,,BOOK ,,III #A ,S9CE VIRTUE IS 3C]N$ ) PAS.NS & AC;NS1 & ON VOLUNT>Y PAS.NS & AC;NS PRAISE & BLAME >E 2/[$1 ON ^? T >E 9VOLUNT>Y P>DON1 & "S"TS AL P;Y1 64T+UI% ! VOLUNT>Y &! 9VOLUNT>Y IS PRESUMABLY NEC = ^? :O >E /UDY+ ! NATURE ( VIRTUE1 & USE;L AL = LEGISLATORS )A VIEW 6! ASSIGN+ BO? ( HON\RS &( PUNI%;TS4 ,^? ?+S1 !N1 >E ?"\-9VOLUNT>Y1 : TAKE PLACE "U -PUL.N OR [+ 6IGNOR.E2 & T IS -PULSORY ( : ! MOV+ PR9CIPLE IS \TSIDE1 2+ A PR9CIPLE 9 : NO?+ IS 3TRIBUT$ 0! P]SON :O IS ACT+ OR IS FEEL+ ! PAS.N1 E4G4 IF HE 7 6BE C>RI$ "S": 0A W9D1 OR 0M5 :O _H HM 9 _! P[]4 ,B ) REG>D 6! ?+S T >E D"O F FE> ( GRT] EVILS OR = "S NO# OBJECT 7E4G4 IF A TYRANT 7 6ORD] "O 6D "S?+ BASE1 HAV+ "O'S P>5TS & *N 9 8 P[]1 & IF "O DID ! AC;N !Y 7 6BE SAV$1 B O!RWISE WD 2 PUT 6D1?71 X MAY 2 DEBAT$ :E!R S* AC;NS >E 9VOLUNT>Y OR VOLUNT>Y4 ,"S?+ (! SORT HAPP5S AL ) REG>D 6! ?R[+ ( GDS OV]BO>D 9 A /ORM2 = 9 ! AB/RACT NO "O ?R[S GDS AWAY VOLUNT>ILY1 B ON 3DI;N ( XS SECUR+ ! SAFETY ( HMF & 8 CREW ANY S5SI# MAN DOES S4 ,S* AC;NS1 !N1 >E MIX$1 B >E M L VOLUNT>Y AC;NS2 = !Y >E WOR?Y ( *OICE AT ! "T :5 !Y >E D"O1 &! 5D ( AN AC;N IS RELATIVE 6! O3A.N4 ,BO? ! T]MS1 !N1 ,8VOLUNT>Y0' & ,89VOLUNT>Y0'1 M/ 2 US$ ) REF];E 6! MO;T ( AC;N4 ,N[ ! MAN ACTS VOLUNT>ILY2 =! PR9CIPLE T MOVES ! 9/RU;TAL "PS (! BODY 9 S* AC;NS IS 9 HM1 &! ?+S ( : ! MOV+ PR9CIPLE IS 9 A MAN HMF >E 9 8 P[] 6D OR N 6D4 ,S* AC;NS1 "!=E1 >E VOLUNT>Y1 B 9 ! AB/RACT P]H 9VOLUNT>Y2 = NO "O WD *OOSE ANY S* ACT 9 XF4 ,= S* AC;NS M5 >E "S"TS EV5 PRAIS$1 :5 !Y 5DURE "S?+ BASE OR PA9;L 9 RETURN = GRT & NO# OBJECTS GA9$2 9 ! OPPOSITE CASE !Y >E BLAM$1 S9CE 65DURE ! GRTE/ 9DIGNITIES = NO NO# 5D OR =A TRIFL+ 5D IS ! M>K ( AN 9F]IOR P]SON4 ,ON "S AC;NS PRAISE 9DE$ IS N 2/[$1 B P>DON IS1 :5 "O DOES :AT HE "\ N "U PRESSURE : OV]/RA9S HUMAN NATURE & : NO "O CD )/&4 ,B "S ACTS1 P]H1 WE _C 2 =C$ 6D1 B "\ R 6FACE D1? AF ! MO/ FE>;L SU6]+S2 =! ?+S T ,8=C$0' ,EURIPIDES ,ALCMAEON 6SLAY 8 "M SEEM ABSURD4 ,X IS DI6ICULT "S"TS 6DET]M9E :AT %D 2 *OS5 AT :AT CO/1 & :AT %D 2 5DUR$ 9 RETURN = :AT GA91 & YET M DI6ICULT 6ABIDE 0\R DECI.NS2 = Z A RULE :AT IS EXPECT$ IS PA9;L1 & :AT WE >E =C$ 6D IS BASE1 :;E PRAISE & BLAME >E 2/[$ ON ^? :O H BE5 -PELL$ OR H N4 ,:AT SORT ( ACTS1 !N1 %D 2 CALL$ -PULSORY8 ,WE ANSW] T )\T QUALIFIC,N AC;NS >E S :5 ! CAUSE IS 9 ! EXT]NAL CIRCUM/.ES &! AG5T 3TRIBUTES NO?+4 ,B ! ?+S T 9 !MVS >E 9VOLUNT>Y1 B N[ & 9 RETURN = ^! GA9S >E WOR?Y ( *OICE1 & ^: MOV+ PR9CIPLE IS 9 ! AG5T1 >E 9 !MVS 9VOLUNT>Y1 B N[ & 9 RETURN = ^! GA9S VOLUNT>Y4 ,!Y >E M L VOLUNT>Y ACTS2 = AC;NS >E 9 ! CLASS ( "PICUL>S1 &! "PICUL> ACTS "H >E VOLUNT>Y4 ,:AT SORT ( ?+S >E 6BE *OS51 & 9 RETURN = :AT1 X IS N EASY 6/ATE2 = "! >E _M DI6];ES 9 ! "PICUL> CASES4 ,B IF "S "O 7 6SAY T PL1SANT & NO# OBJECTS H A -PELL+ P[]1 =C+ U F )\T1 ALL ACTS WD 2 = HM -PULSORY2 = X IS = ^! OBJECTS T ALL M5 D "EY?+ !Y D4 ,& ^? :O ACT "U -PUL.N & UNWILL+LY ACT ) PA91 B ^? :O D ACTS = _! PL1SANT;S & NOBIL;Y D !M ) PL1SURE2 X IS ABSURD 6MAKE EXT]NAL CIRCUM/.ES RESPONSI#1 & N "OF1 Z 2+ EASILY CAUY2 X IS ONLY :AT PRODUCES PA9 & REP5T.E T IS 9VOLUNT>Y4 ,=! MAN :O HAS D"O "S?+ [+ 6IGNOR.E1 & FEELS N ! L1/ VEX,N AT 8 AC;N1 HAS N ACT$ VOLUNT>ILY1 S9CE HE DID N "K :AT HE 0 DO+1 NOR YET 9VOLUNT>ILY1 S9CE HE IS N PA9$4 ,( P1 !N1 :O ACT 0R1SON ( IGNOR.E HE :O REP5TS IS ?"\ AN 9VOLUNT>Y AG5T1 &! MAN :O DOES N REP5T MAY1 S9CE HE IS DI6]5T1 2 CALL$ A N VOLUNT>Y AG5T2 =1 S9CE HE DI6]S F ! O!R1 X IS BETT] T HE %D H A "N ( 8 [N4 ,ACT+ 0R1SON ( IGNOR.E SEEMS AL 6BE DI6]5T F ACT+ 9 IGNOR.E2 =! MAN :O IS DRUNK OR 9 A RAGE IS ?"\ 6ACT Z A RESULT N ( IGNOR.E B ( "O (! CAUSES M5;N$1 YET N "K+LY B 9 IGNOR.E4 ,N[ E WICK$ MAN IS IGNORANT ( :AT HE "\ 6D & :AT HE "\ 6AB/A9 F1 & X IS 0R1SON ( ]ROR ( ? K9D T M5 2COME UNJU/ & 9 G5]AL BAD2 B ! T]M ,89VOLUNT>Y0' T5DS 6BE US$ N IF A MAN IS IGNORANT ( :AT IS 6HIS ADVANTAGE- = X IS N MISTAK5 PURPOSE T CAUSES 9VOLUNT>Y AC;N 7X L1DS R 6WICK$;S71 NOR IGNOR.E (! UNIV]SAL 7= T M5 >E BLAM$71 B IGNOR.E ( "PICUL>S1 I4E4 (! CIRCUM/.ES (! AC;N &! OBJECTS ) : X IS 3C]N$4 ,= X IS ON ^! T BO? P;Y & P>DON DEP5D1 S9CE ! P]SON :O IS IGNORANT ( ANY ( ^! ACTS 9VOLUNT>ILY4 ,P]H X IS J Z WELL1 "!=E1 6DET]M9E _! NATURE & NUMB]4 ,A MAN MAY 2 IGNORANT1 !N1 ( :O HE IS1 :AT HE IS DO+1 :AT OR :OM HE IS ACT+ ON1 & "S"TS AL :AT 7E4G4 :AT 9/RU;T7 HE IS DO+ X )1 & 6:AT 5D 7E4G4 HE MAY ?9K 8 ACT W 3DUCE 6"S "O'S SAFETY71 & H[ HE IS DO+ X 7E4G4 :E!R G5TLY OR VIOL5TLY74 ,N[ ( ALL ( ^! NO "O CD 2 IGNORANT UN.S HE 7 MAD1 & EVID5TLY AL HE CD N 2 IGNORANT (! AG5T2 = H[ CD HE N "K HMF8 ,B ( :AT HE IS DO+ A MAN MI _H A BUTTON ON X1 OR T A /"O 0 PUMICE/"O2 OR "O MIR+1 & RE,Y W.D HM4 ,! IGNOR.E MAY RELATE1 !N1 6ANY ( ^! ?+S1 I4E4 (! CIRCUM/.ES (! AC;N1 &! MAN :O 0 IGNORANT ( ANY ( ^! IS ?"\ 6H ACT$ 9VOLUNT>ILY1 & ESPECI,Y IF HE 0 IGNORANT ON ! MO/ IMPORTANT PO9TS2 & ^! >E ?"\ 6BE ! CIRCUM/.ES (! AC;N & XS 5D4 ,FUR!R1 ! DO+ ( AN ACT T IS CALL$ 9VOLUNT>Y 9 VIRTUE ( IGNOR.E ( ? SORT M/ 2 PA9;L & 9VOLVE REP5T.E4 ,S9CE T : IS D"O "U -PUL.N OR 0R1SON ( IGNOR.E IS 9VOLUNT>Y1 ! VOLUNT>Y WD SEEM 6BE T ( : ! MOV+ PR9CIPLE IS 9 ! AG5T HMF1 HE 2+ AW>E (! "PICUL> CIRCUM/.ES (! AC;N4 ,PRESUMABLY ACTS D"O 0R1SON ( ANG] OR APPETITE >E N "RLY CALL$ 9VOLUNT>Y4 ,= 9 ! F/ PLACE1 ON T %[+ N"O (! O!R ANIMALS W ACT VOLUNT>ILY1 NOR W *N2 & SECONDLY1 IS X M1NT T WE D N D VOLUNT>ILY ANY (! ACTS T >E DUE 6APPETITE OR ANG]1 OR T WE D ! NO# ACTS VOLUNT>ILY &! BASE ACTS 9VOLUNT>ILY8 ,IS N ? ABSURD1 :5 "O &! SAME ?+ IS ! CAUSE8 ,B X WD SURELY 2 ODD 6DESCRIBE Z 9VOLUNT>Y ! ?+S "O "\ 6DESIRE2 & WE "\ BO? 6BE ANGRY AT C]TA9 ?+S & 6H AN APPETITE = C]TA9 ?+S1 E4G4 = H1L? &= LE>N+4 ,AL :AT IS 9VOLUNT>Y IS ?"\ 6BE PA9;L1 B :AT IS 9 A3ORD.E ) APPETITE IS ?"\ 6BE PL1SANT4 ,AG1 :AT IS ! DI6];E 9 RESPECT ( 9VOLUNT>I;S 2T ]RORS -MITT$ ^U CALCUL,N & ^? -MITT$ 9 ANG]8 ,BO? >E 6BE AVOID$1 B ! IRR,NAL PAS.NS >E ?"\ N LESS HUMAN ?AN R1SON IS1 & "!=E AL ! AC;NS : PROCE$ F ANG] OR APPETITE >E ! MAN'S AC;NS4 ,X WD 2 ODD1 !N1 6TR1T !M Z 9VOLUNT>Y4 #B ,BO? ! VOLUNT>Y &! 9VOLUNT>Y HAV+ BE5 DELIMIT$1 WE M/ NEXT 4CUSS *OICE2 = X IS ?"\ 6BE MO/ CLOSELY B.D UP ) VIRTUE & 64CRIM9ATE "*S BETT] ?AN AC;NS D4 ,*OICE1 !N1 SEEMS 6BE VOLUNT>Y1 B N ! SAME ?+ Z ! VOLUNT>Y2 ! LATT] EXT5DS M WIDELY4 ,= BO? *N &! L[] ANIMALS %>E 9 VOLUNT>Y AC;N1 B N 9 *OICE1 & ACTS D"O ON ! SPUR (! MO;T WE DESCRIBE Z VOLUNT>Y1 B N Z *OS54 ,^? :O SAY X IS APPETITE OR ANG] OR WI% OR A K9D ( OP9ION D N SEEM 6BE "R4 ,= *OICE IS N -MON 6IRR,NAL CR1TURES Z WELL1 B APPETITE & ANG] >E4 ,AG1 ! 9CONT95T MAN ACTS ) APPETITE1 B N ) *OICE2 :ILE ! 3T95T MAN ON ! 3TR>Y ACTS ) *OICE1 B N ) APPETITE4 ,AG1 APPETITE IS 3TR>Y 6*OICE1 B N APPETITE 6APPETITE4 ,AG1 APPETITE RELATES 6! PL1SANT &! PA9;L1 *OICE NEI 6! PA9;L NOR 6! PL1SANT4 ,/ LESS IS X ANG]2 = ACTS DUE 6ANG] >E ?"\ 6BE LESS ?AN ANY O!RS OBJECTS ( *OICE4 ,B NEI IS X WI%1 ?\< X SEEMS NE> 6X2 = *OICE _C RELATE 6IMPOSSI#S1 & IF ANY "O SD HE *OSE !M HE WD 2 ?"\ SILLY2 B "! MAY 2 A WI% EV5 = IMPOSSI#S1 E4G4 = IMMORTAL;Y4 ,& WI% MAY RELATE 6?+S T CD 9 NO WAY 2 BR"\ AB 0"O'S [N EF=TS1 E4G4 T A "PICUL> ACTOR OR A?LETE %D W9 9 A -PETI;N2 B NO "O *OOSES S* ?+S1 B ONLY ! ?+S T HE ?9KS CD 2 BR"\ AB 0HIS [N EF=TS4 ,AG1 WI% RELATES R 6! 5D1 *OICE 6! M1NS2 = 9/.E1 WE WI% 6BE H1L?Y1 B WE *OOSE ! ACTS : W MAKE U H1L?Y1 & WE WI% 6BE HAPPY & SAY WE D1 B WE _C WELL SAY WE *OOSE 6BE S2 =1 9 G5]AL1 *OICE SEEMS 6RELATE 6! ?+S T >E 9 \R [N P[]4 ,= ? R1SON1 TOO1 X _C 2 OP9ION2 = OP9ION IS ?"\ 6RELATE 6ALL K9DS ( ?+S1 NO LESS 6ET]NAL ?+S & IMPOSSI# ?+S ?AN 6?+S 9 \R [N P[]2 & X IS 4T+UI%$ 0XS FALS;Y OR TRU?1 N 0XS BAD;S OR GD;S1 :ILE *OICE IS 4T+UI%$ R 0^!4 ,N[ ) OP9ION 9 G5]AL P]H NO "O EV5 SAYS X IS ID5TICAL4 ,B X IS N ID5TICAL EV5 ) ANY K9D ( OP9ION2 = 0*OOS+ :AT IS GD OR BAD WE >E M5 (A C]TA9 "*1 : WE >E N 0HOLD+ C]TA9 OP9IONS4 ,& WE *OOSE 6GET OR AVOID "S?+ GD OR BAD1 B WE H OP9IONS AB :AT A ?+ IS OR :OM X IS GD = OR H[ X IS GD = HM2 WE C H>DLY 2 SD 6OP9E 6GET OR AVOID ANY?+4 ,& *OICE IS PRAIS$ = 2+ RELAT$ 6! "R OBJECT R ?AN = 2+ "RLY RELAT$ 6X1 OP9ION = 2+ TRULY RELAT$ 6XS OBJECT4 ,& WE *OOSE :AT WE BE/ "K 6BE GD1 B WE OP9E :AT WE D N Q "K2 & X IS N ! SAME P T >E ?"\ 6MAKE ! BE/ *OICES & 6H ! BE/ OP9IONS1 B "S >E ?"\ 6H FAIRLY GD OP9IONS1 B 0R1SON ( VICE 6*OOSE :AT !Y %D N4 ,IF OP9ION PREC$ES *OICE OR A3OMPANIES X1 T MAKES NO DI6];E2 = X IS N ? T WE >E 3SID]+1 B :E!R X IS ID5TICAL ) "S K9D ( OP9ION4 ,:AT1 !N1 OR :AT K9D ( ?+ IS X1 S9CE X IS N"O (! ?+S WE H M5;N$8 ,X SEEMS 6BE VOLUNT>Y1 B N ALL T IS VOLUNT>Y 6BE AN OBJECT ( *OICE4 ,IS X1 !N1 :AT HAS BE5 DECID$ ON 0PREVI\S DELIB],N8 ,AT ANY RATE *OICE 9VOLVES A R,NAL PR9CIPLE & ?"\4 ,EV5 ! "N SEEMS 6SU7E/ T X IS :AT IS *OS5 2F O!R ?+S4 #C ,D WE DELIB]ATE AB "EY?+1 & IS "EY?+ A POSSI# SUBJECT ( DELIB],N1 OR IS DELIB],N IMPOSSI# AB "S ?+S8 ,WE "\ PRESUMABLY 6CALL N :AT A FOOL OR A MADMAN WD DELIB]ATE AB1 B :AT A S5SI# MAN WD DELIB]ATE AB1 A SUBJECT ( DELIB],N4 ,N[ AB ET]NAL ?+S NO "O DELIB]ATES1 E4G4 AB ! MAT]IAL UNIV]SE OR ! 9COMM5SURABIL;Y (! DIAGONAL &! SIDE (A SQU>E4 ,B NO M D WE DELIB]ATE AB ! ?+S T 9VOLVE MOVE;T B ALW HAPP5 9 ! SAME WAY1 :E!R ( NECESS;Y OR 0NATURE OR F ANY O!R CAUSE1 E4G4 ! SOL/ICES &! RIS+S (! />S2 NOR AB ?+S T HAPP5 N[ 9 "O WAY1 N[ 9 ANO!R1 E4G4 DR"\S & RA9S2 NOR AB *.E EV5TS1 L ! F9D+ ( TR1SURE4 ,B WE D N DELIB]ATE EV5 AB ALL HUMAN A6AIRS2 = 9/.E1 NO ,S"PAN DELIB]ATES AB ! BE/ 3/ITU;N =! ,SCY?IANS4 ,= N"O ( ^! ?+S C 2 BR"\ AB 0\R [N EF=TS4 ,WE DELIB]ATE AB ?+S T >E 9 \R P[] & C 2 D"O2 & ^! >E 9 FACT :AT IS LEFT4 ,= NATURE1 NECESS;Y1 & *.E >E ?"\ 6BE CAUSES1 & AL R1SON & "EY?+ T DEP5DS ON MAN4 ,N[ E CLASS ( M5 DELIB]ATES AB ! ?+S T C 2 D"O 0_! [N EF=TS4 ,& 9 ! CASE ( EXACT & SELF-3TA9$ SCI;ES "! IS NO DELIB],N1 E4G4 AB ! LRS (! ALPHABET 7= WE H NO D\BT H[ !Y %D 2 WRITT572 B ! ?+S T >E BR"\ AB 0\R [N EF=TS1 B N ALW 9 ! SAME WAY1 >E ! ?+S AB : WE DELIB]ATE1 E4G4 "QS ( M$ICAL TR1T;T OR ( M"OY-MAK+4 ,& WE D S M 9 ! CASE (! >T ( NAVIG,N ?AN 9 T ( GYMNA/ICS1 9ASM* Z X HAS BE5 LESS EXACTLY "W$ \1 & AG AB O!R ?+S 9 ! SAME RATIO1 & M AL 9 ! CASE (! >TS ?AN 9 T (! SCI;ES2 = WE H M D\BT AB ! =M]4 ,DELIB],N IS 3C]N$ ) ?+S T HAPP5 9 A C]TA9 WAY =! MO/ "P1 B 9 : ! EV5T IS OBSCURE1 &) ?+S 9 : X IS 9DET]M9ATE4 ,WE CALL 9 O!RS 6AID U 9 DELIB],N ON IMPORTANT "QS1 4TRU/+ \RVS Z N 2+ EQUAL 6DECID+4 ,WE DELIB]ATE N AB 5DS B AB M1NS4 ,=A DOCTOR DOES N DELIB]ATE :E!R HE % H1L1 NOR AN ORATOR :E!R HE % P]SUADE1 NOR A /ATESMAN :E!R HE % PRODUCE LAW & ORD]1 NOR DOES ANY "O ELSE DELIB]ATE AB 8 5D4 ,!Y ASSUME ! 5D & 3SID] H[ & 0:AT M1NS X IS 6BE ATTA9$2 & IF X SEEMS 6BE PRODUC$ 0S"EAL M1NS !Y 3SID] 0: X IS MO/ EASILY & BE/ PRODUC$1 :ILE IF X IS A*IEV$ 0"O ONLY !Y 3SID] H[ X W 2 A*IEV$ 0? & 0:AT M1NS ? W 2 A*IEV$1 TILL !Y -E 6! F/ CAUSE1 : 9 ! ORD] ( 4COV]Y IS LA/4 ,=! P]SON :O DELIB]ATES SEEMS 69VE/IGATE & ANALYSE 9 ! WAY DESCRIB$ Z ?\< HE 7 ANALYS+ A GEOMETRICAL 3/RUC;N 7N ALL 9VE/IG,N APPE>S 6BE DELIB],N- = 9/.E MA!MATICAL 9VE/IG,NS- B ALL DELIB],N IS 9VE/IG,N71 & :AT IS LA/ 9 ! ORD] ( ANALYSIS SEEMS 6BE F/ 9 ! ORD] ( 2COM+4 ,& IF WE -E ON AN IMPOSSIBIL;Y1 WE GIVE UP ! SE>*1 E4G4 IF WE NE$ M"OY & ? _C 2 GOT2 B IF A ?+ APPE>S POSSI# WE TRY 6D X4 ,BY ,8POSSI#0' ?+S ,I M1N ?+S T MILY 9 ! O!R CASES- "S"TS ! M1NS1 "S"TS ! MODE ( US+ X OR ! M1NS ( BR++ X AB4 ,X SEEMS1 !N1 Z HAS BE5 SD1 T MAN IS A MOV+ PR9CIPLE ( AC;NS2 N[ DELIB],N IS AB ! ?+S 6BE D"O 0! AG5T HMF1 & AC;NS >E =! SAKE ( ?+S O!R ?AN !MVS4 ,=! 5D _C 2 A SUBJECT ( DELIB],N1 B ONLY ! M1NS2 NOR 9DE$ C ! "PICUL> FACTS 2 A SUBJECT ( X1 Z :E!R ? IS BR1D OR HAS BE5 BAK$ Z X %D2 = ^! >E MATT]S ( P]CEP;N4 ,IF WE >E 6BE ALW DELIB]AT+1 WE % H 6G ON 69F9;Y4 ,! SAME ?+ IS DELIB]AT$ ^U & IS *OS51 EXCEPT T ! OBJECT ( *OICE IS ALR DET]M9ATE1 S9CE X IS T : HAS BE5 DECID$ ^U Z A RESULT ( DELIB],N T IS ! OBJECT ( *OICE4 ,= E "O C1SES 69QUIRE H[ HE IS 6ACT :5 HE HAS BR"\ ! MOV+ PR9CIPLE BACK 6HMF & 6! RUL+ "P ( HMF2 = ? IS :AT *OOSES4 ,? IS PLA9 AL F ! ANCI5T 3/ITU;NS1 : ,HOM] REPRES5T$2 =! K+S ANN\NC$ _! *OICES 6! P4 ,! OBJECT ( *OICE 2+ "O (! ?+S 9 \R [N P[] : IS DESIR$ AF DELIB],N1 *OICE W 2 DELIB]ATE DESIRE ( ?+S 9 \R [N P[]2 = :5 WE H DECID$ Z A RESULT ( DELIB],N1 WE DESIRE 9 A3ORD.E ) \R DELIB],N4 ,WE MAY TAKE X1 !N1 T WE H DESCRIB$ *OICE 9 \TL9E1 & /AT$ ! NATURE ( XS OBJECTS &! FACT T X IS 3C]N$ ) M1NS4 #D ,T WI% IS =! 5D HAS ALR BE5 /AT$2 "S ?9K X IS =! GD1 O!RS =! APP>5T GD4 ,N[ ^? :O SAY T ! GD IS ! OBJECT ( WI% M/ ADMIT 9 3SEQU;E T T : ! MAN :O DOES N *OOSE A"R WI%ES = IS N AN OBJECT ( WI% 7= IF X IS 6BE S1 X M/ AL 2 GD2 B X WAS1 IF X S HAPP5$1 BAD72 :ILE ^? :O SAY ! APP>5T GD IS ! OBJECT ( WI% M/ ADMIT T "! IS NO NATURAL OBJECT ( WI%1 B ONLY :AT SEEMS GD 6EA* MAN4 ,N[ DI6]5T ?+S APPE> GD 6DI6]5T P1 &1 IF X S HAPP5S1 EV5 3TR>Y ?+S4 ,IF ^! 3SEQU;ES >E UNPL1S+1 >E WE 6SAY T ABSOLUTELY & 9 TRU? ! GD IS ! OBJECT ( WI%1 B = EA* P]SON ! APP>5T GD2 T T : IS 9 TRU? AN OBJECT ( WI% IS AN OBJECT ( WI% 6! GD MAN1 :ILE ANY *.E ?+ MAY 2 S ! BAD MAN1 Z 9 ! CASE ( BODIES AL ! ?+S T >E 9 TRU? :OLE"S >E :OLE"S = BODIES : >E 9 GD 3DI;N1 :ILE = ^? T >E 41S$ O!R ?+S >E :OLE"S- OR BITT] OR SWEET OR HOT OR H1VY1 & S ON2 S9CE ! GD MAN JUDGES EA* CLASS ( ?+S "RLY1 & 9 EA* ! TRU? APPE>S 6HM8 ,= EA* /ATE ( "* HAS XS [N ID1S (! NO# &! PL1SANT1 & P]H ! GD MAN DI6]S F O!RS MO/ 0SEE+ ! TRU? 9 EA* CLASS ( ?+S1 2+ Z X 7 ! NORM & M1SURE ( !M4 ,9 MO/ ?+S ! ]ROR SEEMS 6BE DUE 6PL1SURE2 = X APPE>S A GD :5 X IS N4 ,WE "!=E *OOSE ! PL1SANT Z A GD1 & AVOID PA9 Z AN EVIL4 #E ,! 5D1 !N1 2+ :AT WE WI% =1 ! M1NS :AT WE DELIB]ATE AB & *OOSE1 AC;NS 3C]N+ M1NS M/ 2 AC 6*OICE & VOLUNT>Y4 ,N[ ! EX]CISE (! VIRTUES IS 3C]N$ ) M1NS4 ,"!=E VIRTUE AL IS 9 \R [N P[]1 & S TOO VICE4 ,= ": X IS 9 \R P[] 6ACT X IS AL 9 \R P[] N 6ACT1 & VICE V]SA2 S T1 IF 6ACT1 ": ? IS NO#1 IS 9 \R P[]1 N 6ACT1 : W 2 BASE1 W AL 2 9 \R P[]1 & IF N 6ACT1 ": ? IS NO#1 IS 9 \R P[]1 6ACT1 : W 2 BASE1 W AL 2 9 \R P[]4 ,N[ IF X IS 9 \R P[] 6D NO# OR BASE ACTS1 & LIKEWISE 9 \R P[] N 6D !M1 & ? 0 :AT 2+ GD OR BAD M1NT1 !N X IS 9 \R P[] 6BE VIRTU\S OR VICI\S4 ,! SAY+ T ,8NO "O IS VOLUNT>ILY WICK$ NOR 9VOLUNT>ILY HAPPY0' SEEMS 6BE "PLY FALSE & "PLY TRUE2 = NO "O IS 9VOLUNT>ILY HAPPY1 B WICK$;S IS VOLUNT>Y4 ,OR ELSE WE % H 64PUTE :AT HAS J BE5 SD1 AT ANY RATE1 & D5Y T MAN IS A MOV+ PR9CIPLE OR 2GETT] ( 8 AC;NS Z ( *N4 ,B IF ^! FACTS >E EVID5T & WE _C REF] AC;NS 6MOV+ PR9CIPLES O!R ?AN ^? 9 \RVS1 ! ACTS ^: MOV+ PR9CIPLES >E 9 U M/ !MVS AL 2 9 \R P[] & VOLUNT>Y4 ,WIT;S SEEMS 6BE BORNE 6? BO? 09DIVIDUALS 9 _! PRIVATE CAPAC;Y & 0LEGISLATORS !MVS2 = ^! PUNI% & TAKE V5GE.E ON ^? :O D WICK$ ACTS 7UN.S !Y H ACT$ "U -PUL.N OR Z A RESULT ( IGNOR.E = : !Y >E N !MVS RESPONSI#71 :ILE !Y HON\R ^? :O D NO# ACTS1 Z ?\< !Y M1NT 65C\RAGE ! LATT] & DET] ! =M]4 ,B NO "O IS 5C\RAG$ 6D ! ?+S T >E NEI 9 \R P[] NOR VOLUNT>Y2 X IS ASSUM$ T "! IS NO GA9 9 2+ P]SUAD$ N 6BE HOT OR 9 PA9 OR HUNGRY OR ! L1 S9CE WE % EXP]I;E ^! FEEL+S N"O ! LESS4 ,9DE$1 WE PUNI% A MAN = 8 V IGNOR.E1 IF HE IS ?"\ RESPONSI# =! IGNOR.E1 Z :5 P5ALTIES >E D\#D 9 ! CASE ( DRUNK5;S2 =! MOV+ PR9CIPLE IS 9 ! MAN HMF1 S9CE HE _H ! P[] ( N GETT+ DRUNK & 8 GETT+ DRUNK 0 ! CAUSE ( 8 IGNOR.E4 ,& WE PUNI% ^? :O >E IGNORANT ( ANY?+ 9 ! LAWS T !Y "\ 6"K & T IS N DI6ICULT1 & S TOO 9 ! CASE ( ANY?+ ELSE T !Y >E ?"\ 6BE IGNORANT ( "? C>E.S;S2 WE ASSUME T X IS 9 _! P[] N 6BE IGNORANT1 S9CE !Y H ! P[] ( TAK+ C>E4 ,B P]H A MAN IS ! K9D ( MAN N 6TAKE C>E4 ,/ !Y >E !MVS 0_! SLACK LIVES RESPONSI# = 2COM+ M5 ( T K9D1 & M5 MAKE !MVS RESPONSI# = 2+ UNJU/ OR SELF- 9DULG5T1 9 ! "O CASE 0*1T+ & 9 ! O!R 0SP5D+ _! "T 9 DR9K+ B\TS &! L2 = X IS ACTIVITIES EX]CIS$ ON "PICUL> OBJECTS T MAKE ! CORRESPOND+ "*4 ,? IS PLA9 F ! CASE ( P TRA9+ = ANY 3TE/ OR AC;N2 !Y PRACTISE ! ACTIV;Y ! :OLE "T4 ,N[ N 6"K T X IS F ! EX]CISE ( ACTIVITIES ON "PICUL> OBJECTS T /ATES ( "* >E PRODUC$ IS ! M>K (A ?OR\ILY4 ,YET X DOES N FOLL[ T IF HE WI%ES HE W C1SE 6BE UNJU/ & W 2 J4 ,= NEI DOES ! MAN :O IS ILL 2COME WELL ON ^? T]MS4 ,WE MAY SUPPOSE A CASE 9 : HE IS ILL VOLUNT>ILY1 "? LIV+ 9CONT95TLY & 4OBEY+ 8 DOCTORS4 ,9 T CASE X 0 !N OP5 6HM N 6BE ILL1 B N N[1 :5 HE HAS ?R[N AWAY 8 *.E1 J Z :5 Y H LET A /"O G X IS TOO LATE 6RECOV] X2 B YET X 0 9 YR P[] 6?R[ X1 S9CE ! MOV+ PR9CIPLE 0 9 Y4 ,S1 TOO1 6! UNJU/ & 6! SELF-9DULG5T MAN X 0 OP5 AT ! 2G9N+ N 62COME M5 ( ? K9D1 & S !Y >E UNJU/ & SELF9DULG5T VOLUNT>ILY2 B N[ T !Y H 2COME S X IS N POSSI# = !M N 6BE S4 ,B N ONLY >E ! VICES (! S\L VOLUNT>Y1 B ^? (! BODY AL = "S M51 :OM WE ACLY BLAME2 :ILE NO "O BLAMES ^? :O >E UGLY 0NATURE1 WE BLAME ^? :O >E S [+ 6WANT ( EX]CISE & C>E4 ,S X IS1 TOO1 ) RESPECT 6W1K;S & 9FIRM;Y2 NO "O WD REPROA* A MAN BL F BIR? OR 041SE OR F A BL[1 B R P;Y HM1 :ILE E "O WD BLAME A MAN :O 0 BL F DRUNK5;S OR "S O!R =M ( SELF-9DULG;E4 ,( VICES (! BODY1 !N1 ^? 9 \R [N P[] >E BLAM$1 ^? N 9 \R P[] >E N4 ,& IF ? 2 S1 9 ! O!R CASES AL ! VICES T >E BLAM$ M/ 2 9 \R [N P[]4 ,N[ "S "O MAY SAY T ALL M5 DESIRE ! APP>5T GD1 B H NO 3TROL OV] ! APPE>.E1 B ! 5D APPE>S 6EA* MAN 9 A =M ANSW]+ 6HIS "*4 ,WE REPLY T IF EA* MAN IS "SH[ RESPONSI# = 8 /ATE ( M9D1 HE W AL 2 HMF "SH[ RESPONSI# =! APPE>.E2 B IF N1 NO "O IS RESPONSI# = 8 [N EVILDO+1 B E "O DOES EVIL ACTS "? IGNOR.E (! 5D1 ?9K+ T 0^! HE W GET :AT IS BE/1 &! AIM+ AT ! 5D IS N SELF-*OS5 B "O M/ 2 BORN ) AN EYE1 Z X W]E1 0: 6JUDGE "RLY & *OOSE :AT IS TRULY GD1 & HE IS WELL 5D[$ 0NATURE :O IS WELL 5D[$ ) ?4 ,= X IS :AT IS GRTE/ & MO/ NO#1 & :AT WE _C GET OR LE>N F ANO!R1 B M/ H J S* Z X 0 :5 GIV5 U AT BIR?1 & 6BE WELL & NOBLY 5D[$ ) ? W 2 P]FECT & TRUE EXCELL;E ( NATURAL 5D[;T4 ,IF ? IS TRUE1 !N1 H[ W VIRTUE 2 M VOLUNT>Y ?AN VICE8 ,6BO? M5 ALIKE1 ! GD &! BAD1 ! 5D APPE>S & IS FIX$ 0NATURE OR H["E X MAY BE1 & X IS 0REF]R+ "EY?+ ELSE 6? T M5 D :AT"E !Y D4 ,:E!R1 !N1 X IS N 0NATURE T ! 5D APPE>S 6EA* MAN S* Z X DOES APPE>1 B "S?+ AL DEP5DS ON HM1 OR ! 5D IS NATURAL B 2C ! GD MAN ADOPTS ! M1NS VOLUNT>ILY VIRTUE IS VOLUNT>Y1 VICE AL W 2 N"O ! LESS VOLUNT>Y2 = 9 ! CASE (! BAD MAN "! IS EQU,Y PRES5T T : DEP5DS ON HMF 9 8 AC;NS EV5 IF N 9 8 5D4 ,IF1 !N1 Z IS ASS]T$1 ! VIRTUES >E VOLUNT>Y 7= WE >E \RVS "SH[ "PLY RESPONSI# = \R /ATES ( "*1 & X IS 02+ P]SONS (A C]TA9 K9D T WE ASSUME ! 5D 6BE S & S71 ! VICES AL W 2 VOLUNT>Y2 =! SAME IS TRUE ( !M4 ,) REG>D 6! VIRTUES 9 G5]AL WE H /AT$ _! G5US 9 \TL9E1 VIZ4 T !Y >E M1NS & T !Y >E /ATES ( "*1 & T !Y T5D1 & 0_! [N NATURE1 6! DO+ (! ACTS 0: !Y >E PRODUC$1 & T !Y >E 9 \R P[] & VOLUNT>Y1 & ACT Z ! "R RULE PRESCRIBES4 ,B AC;NS & /ATES ( "* >E N VOLUNT>Y 9 ! SAME WAY2 = WE >E MA/]S ( \R AC;NS F ! 2G9N+ "R 6! 5D1 IF WE "K ! "PICUL> FACTS1 B ?\< WE 3TROL ! 2G9N+ ( \R /ATES ( "* ! GRADUAL PROGRESS IS N OBVI\S ANY M ?AN X IS 9 ILL;SES2 2C X 0 9 \R P[]1 H["E1 6ACT 9 ? WAY OR N 9 ? WAY1 "!=E ! /ATES >E VOLUNT>Y4 ,LET U TAKE UP ! S"EAL VIRTUES1 H["E1 & SAY : !Y >E & :AT SORT ( ?+S !Y >E 3C]N$ )& H[ !Y >E 3C]N$ ) !M2 AT ! SAME "T X W 2COME PLA9 H[ _M !Y >E4 ,& F/ LET U SP1K ( C\RAGE4 #F ,T X IS A M1N ) REG>D 6FEEL+S ( FE> & 3FID;E HAS ALR BE5 MADE EVID5T2 & PLA9LY ! ?+S WE FE> >E T]RI# ?+S1 & ^! >E1 6SP1K )\T QUALIFIC,N1 EVILS2 = : R1SON P EV5 DEF9E FE> Z EXPECT,N ( EVIL4 ,N[ WE FE> ALL EVILS1 E4G4 4GRACE1 POV]TY1 41SE1 FR.S;S1 D1?1 B ! BRAVE MAN IS N ?"\ 6BE 3C]N$ ) ALL2 = 6FE> "S ?+S IS EV5 "R & NO#1 & X IS BASE N 6FE> !M- E4G4 4GRACE2 HE :O FE>S ? IS GD & MODE/1 & HE :O DOES N IS %AME.S4 ,HE IS1 H["E1 0"S P CALL$ BRAVE1 0A TRANSF];E (! ^W 6A NEW M1N+2 = HE HAS 9 HM "S?+ : IS L ! BRAVE MAN1 S9CE ! BRAVE MAN AL IS A FE>.S P]SON4 ,POV]TY & 41SE WE P]H "\ N 6FE>1 NOR 9 G5]AL ! ?+S T D N PROCE$ F VICE & >E N DUE 6A MAN HMF4 ,B N EV5 ! MAN :O IS FE>.S ( ^! IS BRAVE4 ,YET WE APPLY ! ^W 6HM AL 9 VIRTUE (A SIMIL>;Y2 = "S :O 9 ! DANG]S ( W> >E C[>DS >E LIB]AL & >E 3FID5T 9 FACE (! LOSS ( M"OY4 ,NOR IS A MAN A C[>D IF HE FE>S 9SULT 6HIS WIFE & *N OR 5VY OR ANY?+ (! K9D2 NOR BRAVE IF HE IS 3FID5T :5 HE IS AB 6BE FLO7$4 ,) :AT SORT ( T]RI# ?+S1 !N1 IS ! BRAVE MAN 3C]N$8 ,SURELY )! GRTE/2 = NO "O IS M LIKELY ?AN HE 6/& 8 GR.D AG/ :AT IS AWE-9SPIR+4 ,N[ D1? IS ! MO/ T]RI# ( ALL ?+S2 = X IS ! 5D1 & NO?+ IS ?"\ 6BE ANY L;G] EI GD OR BAD =! D1D4 ,B ! BRAVE MAN WD N SEEM 6BE 3C]N$ EV5 ) D1? 9 ALL CIRCUM/.ES1 E4G4 AT SEA OR 9 41SE4 ,9 :AT CIRCUM/.ES1 !N8 ,SURELY 9 ! NO#/4 ,N[ S* D1?S >E ^? 9 BATTLE2 = ^! TAKE PLACE 9 ! GRTE/ & NO#/ DANG]4 ,& ^! >E CORRESPOND+LY HON\R$ 9 C;Y-/ATES & AT ! C\RTS ( MON>*S4 ,PROP]LY1 !N1 HE W 2 CALL$ BRAVE :O IS FE>.S 9 FACE (A NO# D1?1 &( ALL EM]G5CIES T 9VOLVE D1?2 &! EM]G5CIES ( W> >E 9 ! HI.S1 B N 9 ! SAME WAY Z ! S1MAN2 = HE HAS GIV5 UP HOPE ( SAFETY1 & IS 4LIK+ ! ?"\ ( D1? 9 ? %APE1 :ILE !Y >E HOPE;L 2C ( _! EXP]I;E4 ,AT ! SAME "T1 WE %[ C\RAGE 9 SITU,NS ": "! IS ! OPPORTUN;Y ( %[+ PR[ESS OR ": D1? IS NO#2 B 9 ^! =MS ( D1? NEI ( ^! 3DI;NS IS FULFILL$4 #G ,:AT IS T]RI# IS N ! SAME = ALL M52 B WE SAY "! >E ?+S T]RI# EV5 2Y HUMAN /R5G?4 ,^!1 !N1 >E T]RI# 6E "O- AT L1/ 6E S5SI# MAN2 B ! T]RI# ?+S T >E N 2Y HUMAN /R5G? DI6] 9 MAGNITUDE & DEGREE1 & S TOO D ! ?+S T 9SPIRE 3FID;E4 ,N[ ! BRAVE MAN IS Z DAUNT.S Z MAN MAY BE4 ,"!=E1 :ILE HE W FE> EV5 ! ?+S T >E N 2Y HUMAN /R5G?1 HE W FACE !M Z HE "\ & Z ! RULE DIRECTS1 = HON\R'S SAKE2 = ? IS ! 5D ( VIRTUE4 ,B X IS POSSI# 6FE> ^! M1 OR LESS1 & AG 6FE> ?+S T >E N T]RI# Z IF !Y W]E4 ,(! FAULTS T >E -MITT$ "O 3SI/S 9 FE>+ :AT "O %D N1 ANO!R 9 FE>+ Z WE %D N1 ANO!R 9 FE>+ :5 WE %D N1 & S ON2 & S TOO ) RESPECT 6! ?+S T 9SPIRE 3FID;E4 ,! MAN1 !N1 :O FACES & :O FE>S ! "R ?+S & F ! "R MOTIVE1 9 ! "R WAY & F ! "R "T1 & :O FEELS 3FID;E "U ! CORRESPOND+ 3DI;NS1 IS BRAVE2 =! BRAVE MAN FEELS & ACTS AC 6! M]ITS (! CASE & 9 :AT"E WAY ! RULE DIRECTS4 ,N[ ! 5D ( E ACTIV;Y IS 3=M;Y 6! CORRESPOND+ /ATE ( "*4 ,? IS TRUE1 "!=E1 (! BRAVE MAN Z WELL Z ( O!RS4 ,B C\RAGE IS NO#4 ,"!=E ! 5D AL IS NO#2 = EA* ?+ IS DEF9$ 0XS 5D4 ,"!=E X IS =A NO# 5D T ! BRAVE MAN 5DURES & ACTS Z C\RAGE DIRECTS4 ,( ^? :O G 6EXCESS HE :O EXCE$S 9 FE>.S;S HAS NO "N 7WE H SD PREVI\SLY T _M /ATES ( "* H NO "NS71 B HE WD 2 A SORT ( MADMAN OR 9S5SI# P]SON IF HE FE>$ NO?+1 NEI E>?QUAKES NOR ! WAVES1 Z !Y SAY ! ,CELTS D N2 :ILE ! MAN :O EXCE$S 9 3FID;E AB :AT RE,Y IS T]RI# IS RA%4 ,! RA% MAN1 H["E1 IS AL ?"\ 6BE BOA/;L & ONLY A PRET5D] 6C\RAGE2 AT ALL EV5TS1 Z ! BRAVE MAN IS ) REG>D 6:AT IS T]RI#1 S ! RA% MAN WI%ES 6APPE>2 & S HE IMITATES HM 9 SITU,NS ": HE C4 ,H;E AL MO/ ( !M >E A MIXTURE ( RA%;S & C[>DICE2 =1 :ILE 9 ^! SITU,NS !Y 4PLAY 3FID;E1 !Y D N HOLD _! GR.D AG/ :AT IS RE,Y T]RI#4 ,! MAN :O EXCE$S 9 FE> IS A C[>D2 = HE FE>S BO? :AT HE "\ N & Z HE "\ N1 & ALL ! SIMIL> "*IZ,NS ATTA* 6HM4 ,HE IS LACK+ AL 9 3FID;E2 B HE IS M 3SPICU\S = 8 EXCESS ( FE> 9 PA9;L SITU,NS4 ,! C[>D1 !N1 IS A DESPAIR+ SORT ( P]SON2 = HE FE>S "EY?+4 ,! BRAVE MAN1 ON ! O!R H&1 HAS ! OPPOSITE 4POSI;N2 = 3FID;E IS ! M>K (A HOPE;L 4POSI;N4 ,! C[>D1 ! RA% MAN1 &! BRAVE MAN1 !N1 >E 3C]N$ )! SAME OBJECTS B >E DI6]5TLY 4POS$ T[>DS !M2 =! F/ TWO EXCE$ & FALL %ORT1 :ILE ! ?IRD HOLDS ! MI4LE1 : IS ! "R1 POSI;N2 & RA% M5 >E PRECIPITATE1 & WI% = DANG]S 2FH& B DRAW BACK :5 !Y >E 9 !M1 :ILE BRAVE M5 >E KE5 9 ! MO;T ( AC;N1 B QUIET 2FH&4 ,Z WE H SD1 !N1 C\RAGE IS A M1N ) RESPECT 6?+S T 9SPIRE 3FID;E OR FE>1 9 ! CIRCUM/.ES T H BE5 /AT$2 & X *OOSES OR 5DURES ?+S 2C X IS NO# 6D S1 OR 2C X IS BASE N 6D S4 ,B 6DIE 6ESCAPE F POV]TY OR LOVE OR ANY?+ PA9;L IS N ! M>K (A BRAVE MAN1 B R (A C[>D2 = X IS S(T;S 6FLY F :AT IS TR\#"S1 & S* A MAN 5DURES D1? N 2C X IS NO# B 6FLY F EVIL4 #H ,C\RAGE1 !N1 IS "S?+ ( ? SORT1 B ! "N IS AL APPLI$ 6FIVE O!R K9DS4 ,F/ -ES ! C\RAGE (! CITIZ5-SOLDI]2 = ? IS MO/ L TRUE C\RAGE4 ,CITIZ5-SOLDI]S SEEM 6FACE DANG]S 2C (! P5ALTIES IMPOS$ 0! LAWS &! REPROA*ES !Y WD O!RWISE 9CUR1 & 2C (! HON\RS !Y W9 0S* AC;N2 & "!=E ^? PEOPLES SEEM 6BE BRAVE/ AM;G :OM C[>DS >E HELD 9 4HON\R & BRAVE M5 9 HON\R4 ,? IS ! K9D ( C\RAGE T ,HOM] DEPICTS1 E4G4 9 ,DIOM$E & 9 ,HECTOR3 ,F/ W ,POLYDAMAS 2 6H1P REPROA* ON ME !N2 & ,= ,HECTOR "O "D ,8MID ! ,TROJANS % UTT] 8 VAULT+ H>ANGUE3 ,AFRAID 0 ,TYDEIDES1 & FL$ F MY FACE4 ,? K9D ( C\RAGE IS MO/ L 6T : WE DESCRIB$ E>LI]1 2C X IS DUE 6VIRTUE2 = X IS DUE 6%AME & 6DESIRE (A NO# OBJECT 7I4E4 HON\R7 & AVOID.E ( 4GRACE1 : IS IGNO#4 ,"O MIE -PELL$ 0_! RUL]S2 B !Y >E 9F]IOR1 9ASM* Z !Y D :AT !Y D N F %AME B F FE>1 & 6AVOID N :AT IS 4GRACE;L B :AT IS PA9;L2 = _! MA/]S -PEL !M1 Z ,HECTOR DOES3 ,B IF ,I % SPY ANY DA/>D T C[]S F> F ! FID 6"PICUL> FACTS IS AL ?"\ 6BE C\RAGE2 ? IS 9DE$ ! R1SON :Y ,SOCRATES ?"\ C\RAGE 0 K4 ,O!R P EXHIBIT ? QUAL;Y 9 O!R DANG]S1 & PROFES.NAL SOLDI]S EXHIBIT X 9 ! DANG]S ( W>2 = "! SEEM 6BE _M EMPTY AL>MS 9 W>1 ( : ^! H _H ! MO/ -PREH5SIVE EXP]I;E2 "!=E !Y SEEM BRAVE1 2C ! O!RS D N "K ! NATURE (! FACTS4 ,AG1 _! EXP]I;E MAKES !M MO/ CAPA# 9 ATTACK & 9 DEF;E1 S9CE !Y C USE _! >MS & H ! K9D T >E LIKELY 6BE BE/ BO? = ATTACK &= DEF;E2 "!=E !Y FIM$ M5 AG/ UN>M$ OR L TRA9$ A?LETES AG/ AMATEURS2 = 9 S* 3TE/S TOO X IS N ! BRAVE/ M5 T FIE /R;GE/ & H _! BODIES 9 ! BE/ 3DI;N4 ,PROFES.NAL SOLDI]S TURN C[>DS1 H["E1 :5 ! DANG] PUTS TOO GRT A /RA9 ON !M & !Y >E 9F]IOR 9 NUMB]S & EQUIP;T2 = !Y >E ! F/ 6FLY1 :ILE CITIZ5-=CES DIE AT _! PO/S1 Z 9 FACT HAPP5$ AT ! TEMPLE ( ,H]MES4 ,= 6! LATT] FLI+ D1? M ?AN 4GRACE2 B ! BRAVE MAN IS N T SORT ( P]SON4 ,PAS.N AL IS "S"TS RECKON$ Z C\RAGE2 ^? :O ACT F PAS.N1 L WILD B1/S RU%+ AT ^? :O H W.D$ !M1 >E ?"\ 6BE BRAVE1 2C BRAVE M5 AL >E PAS.NATE2 = PAS.N ABV ALL ?+S IS EAG] 6RU% ON DANG]1 & H;E ,HOM]'S ,8PUT /R5G? 96HIS PAS.N0' & ,8>\S$ _! _S & PAS.N & ,8H>D HE BR1!D PANT+0' & ,8HIS BLOOD BOIL$0'4 ,= ALL S* EXPRES.NS SEEM 69DICATE ! /IRR+ & ONSET ( PAS.N4 ,N[ BRAVE M5 ACT = HON\R'S SAKE1 B PAS.N AIDS !M2 :ILE WILD B1/S ACT "U ! 9FLU;E ( PA92 = !Y ATTACK 2C !Y H BE5 W.D$ OR 2C !Y >E AFRAID1 S9CE IF !Y >E 9 A =E/ !Y D N -E NE> "O4 ,?US !Y >E N BRAVE 2C1 DRIV5 0PA9 & PAS.N1 !Y RU% ON DANG] )\T =ESEE+ ANY (! P]ILS1 S9CE AT T RATE EV5 ASSES WD 2 BRAVE :5 !Y >E HUNGRY2 = BL[S W N DRIVE !M F _! FOOD2 & LU/ AL MAKES ADULT]]S D _M D>+ ?+S4 7,^? CR1TURES >E N BRAVE1 !N1 : >E DRIV5 ON 6DANG] 0PA9 OR PAS.N47 ,! ,8C\RAGE0' T IS DUE 6PAS.N SEEMS 6BE ! MO/ NATURAL1 & 6BE C\RAGE IF *OICE & MOTIVE 2 A4$4 ,M51 !N1 Z WELL Z B1/S1 SU6] PA9 :5 !Y >E ANGRY1 & >E PL1S$ :5 !Y EXACT _! REV5GE2 ^? :O FIE PUGNACI\S B N BRAVE2 = !Y D N ACT = HON\R'S SAKE NOR Z ! RULE DIRECTS1 B F /R5G? ( FEEL+2 !Y H1 H["E1 "S?+ AK9 6C\RAGE4 ,NOR >E SANGU9E P BRAVE2 = !Y >E 3FID5T 9 DANG] ONLY 2C !Y H 3QU]$ (T5 & AG/ _M FOES4 ,YET !Y CLOSELY RESEM# BRAVE M51 2C BO? >E 3FID5T2 B BRAVE M5 >E 3FID5T =! R1SONS /AT$ E>LI]1 :ILE ^! >E S 2C !Y ?9K !Y >E ! /R;GE/ & C SU6] NO?+4 7,DRUNK5 M5 AL 2HAVE 9 ? WAY2 !Y 2COME SANGU9E74 ,:5 _! ADV5TURES D N SU3E$1 H["E1 !Y RUN AWAY2 B X 0 ! M>K (A BRAVE MAN 6FACE ?+S T >E1 & SEEM1 T]RI# =A MAN1 2C X IS NO# 6D S & 4GRACE;L N 6D S4 ,H;E AL X IS ?"\ ! M>K (A BRAV] MAN 6BE FE>.S & UNDISTURB$ 9 SU45 AL>MS ?AN 6BE S 9 ^? T >E =ESE52 = X M/ H PROCE$$ M F A /ATE ( "*1 2C LESS F PREP>,N2 ACTS T >E =ESE5 MAY 2 *OS5 0CALCUL,N & RULE1 B SU45 AC;NS M/ 2 9 A3ORD.E ) "O'S /ATE ( "*4 ,P :O >E IGNORANT (! DANG] AL APPE> BRAVE1 & !Y >E N F> REMOV$ F ^? (A SANGU9E TEMP]1 B >E 9F]IOR 9ASM* Z !Y H NO SELF-RELI.E :ILE ^! H4 ,H;E AL ! SANGU9E HOLD _! GR.D =A "T2 B ^? :O H BE5 DCVD AB ! FACTS FLY IF !Y "K OR SUSPECT T ^! >E DI6]5T F :AT !Y SUPPOS$1 Z HAPP5$ 6! ,>GIVES :5 !Y FELL 9 )! ,S"PANS & TOOK !M = ,SICYONIANS4 ,WE H1 !N1 DESCRIB$ ! "* BO? ( BRAVE M5 &( ^? :O >E ?"\ 6BE BRAVE4 #I ,?\< C\RAGE IS 3C]N$ ) FEEL+S ( 3FID;E &( FE>1 X IS N 3C]N$ ) BO? ALIKE1 B M )! ?+S T 9SPIRE FE>2 = HE :O IS UNDISTURB$ 9 FACE ( ^! & BE>S HMF Z HE %D T[>DS ^! IS M TRULY BRAVE ?AN ! MAN :O DOES S T[>DS ! ?+S T 9SPIRE 3FID;E4 ,X IS = FAC+ :AT IS PA9;L1 !N1 Z HAS BE5 SD1 T M5 >E CALL$ BRAVE4 ,H;E AL C\RAGE 9VOLVES PA91 & IS JU/LY PRAIS$2 = X IS H>D] 6FACE :AT IS PA9;L ?AN 6AB/A9 F :AT IS PL1SANT4 ,YET ! 5D : C\RAGE SETS 2F X WD SEEM 6BE PL1SANT1 B 6BE 3C1L$ 0! ATT5D+ CIRCUM/.ES1 Z HAPP5S AL 9 A?LETIC 3TE/S2 =! 5D AT : BOX]S AIM IS PL1SANT- ! CR[N &! HON\RS- B ! BL[S !Y TAKE >E 4TRESS+ 6FLE% & BLOOD1 & PA9;L1 & S IS _! :OLE EX];N2 & 2C ! BL[S &! EX];NS >E _M ! 5D1 : IS B SMALL1 APPE>S 6H NO?+ PL1SANT 9 X4 ,& S1 IF ! CASE ( C\RAGE IS SIMIL>1 D1? & W.DS W 2 PA9;L 6! BRAVE MAN & AG/ 8 W1 B HE W FACE !M 2C X IS NO# 6D S OR 2C X IS BASE N 6D S4 ,&! M HE IS POSSESS$ ( VIRTUE 9 XS 5TIRETY &! HAPPI] HE IS1 ! M HE W 2 PA9$ AT ! ?"\ ( D1?2 = LIFE IS BE/ WOR? LIV+ = S* A MAN1 & HE IS "K+LY LOS+ ! GRTE/ GDS1 & ? IS PA9;L4 ,B HE IS N"O ! LESS BRAVE1 & P]H ALL ! M S1 2C HE *OOSES NO# DE$S ( W> AT T CO/4 ,X IS N ! CASE1 !N1 ) ALL ! VIRTUES T ! EX]CISE ( !M IS PL1SANT1 EXCEPT 9 S F> Z X R1*ES XS 5D4 ,B X IS Q POSSI# T ! BE/ SOLDI]S MAY 2 N M5 ( ? SORT B ^? :O >E LESS BRAVE B H NO O!R GD2 = ^! >E R1DY 6FACE DANG]1 & !Y SELL _! LIFE = TRIFL+ GA9S4 ,S M*1 !N1 = C\RAGE2 X IS N DI6ICULT 6GRASP XS NATURE 9 \TL9E1 AT ANY RATE1 F :AT HAS BE5 SD4 #AJ ,AF C\RAGE LET U SP1K ( TEMP].E2 = ^! SEEM 6BE ! VIRTUES (! IRR,NAL "PS4 ,WE H SD T TEMP].E IS A M1N ) REG>D 6PL1SURES 7= X IS LESS1 & N 9 ! SAME WAY1 3C]N$ ) PA9S72 SELF-9DULG;E AL IS MANIFE/$ 9 ! SAME SPH]E4 ,N[1 "!=E1 LET U DET]M9E ) :AT SORT ( PL1SURES !Y >E 3C]N$4 ,WE MAY ASSUME ! 4T9C;N 2T BODILY PL1SURES & ^? (! S\L1 S* Z LOVE ( HON\R & LOVE ( LE>N+2 =! LOV] ( EA* ( ^! DELIE 3C]N$ ) S* PL1SURES >E CALL$ NEI TEMP]ATE NOR SELF- 9DULG5T4 ,NOR1 AG1 >E ^? :O >E 3C]N$ )! O!R PL1SURES T >E N BODILY2 = ^? :O >E FOND ( HE>+ & TELL+ /ORIES & :O SP5D _! "DS ON ANY?+ T TURNS UP >E CALL$ GOSSIPS1 B N SELF-9DULG5T1 NOR >E ^? :O >E PA9$ AT ! LOSS ( M"OY OR ( FRS4 ,TEMP].E M/ 2 3C]N$ ) BODILY PL1SURES1 B N ALL EV5 ( ^!2 = ^? :O DELIE CALL$ NEI TEMP]ATE NOR SELF- 9DULG5T2 YET X WD SEEM POSSI# 6DELI+2 NO "O CALLS ^? :O DELIE HUNGRY1 DELIK (! SELF-9DULG5T MAN2 = ^! >E OBJECTS ( APPETITE 6HM4 ,NOR IS "! 9 ANIMALS O!R ?AN MAN ANY PL1SURE 3NECT$ ) ^! S5SES1 EXCEPT 9CID5T,Y4 ,= DOGS D N DELIES1 B 9 ! EAT+ ( !M1 B ! SC5T TOLD !M ! H>ES 7 "!2 NOR DOES ! LION DELI1 & "!=E APPE>S 6DELILY HE DOES N DELIE 3C]N$ )! K9D ( PL1SURES T ! O!R ANIMALS %>E IN1 : "!=E APPE> SLAVI% & BRUTI%2 ^! >E T\* & TA/E4 ,B EV5 ( TA/E !Y APPE> 6MAKE LL OR NO USE2 =! BUSI;S ( TA/E IS ! 4CRIM9AT+ ( FLAV\RS1 : IS D"O 0W9ETA/]S & P :O S1SON DI%ES2 B !Y H>DLY TAKE PL1SURE 9 MAK+ ^! 4CRIM9,NS1 OR AT L1/ SELF-9DULG5T P D N1 B 9 ! ACTUAL 5JOY;T1 : 9 ALL CASES -ES "? T\*1 BO? 9 ! CASE ( FOOD & 9 T ( DR9K & 9 T ( SEXUAL 9T]C\RSE4 ,? IS :Y A C]TA9 G\RM& PRAY$ T 8 ?ROAT MI$ (! S5SES2 & SELF-9DULG;E WD SEEM 6BE JU/LY A MATT] ( REPROA*1 2C X ATTA*ES 6U N Z M5 B Z ANIMALS4 ,6DELI 69DIVIDUALS & ACQUIR$2 E4G4 ! APPETITE = FOOD IS NATURAL1 S9CE E "O :O IS )\T X CRAVES = FOOD OR DR9K1 & "S"TS = BO?1 &= LOVE AL 7Z ,HOM] SAYS7 IF HE IS "Y & LU/Y2 B N E "O CRAVES = ? OR T K9D ( N\RI%;T OR LOVE1 NOR =! SAME ?+S4 ,H;E S* CRAV+ APPE>S 6BE \R V [N4 ,YET X HAS ( C\RSE "S?+ NATURAL AB X2 = DI6]5T ?+S >E PL1SANT 6DI6]5T K9DS ( P1 & "S ?+S >E M PL1SANT 6E "O ?AN *.E OBJECTS4 ,N[ 9 ! NATURAL APPETITES FEW G WR;G1 & ONLY 9 "O DIREC;N1 T ( EXCESS2 = 6EAT OR DR9K :AT"E (F]S XF TILL "O IS SURFEIT$ IS 6EXCE$ ! NATURAL AM.T1 S9CE NATURAL APPETITE IS ! REPL5I%;T ( "O'S DEFICI5CY4 ,H;E ^! P >E CALL$ BELLY- GODS1 ? IMPLY+ T !Y FILL _! BELLY 2Y :AT IS "R4 ,X IS P ( 5TIRELY SLAVI% "* T 2COME L ?4 ,B ) REG>D 6! PL1SURES PECULI> 69DIVIDUALS _M P G WR;G & 9 _M WAYS4 ,= :ILE ! P :O >E ,8FOND ( S & S0' >E S CALL$ 2C !Y DELIE HATE;L71 & IF "O "\ 6DELID 6PL1SURES IS SELF-9DULG;E & IS CULPA#2 ) REG>D 6PA9S "O IS N1 Z 9 ! CASE ( C\RAGE1 CALL$ TEMP]ATE = FAC+ !M OR SELF-9DULG5T = N DO+ S1 B ! SELF9DULG5T MAN IS S CALL$ 2C HE IS PA9$ M ?AN HE "\ AT N GETT+ PL1SANT ?+S 7EV5 8 PA9 2+ CAUS$ 0PL1SURE71 &! TEMP]ATE MAN IS S CALL$ 2C HE IS N PA9$ AT ! ABS;E ( :AT IS PL1SANT & AT 8 AB/9;E F X4 ,! SELF-9DULG5T MAN1 !N1 CRAVES = ALL PL1SANT ?+S OR ^? T >E MO/ PL1SANT1 & IS L$ 0HIS APPETITE 6*OOSE ^! AT ! CO/ ( "EY?+ ELSE2 H;E HE IS PA9$ BO? :5 HE FAILS 6GET !M & :5 HE IS M]ELY CRAV+ = !M 7= APPETITE 9VOLVES PA972 B X SEEMS ABSURD 6BE PA9$ =! SAKE ( PL1SURE4 ,P :O FALL %ORT ) REG>D 6PL1SURES & DELIE H>DLY F.D2 = S* 9S5SIBIL;Y IS N HUMAN4 ,EV5 ! O!R ANIMALS 4T+UI% DI6]5T K9DS ( FOOD & 5JOY "S & N O!RS2 & IF "! IS ANY "O :O F9DS NO?+ PL1SANT & NO?+ M ATTRACTIVE ?AN ANY?+ ELSE1 HE M/ 2 "S?+ Q DI6]5T F A MAN2 ? SORT ( P]SON HAS N RCVD A "N 2C HE H>DLY O3URS4 ,! TEMP]ATE MAN O3UPIES A MI4LE POSI;N ) REG>D 6^! OBJECTS4 ,= HE NEI 5JOYS ! ?+S T ! SELF-9DULG5T MAN 5JOYS MO/-B R 4LIKES !M-NOR 9 G5]AL ! ?+S T HE %D N1 NOR ANY?+ ( ? SORT 6EXCESS1 NOR DOES HE FEEL PA9 OR CRAV+ :5 !Y >E ABS5T1 OR DOES S ONLY 6A MOD]ATE DEGREE1 & N M ?AN HE %D1 NOR :5 HE %D N1 & S ON2 B ! ?+S T1 2+ PL1SANT1 MAKE = H1L? OR = GD 3DI;N1 HE W DESIRE MOD]ATELY & Z HE %D1 & AL O!R PL1SANT ?+S IF !Y >E N H9DR.ES 6^! 5DS1 OR 3TR>Y 6:AT IS NO#1 OR 2Y 8 M1NS4 ,= HE :O NEGLECTS ^! 3DI;NS LOVES S* PL1SURES M ?AN !Y >E WOR?1 B ! TEMP]ATE MAN IS N T SORT ( P]SON1 B ! SORT ( P]SON T ! "R RULE PRESCRIBES4 #AB ,SELF-9DULG;E IS M L A VOLUNT>Y /ATE ?AN C[>DICE4 ,=! =M] IS ACTUAT$ 0PL1SURE1 ! LATT] 0PA91 ( : ! "O IS 6BE *OS5 &! O!R 6BE AVOID$2 & PA9 UPSETS & DE/ROYS ! NATURE (! P]SON :O FEELS X1 :ILE PL1SURE DOES NO?+ (! SORT4 ,"!=E SELF-9DULG;E IS M VOLUNT>Y4 ,H;E AL X IS M A MATT] ( REPROA*2 = X IS EASI] 62COME A3U/OM$ 6XS OBJECTS1 S9CE "! >E _M ?+S ( ? SORT 9 LIFE1 &! PROCESS ( HABITU,N 6!M IS FREE F DANG]1 :ILE ) T]RI# OBJECTS ! REV]SE IS ! CASE4 ,B C[>DICE WD SEEM 6BE VOLUNT>Y 9 A DI6]5T DEGREE F XS "PICUL> MANIFE/,NS2 = X IS XF PA9.S1 B 9 ^! WE >E UPSET 0PA91 S T WE EV5 ?R[ D[N \R >MS & 4GRACE \RVS 9 O!R WAYS2 H;E \R ACTS >E EV5 ?"\ 6BE D"O "U -PUL.N4 ,=! SELF- 9DULG5T MAN1 ON ! O!R H&1 ! "PICUL> ACTS >E VOLUNT>Y 7= HE DOES !M ) CRAV+ & DESIRE71 B ! :OLE /ATE IS LESS S2 = NO "O CRAVES 6BE SELF-9DULG5T4 ,! "N SELF-9DULG;E IS APPLI$ AL 6*ILDI% FAULTS2 = !Y BE> A C]TA9 RESEMBL.E 6:AT WE H BE5 3SID]+4 ,: IS CALL$ AF :1 MAKES NO DI6];E 6\R PRES5T PURPOSE2 PLA9LY1 H["E1 ! LAT] IS CALL$ AF ! E>LI]4 ,! TRANSF];E (! "N SEEMS N A BAD "O2 = T : DESIRES :AT IS BASE & : DEVELOPS QKLY "\ 6BE KEPT 9 A *A/5$ 3DI;N1 & ^! "*I/ICS 2L;G ABV ALL 6APPETITE & 6! *1 S9CE *N 9 FACT LIVE AT ! BECK & CALL ( APPETITE1 & X IS 9 !M T ! DESIRE = :AT IS PL1SANT IS /R;GE/4 ,IF1 !N1 X IS N GO+ 6BE OB$I5T & SUBJECT 6! RUL+ PR9CIPLE1 X W G 6GRT L5G?S2 = 9 AN IRR,NAL 2+ ! DESIRE = PL1SURE IS 9SATIA# EV5 IF X TRIES E S\RCE ( GRATIFIC,N1 &! EX]CISE ( APPETITE 9CR1SES XS 9NATE =CE1 & IF APPETITES >E /R;G & VIOL5T !Y EV5 EXPEL ! P[] ( CALCUL,N4 ,H;E !Y %D 2 MOD]ATE & FEW1 & %D 9 NO WAY OPPOSE ! R,NAL PR9CIPLE-& ? IS :AT WE CALL AN OB$I5T & *A/5$ /ATE-& Z ! * %D LIVE AC 6! DIREC;N ( 8 TUTOR1 S ! APPETITIVE ELE;T %D LIVE AC 6R,NAL PR9CIPLE4 ,H;E ! APPETITIVE ELE;T 9 A TEMP]ATE MAN %D H>MONIZE )! R,NAL PR9CIPLE2 =! NO# IS ! M>K AT : BO? AIM1 &! TEMP]ATE MAN CRAVES =! ?+S 2 "\1 Z HE "\1 Z :5 HE "\2 & :5 HE "\2 & ? IS :AT R,NAL PR9CIPLE DIRECTS4 ,"H WE 3CLUDE \R A3.T ( TEMP].E4