E ?"\ 6BE A MUTUAL JU/ICE 2T !M Z 2T RUL] & RUL$4 ,LET ? 2 TAK5 Z \R A3.T ( JU/ICE &! O!R1 I4E4 ! O!R MORAL1 VIRTUES4